Very overdue, but I'm finally here with the promised sub review! These are just my thoughts on your submissions, how they could be improved, and if they're in danger of getting vetoed. Keep in mind that these are just my opinions, so, unless it's a veto warning, you don't have to take my advice, just consider it
S0meguy said::incineroar:
Pokémon: Incineroar
Category: Dark
New Type: Fire/Fighting
Stats: 95 HP / 120 ATK / 90 DEF / 80 SPC/ 65 SPE
New Moves: Heavy slam.
Removed Moves: Leech life, thunder punch & everything from the other gens.
Competitive Overview: Incineroar and Arcanine are essentially two sides of the same coin, they are both bulky fire types with 80 special and +100 attack that represent domestic animals; what sets them apart is that Incineroar gives up 30 points in speed to get more bulk, better movepool and uh...a better typing?
Set
-Low kick/Double Kick/Submission
-Sword dance
-Earthquake
-Fire Blast/Body Slam/Hyper Beam
What makes Incineroar so interesting is that it can be unpredictable, nobody wants to switch in on a boosted Incineroar with right moves and most of OU is either one or two shotted by it depending on the amount of SDs used beforehand.
It's still a fire/fighting type though, so beware of Psychics and surf.
:skarmory:
Pokémon: Skarmory
Category: Steel
New Type: Flying/Fighting
Stats: 70 HP / 80 ATK / 130 DEF / 60 SPC / 75 SPE
New Moves: Egg bomb, Heavy slam, Harden, Body slam, Hyper beam and soft boiled (yes, you read that right)
Removed Moves: Rock slide + anything that wasn't in RBY.
Competitive Overview: Skarmory has a very unique typing and niche in RBY OU, it's the only pokemon in the whole game that is immune to EQ and neutral to Rock slide as well as being the single best user of heavy slam, making it the perfect counter to the likes of Rhydon and Steelix.
It can also OHKO Chansey with Heavy slam after a single harden (i never thought i'd say this) and has a 49% chance of doing the same to Tauros.
Relevant moves
-Drill peck
-Heavy slam
-Body slam
-Hyper beam
-Soft boiled
-Taunt
-Harden
-Agility
-Sword dance
There's no standard set for Skarmory, it can play wall, hyper offense or both, unfortunately Skarmory is held back by its poor stats outside of deffense, it doesn't want to be paralized at all and Taunt users just ruin its day.
:diancie:
Pokémon: Diancie
Category: Fairy
New Type: Rock/Ice
Stats: 65 HP / 100 ATK / 100 DEF / 100 SPC / 50 SPC
New Moves: Earthquake, Heavy slam, Ice beam and Blizzard.
Removed Moves: Non gen 1 moves.
Competitive Overview: Normal and Ice resistance? With Rock slide, blizzard and AMNESIA on top!?
Set
-Rock Slide
-Blizzard
-Amnesia
-Earthquake/Heavy slam/Rest
Diancie is a very threatning pokemon in RBY OU, some say it's basically Tobybro but better, however, unlike Slowbro Diance has many physical weaknesses, so ANYTHING that runs a fighting move is either faster, strong enough to OHKO or both
:incineroar: A bit odd, but it could certainly function as a lategame cleaner with SD or a Fire Spin pivot that can force out Normals, though it does massively compete with Scizor in the former role and Spiritomb in the latter role, so I'm not too sure if this'll be viable, but it's not that bad. Also, you can definitely let it keep Leech Life, it's only 20 BP this gen. Same goes for Thunder Punch, it's pretty weak on this and only useful for Slowbro, so they should be okay to keep
:skarmory: Another kinda weird one that I don't think will end up being too viable because of its atrocious typing and low special bulk, meaning that it can't setup on or beat anything other than Non-Ice move Lax, Rhydon, or Steelix. Its movepool makes it just about decent I suppose
:diancie: This one is a bit spooky, as Rock/Ice is a pretty amazing typing in Gen 1, so with this having an great typing, great moves, good stats, and Amnesia is simply too much. Remove Amnesia and this'll be a pretty good sub, being a decent Ice-type that can break Chansey
Copen said::ss/tapu koko:
Pokémon: Tapu Koko
Category: Fairy
New Type:
Stats: 80 / 95 / 80 / 95 / 125 [475 BST]
New Moves: Heavy Slam, Recover, Submission
Removed Moves: Thunderbolt, Thunder, Thunder Punch
Competitive Overview: Fast fighting type that can shutdown opposing status with taunt and spread para itself with twave while abusing natures madness.
Full Movepool
Agility, Double Team, Fly, Hyper Beam, Light Screen, Mirror Move, Nature's Madness, Quick Attack, Reflect, Recover, Rest, Roar, Screech, Sky Attack, Steel Wing, Submission, Substitute, Swift, Taunt, Thunder Wave, Taunt, Withdraw
:ss/Yveltal:
Pokémon: Yveltal
Category: Dark
New Type:
Stats: 126 / 131 / 99 / 131 / 99 [586 BST]
New Moves: Acid, Strange Steam
Removed Moves:
Competitive Overview: A cover legend able to rival the power of Mewtwo with its expansive movepool and great typi- oh wait nevermind.
Full Movepool
Acid, Body Slam, Cut, Disable, Double Team, Dream Eater, Fly, Gust, Hyper Beam, Psychic, Razor Wind, Rest, Rock Slide, Sky Attack, Snarl, Steel Wing, Strange Steam, Substitute, Swift, Taunt, Toxic
:ss/Stakataka:
Pokémon: Stakataka
Category:Steel
New Type:
Stats: 61 / 111 / 181 / 31 / 13 [397 BST]
New Moves: Self-Destruct
Removed Moves: N/A
Competitive Overview: Very physically fat normal resist that can pivot with Bind.
Full Movepool
Bide, Bind, Body Slam, Double-Edge, Earthquake, Harden, Light Screen, Mega Kick, Reflect, Rest, Rock Slide, Rock Throw, Self-Destruct, Stomp, Substitute, Tackle, Take Down, Toxic
:tapu koko: Not really sure how to feel about this one. On one hand, it has an absolutely insane movepool with good stats, broken move Recover, and STAB for the Big 3, Nature's Madness, decent bulk for what it is, and TWave. But on the other, it's a pure Fighting-type that gets abused by every Psychic and Ghost + Steelix + Zapdos. Overall, I think it'll be decent enough as is, as weird as it is. Could be a little annoying to manuever around with TWave, Madness, and Fighting STAB, though
:yveltal: Love this thing. Not sure if it'll actually be viable at all though, since all it has are bulk, Steel Wing, and Psychic
:stakataka: Seems like a weird intersection between Rhydon and Steelix that'll end up being worse than both. Comparable to Golem, but Golem might also be better than it. Might suggest changing its type to make it more desirable in some way. Also worth noting that this does get Heavy Slam
Ema Skye said:Pokémon: Skarmory
Category: Steel
New Type: Rock/Flying
Stats: 65/80/140/70/70 (425)
New Moves: Snarl, Heavy Slam
Removed Moves:
Competitive Overview: Fat Aerodactyl definitely finds value in the tier as a Normal resist and a Ground immunity. SD potentially goes hard.
Skarmory
- Drill Peck / Steel Wing
- Snarl / Rock Slide
- Heavy Slam
- Rest / Swords Dance
full movepool
Agility, Counter, Cut, Double Team, Double-Edge, Drill Peck, Flash, Fly, Fury Attack, Leer, Mimic, Peck, Rest, Roar, Rock Slide, Sand Attack, Sky Attack, Slash, Substitute, Swift, Swords Dance, Toxic, Whirlwind, Wing Attack
Pokémon: Azumarill
Category: Fairy
New Type: Normal/Water
Stats: 100/60/80/80/50 (370)
New Moves: Heavy Slam
Removed Moves:
Competitive Overview: Amnesia user in the vein of Slowbro. Ends up being walled by Waters without DEdge, but it’s bulk could also allow it to fit Sing to stop them.
Azumarill
- Amnesia
- Blizzard
- Hydro Pump
- Double Edge/Sing
Pokémon: Houndoom
Category: Dark
New Type: Fire
Stats: 75/90/50/120/115 (450)
New Moves:
Removed Moves: Snarl, Fire Spin, Super Fang
Competitive Overview: An offensive Fire in the vein of Moltres. Has the speed for Tauros and the special. Based on a discord chat about ‘what if Arcanine was good?’
Houndoom
- Fire Blast
- Sludge
- Double Edge
- Taunt
:skarmory: I like this take on Skarmory, though it might also suffer from having a poor defensive type that makes it tough to setup or wall much. At least being a Normal resist that immediately threatens the Big 3 gives it a few more entry opportunities, but I fear that its Special bulk is really gonna hold it back. Might wanna see it in action before deciding that it needs more Special though. juoean in the Discord suggested adding Body Slam to threaten paras when the Normals you wall switch out and I like that idea too
:azumarill: I like it. Very similar to
Eve's Slate 1 Azumarill sub, though this one has higher Special and lower Attack. I think I do like Eve's version a bit more, but either way I like the idea of Azu as an Amnesia mon, something we've somehow managed to not add yet
:houndoom: Looks kinda insane on paper, but should be perfectly fine with it being just a fast Moltres without Agility or Fire Spin or Flying STAB at the end of the day. Also, if you're giving it Sludge, make sure to to add that to the New Moves section
PalpitoadChamp said::ss/tapu-bulu:
Pokemon: Tapu Bulu
Category: Fairy
New Type: Grass
Stats: 70/85/115/110/75
New Moves: Razor Leaf
Removed Moves: Swords Dance
Competitive Overview: Tapu Bulu is a Grass-type that uses Nature's Madness combined with Razor Leaf or Mega Drain for STAB and HB & Snarl/RSlide for good damage. Also boasts Leech Seed, Taunt, & Reflect for utility. Nature's Madness is just really good to the point where Super Fang gave Raticate a niche in normal play. Something like that given to a good pokemon makes for a fairly good pokemon.
:tapu bulu: Seems alright, Nature's Madness is a lot better on a mon with Hyper Beam or Fleur Cannon since if you can 2HKO something with Nature's Madness -> Special move, you could've just used that Special move twice, so it only eases prediction. 110 Spc + Razor Leaf is pretty high and it is really bulky, though it doesn't have much else going for it
Regic Boat said::ss/duraludon:
Pokémon: Duraludon
Category: Steel
New Type: Rock / Dragon
Stats: 70 / 95 / 115 / 110 / 85
New Moves: Earthquake, Ice Beam, Flamethrower
Removed Moves: none
Competitive Overview: swords dance sweeper or paraspreader, having sadly its only STAB be Snarl, wich isnt too bad since its offensive stats are good, and its defensive stats as well. it has alright coverage in ice, electric and fire, and earthquake if you go solely physical. Heavy Slam also gos off its highest stat, defense, wich hits 115, wich is quite nice. (quickly after posting this i realized it got Slash, wich i dont think would be run, and rock slide, wich is only 5 BP over snarl anyway and has 90% acc instead of 100%.)
:duraludon: This would probably be a pretty great mon, kinda like a better Kabutops with a slightly worse defensive typing trading being weak to Electric for being weak to Blizzard. With that in mind, I'd recommend removing Thunder Wave, since it's stats and typing are so good that it can spread it very easily and be threatening with all of its other options
And that's all! With this, voting will finally start in
24 hours! See you then!