I hate how the modern playerbase is so pro-universal ban on more recent mechanics, especially uncompetitive ones. Serene Grace is an uncompetitive ability, but only Shaymin-Sky was too problematic with it. Other Serene Grace Pokémon like Jirachi and Togekiss are still uncompetitive, but have sufficient counterplay that banning the entire ability was not needed. When Swagger was a problem on multiple Pokémon, only the move was banned. Confusion as a whole wasn't even though it is still uncompetitive, especially when it had a 50% proc chance. This kind of tiering has been forgotten in recent years. There are different severities of uncompetitiveness, and all forms of RNG have some sort of counterplay (some more than others), whether it be in-game and when teambuilding. Viable RNG =/= no counterplay RNG. Only the extreme ones should be banned, and they should be addressed individually first before considering a full mechanic ban.
I also noticed that people are so biased when defending "traditional hax" (Scald, Flame Body, Serene Grace, paralysis, etc.) because they have been an accepted part of the metagame for a long time. Meanwhile, the more recent uncompetitive elements (which not only includes new RNG mechanics like Dire Claw, but also old ones that have started seeing minor relevancy in recent years like Quick Claw and King's Rock) aren't held to the same standards. Instead of
starting with a base definition on what makes an RNG element uncompetitive enough to be banned, they are just
observing qualities that "traditional hax" and Quick Claw have and using Quick Claw's unique attributes as grounds to ban the item while conveniently ignoring or making excuses for the advantages and unfairness of "traditional hax". Their stance on what makes certain RNG elements "ok" are based on elements that have already been accepted in the metagame, and they aren't even doing that consistent a job at it. This kind of reasoning also makes their standards more prone to bias. What's worse is that some of these people have probably never used or battled against Quick Claw because some of their arguments are straight up incorrect like saying Quick Claw has no counterplay or is free RNG, which have been debunked by some people here only for those arguments to be dismissed or downplayed by some.
If I switch Tapu Bulu or any physical Grass-type into a Water-type and get burned, it's my fault for risking the burn. Special attackers have Surf while physical attackers have Liquidation, and both are about as relevantly distributed as Scald. But sure keep pretending Scald has "competitive" value when Alomomola and Quagsire use Scald as their STAB over Liquidation.
If I use Kartana or Kingambit and get statused by Static or Flame Body, it's my fault for clicking a contact move. This scenario is even worse than the Scald one because at least you can predict turns your opponent doesn't Scald. You can't just tell Pokémon like Kartana to not click a contact move. How exactly did some people justify this? "Static and Flame Body only procs on certain attacks unlike Quick Claw." Yes because I totally use Zapdos to check special attackers and it's totally fair for Kartana to run Flash Cannon to avoid Static...
Scald and friends can be played around the same way Quick Claw can. If people can tell me to not use Tapu Bulu as my only Water-type check or to be careful around Zapdos when using Kartana, then I can tell them to stop using Weavile to revenge kill a low HP Melmetal without scouting its item or dropping it to Ice Shard range. You still have other options like Lando-T, Corviknight, Moltres, Zapdos as other options if you don't want to risk the RNG. People have discussed the counterplays/opportunity costs of Quick Claw in this thread a bunch, and whether you dismiss it or not, those counterplays/opportunity costs are as relevant as Scald or Static's counterplays/opportunity costs/method of activations.
You can't be pro-Scald and anti-Quick Claw with these arguments. Either learn to play and stop whining about Quick Claw, whine about Scald and Quick Claw, or find good arguments that isolate Quick Claw as a more extreme form of uncompetitive. The Scald vs Quick Claw conversation basically goes like this:
Spoiler
"Scald has X qualities. You can counter Scald with water immunities or Pokémon that don't really care about burns. You so have to use a moveslot and a turn for Scald. Quick Claw doesn't have those since every turn you move is affected by Quick Claw."
"But Quick Claw has Y qualities. It takes up an item slot, so they sacrifice a boosting or defensive item. A Quick Claw proc is also sometimes inconsequential when it activates in a switch, priority, or slower Pokémon. In fact, tanky Pokémon are essentially fighting itemless Pokémon since they don't care about speed. Quick Claw also has to activate multiple times to get its worth since a lot of the time it activates on useless turns, unlike Scald where it only needs to activate once for permanent impact. It can also be knocked off.
"X is acceptable because I said so, unlike Y which I don't find sufficient enough. RNG burns are acceptable hax because burns are an accepted part of the meta, but RNG priority is not despite priority being just as accepted as burns because reasons. Quick Claw also has no relevant metagame impact so nothing of value would be lost."
Compare this to Swagger arguments back in the day:
Spoiler
"Swagger is commonly paired with Prankster, T-Wave, and Sub to maximize RNG and disregard speed, which also allows the user to invest more in bulk. Most relevant Swagger users also have Foul Play to avoid being too passive. Swagger is especially punishing for special attackers as they don't benefit from the attack boost and essentially experience a 45% chance of hitting themselves the moment they are sent out against Prankster Swagger users. And if the 50% confusion chance wasn't enough, parafusion has a 62.5% chance of no action. Counterplay is limited because T-Wave has few immunities and is a permanent status condition, while confusion has even less immunities despite being temporary. And thanks to Prankster, whatever switches in just gets statused again. Even if RNG doesn't go your way, you still have a paralyzes/confused opponent. All this for a not so high opportunity cost since T-Wave, Swagger, and Foul Play are all good moves".
This is how you argue for a non-Pokémon ban, even on uncompetitive elements. Sleep in gen 5 or Shaymin-Sky vs. Serene Grace are also good examples. Marshadow can viably use Swagger in gen 7, but people aren't pointing fingers at Swagger. Even anti-Scalders in gens 5 and 6 had better arguments than most recent anti-Quick Claw posts. Bring back this form of tiering.
If Sand Attack starts seeing legitimate and viable 1% use in modern times, there is a very good chance for some to beg for a Sand Attack ban by nitpicking its unique qualities before resorting to "it's a purely luck-based strategy that has no relevant metagame impact" arguments instead of playing around it (assuming they even see it). Thank goodness Jirachi and Togekiss were released in earlier generations because if they were released now, they won't have their status as "accepted parts of the metagame we learned to play around" and recency bias would very likely force Serene Grace to banned as a whole for the sins of Shaymin-Sky.
The only thing that would convince me of a Quick Claw ban without banning other luck-based elements is if Quick Claw alone has shown itself to be too RNG-based, all-or-nothing, uncounterable, or has a massively skewerd risk/reward factor. And while I still disagree with a Quick Claw ban, Delibird Heart's Quick Claw spam team is enough for me to at the very least accept the decision if Quick Claw gets banned. The consequence of this RNG isn't as extreme or biased towards one side and can still be played around (which is why I disagree with the Quick Claw ban), but it does make up for it by having
an absurd amount of presence compared to other forms of RNG. I'm just glad that someone was innovative enough with Quick Claw unlike last generation where there was barely experimentation or even encounters with the item. I did use Quick Claw last generation on walls like Ferrothorn and Toxapex to punish fast HDB VoltTurn users and never found it to be too extreme, but the thought of mass spamming it to bulky attackers apart from Melmetal or Slowbro-G never crossed my mind.
Other more general thoughts on tiering policy:
- Unless there is a ban on luck items or flinching, Cloyster deserves the Skymin treatment. Preserve King's Rock and Serene Grace; ban the abusers. Both are fast and hit hard. Cloyster is stronger but requires set up and is very all-or-nothing. Skymin has the privilege of switching out and still being useful but doesn't sweep past teams as easily.
- While I disagree with the Bright Powder ban, it falls under Evasion Clause. If there is a "luck item ban" or "priority ban", then go ahead and ban Quick Claw for consistency (along with other mechanics that false under those bans).
- While I disagree with a complete luck item ban, I understand why it might get implemented and won't complain about it. Having explicitly written premises that are simple (ex. evasion ban, OHKO ban, flinch ban, secondary effect ban) lessens discussions and arguments on technicalities and exceptions (ex. OHKO types, what flinch chance and speed tiers are acceptable for flinching). Sure there may be collateral damage on weaker forms of the mechanic, but it's a worthy price to pay to avoid spending pages discussing what percent or type of luck is ok. Still though, I think that a luck item ban at this stage when no luck item has shown to be too extreme (apart from King's Rock Cloyster) is too whiney, but at least it's simple and consistent.
- I also hate the "no relevant competitive impact" argument. It's lazy and can be applied to so many elements, luck-based or not. Rather than using intrinsic properties that a mechanic has (base power, type, RNG, how the mechanic works, strengths and weaknesses), they are using irrelevant elemements like
popularity/viability to determine whether something should stay or go. Parafusion had relevant metagame impact in gen 6. Imagine using that as ab argument for Swagger to stay. It's supposed to be the viability of counters that determines whether something should be banned.
Last comments
- I know that my posts uses Scald a lot despite Scald being non-existent in the metagame and discussion on it has died a couple pages ago. But I started writing this when Scald was being compared to Quick Claw and since I'm busy irl and dyslexic, this post got very delayed. If only OU is less active I could actually keep up with the discussions. Anyway, my point still stands since you can replace Scald with other accepted forms of RNG.
- While there has been a lot of messy arguments on Quick Claw vs. other traditional RNG elements, I have to commend
Alternator's consistent stance on RNG.
Roller K's and
DiscoDucky's
posts on
luck items are also great as they show the pros and cons of both sides. Roller K's post can make use of simple deductive reasoning (luck items are uncompetitive and deserve to be banned, x is a luck item, x should be banned) to make tiering simpler at the cost of more collateral damage. DiscoDucky takes a more individualistic approach with the "innocent until proven guilty" stance which allows for more variety at the cost of more subjectivity and debate on what constitutes "extreme RNG". There is nothing wrong with differing opinions. Supporting your opinions with FACTS and having CONSISTENCY in your views is more important. Probably missed acknowledging a few good posts but reading this thread is a chore with how much activity there is.