With all those guys giving their opinion on Weavile, I'll share mine too.
I'll just give the opinion of a casual player, I'll not argue so much as I think both sides will do this better than me.
I was a strong supporter of Weavile and Genesect ban back in the time, with kinda the same arguments as the pro-ban now, insane speed, strong moves, very few SI, etc (talking only of Weavile, Genesect is not th point here). And I think it's still the case - and I think everyone agrees on that, Weavile
is strong, the question is "is it too strong/unhealthy". If you ask me to decide to vote ban or not on Weavile rn, and it'll be definitive, I'll vote ban as I think it'll allow more freedom in teambuilding without changing the tier that much - unlike a ban of Tapu Fini for example.
However, with time and experience, I've learned to deal with Weavile and I am not sure it is absolutely ban worthy - I'm kinda caught between two stools. I personally think that CB Tech set is the best one - and the one that make Weavile almost broken - as it has very few SI and insane instant power, when MGLO always led a 50/50 between clicking SD or attack immediatly - and when I've played Weavile, I always find that MGLO lacks a lot of power to OHKO stuff like that : 252 Atk Life Orb Weavile Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Tapu Lele: 247-292 (87.9 - 103.9%) -- 31.3% chance to OHKO (Triple Axel kills yea but it's kinda the same as clicking focus blast every time so it's annoying - and, to answer to mh I think it was
Dr. Phd. BJ question, I think Triple Axel accuracy is a part of Weavile being less strong as it doesn't have a reliable 120 BP Ice move).
Also, as said by
UT (I tried to tag you with UnnerfTalonflame bruh) it's not that easy to bring Weavile on a good situation on the field, and the replay he showed explains quite well how Weavile is manageable even without hard counter/if your counter is dead. Lastly, I'd like to say than, as every good threat, Weavile has different sets and it's logical to be weak to some specific threats - you can't cover anything - and in my opinion, if your team straight lose to a particular set it's a choice of building or a missbuild as you should always have
something to at least not being 6-0'd ; also, I never lost a game to Weavile and said myself at the end "the mon is broken I couldn't do anything". It was either bulding weakness, bad plays, or just long term lose and any threat in place of Weavile would have lead to the same result.
This was my part to say that Weavile is less broken and unmanageable that people think - and I was thinking like them at the beginning, but I think it's possible to adapt ourselves to deal with Weavile as with any threat. However, I think that Weavile restrains the teambuilding a lot and probably more than any other threat, because of amazing speed and - and it's an important point imo that has not been said - the fact that Dark and Ice STABs do not have immunities. Barraskewda is super fast but you can add a Desolate Land/Water Absorb mon to block him. Same with Blacephalon. Same with Thunderbolt from Koko, Flare Blitz from Talon, Expanding Force from Azelf, etc... The other fast threats can be almost completely hard blocked - Weavile cannot. And its speed and access to priority make it less manageable than stuff like Blace or Terrak - you can accept to sacrifice something, then rk with your scarf Lando or your Latios, etc... That's why I think Weavile is probably the more restrictive mon in the meta as it is really hard to say "I don't have a counter but I can sac something and rk" - even if you can ofc find middleground, offensive counterplays, etc
To conclude, I think Weavile is a bit unhealthy for the tier, and more because it's restrictive than because it's "broken", but I'm fine with it in because I think it's more manageable than most of people think.
I am
really bad at expressing my opinion, especially in English, so I hope I didn't say too much bullshit, anyway that was just my opinion on how
I manage to deal with Weavile when building and playing, and I ask you guys to express your opinion here as, no matter in which side you are, it is annoying for everyone I think to have small discussions in the discord everytime about Weavile without really understanding each other so let's get it straight once and for all.
Stay safe, take care, love on y'all