Sub Feedback! Note that this isn't the veto post, but intended to get you thinking about your sub.
Before I start, I want to begin with one big thought I ask that you take with your subs: RBY does not need 'fixing'. It's been played for over 20 years, which I think is proof enough that it doesn't need fixing. Your subs should be more about exploring new things in the tier (I suggest looking at the RBY OMs like RBY STABmons, other RBY Pet Mods (Rose Red Iris Blue, Kanto Expansion Pak, MG1 and RBY Cap) and the Tradebacks meta to get some ideas.
RBY's Discord server is a treasure trove of information, and their #pet-mods channel serves as where we discuss the mod. It's the best place to get real time feedback on your stuff or to bounce ideas off of each other (and from my experience, they are one the friendliest Discord communities).
I-Deepblue-I said:Move: Crafty Shield
Type: Psychic
Power: --
Accuracy: --
PP: 24
Effect: While the user remains active, it becomes immune to the secondary effects of attacking moves. This effect can be removed by Haze.
Distribution: (:staryu:?) :kangaskhan: :porygon::karrablast: :scizor: :tapu_koko: :dratini: :omanyte: :pinsir: :ralts:
Justification: Handy Body Slam immunity, helps many Pokemon become more reliable as physical walls with that annoying Body Slam paralysis chance taken away, also allows stuff like Staryu to stay in against Alakazam without fearing Psychic drops.
This is cool, however, I'm not sure how much this is going to be relevant in the meta, as many will find it challenging to slot it in their moveset, especially the Normals like Kangaskhan (since they're already immune to Body Slam). Though a Normal with high special may find value in it (Altaria?). You're looking for Pokemon with good mixed bulk that can afford the moveslot (and the turn) needed to setup this move. The challenge is that when they switch into the BSlam, they risk the para and then the move kinda becomes a dead slot. If you can find something that would use it, be sure to add it, but I'm not sure that Pokemon exists. Something like Hydreigon or Yveltal, but those are weak to Psychic so they don't want to stay in anyways. Maybe the Legendary Birds? Cloyster?
Move: Magnet Bomb
Type: Electric
Power: 130
Accuracy: 100%
PP: 5
Effect: The user faints after using this move, unless the target's substitute was broken by the damage. The target's Special is halved during damage calculation
Distribution: :jolteon: :magnemite: :geodude: :onix: :mr_mime:
Justification: Good move to bait in and remove the likes of Starmie, Cloyster and Chansey, but just like Explosion, has clear counters that can be used to play around it so it can't be spammed willy nilly.
I don't really like this. While it's not broken (Jolteon Double Kick crits can beat Chansey without saccing the Jolteon), the learnset would need to be super specific to not break the tier because it toes a fine line as it's a matchup fish move (Electrics do really well against teams lacking a Ground, this just makes it more apparent). It is kinda neat on Mr. Mime though, and its an interesting Cloyster lure for Golem.
Move: False Surrender
Type: Bug
Power: 30
Accuracy: 100%
PP: 16
Effect: This move nearly always goes first. (Quick Attack priority).
Distribution: :pinsir: :karrablast: :paras: :meowth: :drowzee: :krabby:
Justification: Good finisher for generally slow Pokemon that can also take Psychics by surprise.
On paper, this seems a bit ridiculous, even though it's a 30BP Bug move. This allows Escavalier to operate without its biggest flaw, and it actually uses Tauros/Snorlax as setup fodder to sweep the rest of their teams. Pinsir is in a similar spot, with the option of Binding to put targets in range. Parasect's Fleur Cannon gives it a big nuke with SD. I'm generally of the opinion that this is a bit superfluous, given that the Fleur Cannon buff is a very sizeable boost for the type, and that the SD Bug mons really have no switchins aside from Moltres and Spiritomb.
S0meguy said:Move: Flash canon
Type: Dragon
Power: 95
Accuracy: 100
PP: 15
Effect: 10% chance to lower the opponent's speed.
Distribution: :onix: :dratini: :deino: :charmander: :larvitar: :growlithe: :aerodactyl: :gyarados: :flareon: :horsea:
Justification: Dragon pulse but with an uncommon effect.
Dragon moves are kinda weird, because they are unresisted this gen and so provide perfect neutral coverage in one move. It's an upgraded Normal-type move that runs off the other attacking stat. This move has me wary for that reason. It simplifies a lot of movesets, especially with its high BP, and removes their need to run Normal coverage assuming they have good special (which most of these do). I honestly don't think there's a place for a Dragon move in this meta unless it has some drawback (like Outrage) or is low BP with a cool effect to warrant use (like Dragonbreath). A BP nerf to 80 will make this more tolerable.
Move: Beat Up
Type: Fighting
Power: 80
Accuracy: 100
PP: 15
Effect: 10% chance to lower the foe's defense
Distribution: Everything that learns submission.
Justification: Same as my previous sub.
This is a sub that I think is trying to fix something in RBY. There are good Fighting moves in RBY, they're just on awful Pokemon. High Jump Kick slices through the Normals as one of the strongest Fighting moves. Rolling Kick has phenomenal synergy with paralysis (which is on every team), creating a ~55% chance to prevent a paralyzed opponent from acting. Both are just only on a Pokemon that dies if you breath on it. As bad as Submission is, it does find niche value on some things (not so much now with Heavy Slam in this tier on things like Poliwrath, or on Gengar to lure Chansey to KO it with Explosion). Fighting's flaw is its defensive profile: it has no defensive value outside of Rock Slide/Snarl switches and most teams have two or three mons that resist its STAB with a move to hit it super effectively. A move won't fix that, no matter how good it is, and so I think this meta needs to think about how to design a Pokemon to work around those defensive limitations. This added effect is the cherry on top, and the 10% chance to secure the 2HKO is rather meta warping (bringing in a Fighting resist that gets hit by a defense drop usually means Hyper Beam now KOs), so a different effect is needed. This will be
vetoed under its current iteration.
Also, please post the distribution and justification from your old sub so that we don't have to look back to reference it. Saves us some time which is appreciated.
Move: Disarming voice
Type: Bug
Power: 75
Accuracy: 100
PP: 15
Effect: 10% chance to confuse the opponent
Distribution: All bug types + :zubat: :jigglypuff: :ralts:
Justification: Literally signal beam and bugs deserve an actual move.
Same thing with False Surrender. We have an actual Bug move (Fleur Cannon), and its kind of insane. Bug isn't terrible, it just has terrible Pokemon. We actually had to nerf Scizor (a Bug/Fighting mon) because its movepool and stats were too much for the tier to switch into. Bug's problem in RBY are the Pokemon: two Bugs are Poison (a type that actively makes the Pokemon worse defensively), three have no Bug STAB and the last has 30 speed (one of our FutureProofing bugs is even slower!). Design a good Bug type and things can fall into place, otherwise you're designing tools that aren't really needed (Pinsir is almost OU viable without Bug STAB and this probably breaks it. Scyther might be in a similar spot.). Lastly, both Yoshi and I are really not fans of RNG based side effects like confusion and would appreciate a different added effect.
Yoshiblaze said:Move: Fiery Wrath
Type:
Power: --
Accuracy: 90%
PP: 15
Effect: Burns the foe
Distribution:
:moltres::arcanine::ninetales::gardevoir::spiritomb::charizard::rapidash::magmar::weezing::whimsicott::mew: (
:gengar:?)
Justification: Burn is pretty awful in Gen 1, so having a move that just does that is pretty unimpressive, but burn still has some merit, notably neutering Tauros in case a lot of your team gets paralyzed, which makes it absolutely certain that it can't clean up, and being able to burn physical attackers that are immune to Thunder Wave or don't care about being slower like Steelix, Rhydon, and Snorlax. Just be careful using it so you don't accidentally burn a Chansey
Very interesting idea! I am a little wary of it as a panic button on fast mons like Whims/Gar, but it's burn (which is bad) and it needs applications to warrant using. I'm not sure what all you would actually want burned other than Tauros (who you'd also want to paralyze), as paralysis has more universal application. I imagine we'll keep hashing this out on the discord.
Move: Metal Sound
Type:
Power: --
Accuracy: --
PP: 10
Effect: Shares HP of user and target equally. (Pain Split effect)
Distribution:
:magneton::weezing::ninetales::chansey::escavalier:(
:gardevoir:?)
Justification: (Resub) First things first, the flavor for this is that both Pokemon are subjected to a grating noise and thus they share the pain. Flimsy for sure, but it's there. Anyway, Pain Split is a super powerful effect in a generation dominated by two high HP Pokemon, essentially being a Super Fang against Chansey and Snorlax sometimes. This is huge for Special Attackers that'd otherwise struggle to break through Chansey and weaker attackers that can't KO Snorlax through its Rests and Reflects. Also provides an alternative form of recovery, making bringing Lax and Chansey in dangerous. However, with such a powerful effect, we do have to be very careful with what gets it, so I opted for lower ranked/unranked mons that are mostly Physical Attackers, leaving out some future gen Pain Split users like Starmie, Gengar, and Spiritomb since it could be too powerful on them, especially the latter since it already abuses Lax so well. Also would be very funny to give to Chansey, since 99% of the time you're healing the foe. Biggest benefactors from the list are Magneton, who can consistently chip Chansey and Rhydon/Steelix down until it can eventually break through them with Gear Up boosts, Ninetales, who can be a menace with Fire Spin + Metal Sound, and Escavalier, who can run Substitute to avoid paralysis from Body Slam and then heal off the damage later
I'm not sure where this fits in the meta. Obviously the big thing is that it has PP equal to Softboiled for stalling Chansey, but I think Chansey stalls you out faster. That said, I think Jynx right now is showing why giving special breakers tools to break Chansey easily is kind of a problem, because nothing else really walls the onslaught of special breakers if Chansey is easy to remove. I feel like right now we should be working on preserving Chansey's place in the meta.
Move: Spirit Break
Type:
Power: 60
Accuracy: 100
PP: 15
Effect: Lowers the foe's Attack by 1 stage
Distribution:
:dragonite::seadra::gyarados::arcanine::aerodactyl::charizard::lapras::altaria: (
:hydreigon:?)
Justification: Might scrap this, but for now, this is a counterpart to Snarl, a physical move that lowers Special, being a special move that lowers Attack. Obviously Snarl has a stronger effect since it essentially lowers two stats, but Spirit Break is still a nice deterrent to physical attackers while not having to status them with Fire moves, allowing you to both paralyze them and cripple their Attack stat. Also, it's a STAB move for Dragonite, but I doubt it uses it. Arcanine and Aerodactyl having both Spirit Break and Snarl is funny
I'm not quite sure where this fits in the meta. I know I mentioned with Flash Cannon that Dragon moves are kinda weird, and both Dragon moves here are opposites of each other. I don't think most of the Pokemon that get the move would use it (Seadra/Arcanine are bad; they need coverage for Waters and Double-Edge actually outdamages Spirit Break on both of them. The rest don't have the moveslots to afford it.) Hydreigon could likely use it, but it becomes too annoying to break with Twave + Recover and so probably won't get it. I feel like the potential for the effect is definitely here, but I'm not sure if we have the Pokemon that could use this yet (maybe on some Bugs since they come in on the Normal's EQ).
Subs close in about 48 hours. See you then, and then on Saturday for the tour!