When the meta was new:
“This Tera mechanic is kinda awesome, but it’s probably gonna break stuff like Kartana and other things that are less obvious, we saw it happen with Z crystals too, but this can also be used defensively”
no one knew exactly to what degree obviously, but this was obvious from the start.
—
but it feels like decisions go from liberal to conservative on the fly.
some decisions seem so liberal,
“let’s try magearna and Chien-pao , even tho we have little reason to think they’d be any more balanced outside of a cool new resist profile magearna brings to the meta, and Chien Pappy can’t even 2HKO magearna with its STABs, forcing mag usage even higher on every team is a small price to pay for making it possible to deal with Chien-Pao. It’s all good they can be banned quickly anyway”
Side note about eleki
eleki isn’t included in this, even tho it was clearly worse than both of the above. This is because to be fair, there was no precedent outside of Natdex that demonstrated eleki was broken. And Natdex is allegedly invalid precedent.
“
Tera water Volcarona nukes skeledirge, heatran and more, and all it takes is a small price of blowing your Tera slot and using an otherwise useless Terablast! This is grounds for a quick ban and skipping all precedent because Volcarona has been discussed for many gens as being borderline broken”
Some decisions seem so conservative
“we cannot discuss suspecting terastalization for at least some months, even tho the vote on restricting it was so close, in fact the closest ever. This is not even on the cards. More important fish to fry here”
—
Just some comments, not an attack on anything or anyone. Very grateful for a good conversation and a very fun game with fun metas since forever. It’s just fun to pick at things, especially because there’s this idea that things “must be a certain way”, and then you still get “on the fly” things happening like the kings rock treatment.
conservative: there is a high burden of proof on items to demonstrate that they break too many pokemon
liberal: let’s ban kings rock, it turned cloyster into cheese, and nothing else misses it anyway
like , I get why the decision was made, and am completely OK with it. But this shows that everything is possible. It doesn’t need to be so fixed.