Given that this post is about the content I write; I don't necessarily feel that it's appropriate for me to comment on its entirety and I believe that it's up to the community as a whole to decide how they feel about my posts. But I would like to point out something that I think ant4456 and I can both agree on, at the very least. Ant is absolutely correct about this point I quoted here, and while I adore and appreciate all of the positive feedback and awesome things many people here say about my posts, I'd like to stress that the most consistently fun part of Pokemon is undergoing the fun challenge of experimentation within established meta frameworks. Every single person on this forum has the capability, and ability to develop the memory/skill to make Pokemon they love work - that's what I want to convey with my posts
"Strong Pokémon. Weak Pokémon. That is only the selfish perception of people. Truly skilled trainers should try to win with their favorites. I like your style. You understand what's important. Go on--the Champion is waiting." - Karen, Elite Four
I write my huge posts for three reasons -
- To bring up niches that I've used during my time playing the meta and to bring attention to long-forgotten or disregarded Pokemon (Karen of the Elite Four is my spirit animal basically)
- To give specialized takes on handling potent threats in the meta (like how I brought up Wigglytuff a while back as a hard Dragapult stop)
- Frankly, because they're fun and I love engaging with Smogon's community
You're all awesome, and I appreciate the discussions that we can all have about niche content in the OU meta and how we choose to elevate each other and help each other more than ever before
As a baseline, I am someone who dislikes this thread solely based on the quality of the content. Your stuff runs contrary to that, which I greatly appreciate; however, some of the content presented can come off as likewhoring more than instructive. I generally agree with the sentiment that there's a lot of Pokemon that have niches in OU and should be explored more. Kriketune is not one of them, and it has never been since it came out 17 years ago. Combine that with the additional text formatting, pictures, and memes that you add to your post, and it's easy to see why people perceive it as showboating. I personally think the backlash would go down significantly if you focused more on Pokemon that exists in like the C or D tier on the OUVR thread. You can use edge case comparisons like "Wigglytuff hard-stops Dragapult", but in the big picture it's not practical to use from a team-building perspective.
I appreciate the effort you take to explore some lesser-used Pokemon in the tier, but at the end of the day, it's still a metagame thread. Kriketune and Wigglytuff might have tools that seem usable in OU on paper, but we have historical precedence regarding their viability not just in OU but lower tiers as well. The posts don't really help further an understanding of a metagame for both seasoned and newer players.