Did you even read my post? I wasn't talking about the anime.
I'm talking about the concept behind what Leon represented. Leon was presented as "strongest Champion ever". Period. True? False? Doesn't matter. Leon was shown to us as essentially a mirror of the player, the never-defeated trainer (the whole Charmander thing is anime exlcusive, not saying it didn't happen but there's quite a difference between losing a battle when you're a kid and never losing a battle when you became a dedicate pro).
Now, let's say they make future Champions all "the strongest Champion ever". Well, that just completely undermines Leon's purpose, possibly his entire identity. It also then creates a power creep problem where, now that each Champion has to trump the previous, why should we care about the current Champion's strength reputation when we know next gen there is going to be a Champion even stronger? And this isn't like DBZ where you have to care about the current villain cause, even though next arcs is gonna be stronger, the current one is still trying to kill everyone. No, this is a Pokemon battling competition, the stakes are a title and that's it.
You sound like a jerk, don’t go to that level with me again or I will level the playing field and sink to your level for just enough time to post a scathing reply… Got it?
Good!
Now onto your post,
You mentioned
”Leon was introduced to us as the GREATEST Champion of all time. Undefeatable. A hero to all the people in Galar. He's essentially what the player character is but as an NPC. And when Rose is arrested and the player takes the Champion title, Leon becomes the Galar League Chairman. Cool, interesting idea, execution is questionable but Leon is pretty genuine in his role.
And now we've moved onto the next gen and have been introduced to the next Champion: Geeta. Alright... so... is she supposed to be the strongest trainer ever now? Yeah, you see the problem now, when you introduced the GREATEST Champion of all time, any other Champion you now introduce is gonna need to stand out in another way ASIDE from being a good trainer. And Geeta's twist is that... she's the chairman of the Paldea League... so she's really no different from Leon in that regard aside she's at the moment holding both positions (though with how involved Leon was with the League and how close he was to Rose you could say Leon was always just one step away from being the Chairman).”
The answer is simple, he is no longer Champion, so cannot be the “GREATEST”, Bc even though he may have been “of all time”, that is never guaranteed Bc “all time” should read as “so far”, otherwise the current player of SW/SH would never be able to defeat him and become the new champion, surpassing him.
That also does not negate my own point; that Greeta may have received her champion title somewhere between he earns his title but before he loses it- which mean Leon was the best at the time of the game saying so, but clearly not the best by the time the player wins the game and takes that title of champion (and simultaneously “all time”) away from him. Bc “All time” means past, present, and future.
Just like Red is considered the best trainer ever when Gen 1 concludes, but then by Gen 2, Gold defeats him in Mt. Silver as the true boss, even better than Lance. So suddenly, Red doesnt feel so powerful after you win against his level 80 Pikachu.
My point is not wrong; the game‘s use of “all-time” is, Bc the very person they tell it to (the player) ends up becoming “greater” than Leon by the game’s end. Seemingly, so can Greeta.
All time is used as if it means past, present, and future in the real world, but in Pokémon it just means past, and present, so it should be taken as “so far”.
Therefore, in Pokemon, any future generation’s Champion is not prevented in becoming Greater than Leon, just Bc of the titles given to Leon, Bc as the game ends, so ends his undefeated winning streak, his title, and his “greatest of all time” reputation.