Defensive cores in the current meta
I've been seeing a lot of people in the OM discord server struggling with building competent defensive cores in the current meta. Many of them are resorting to a very limited supply of "proven" archetypes that they can just plug in to any team alongside their offensive mons and Imposter. A great example of that is the above post about the "MARI" core of Miraidon, Arceus, Regenvest, Imposter.
In this post I'm gonna talk about how I go about building defensive cores, the flaws I see in the commonly spread around defensive cores like MARI, why building defensive cores feels so rough nowadays and what can be done about it from a tiering perspective.
What exactly is a defensive core and what does it need to do?
A defensive core is a group of 2-4 mons that serve the purpose of taking hits from opposing breakers and forcing said breakers out by threatening damage, status, pivoting into your own offensive threats or any other effect that they can't allow themselves to take.
This post is geared towards the most common type of Balanced Hackmons team, Balance / Semi-Stall. Stall teams also have primary defensive cores alongside support or specialised mons, but that isn't the subject here.
On balance teams, the defensive core is tasked with checking every possible offensive threat, which is obviously impossible in a tier with as much freedom in building, however a good defensive core will be able to check as many of these as possible, while also minimising the one-sidedness of poor matchups (in other words, even if you can't wall something, you should be able to play around it with good predictions).
However, if you limit your defensive core to only this role, you'll find opposing teams quickly wearing you down while never giving you a chance to strike back. Defensive cores must not only be able to hold off threats, but
generate momentum back to allow your offensive mons to make progress against the opponent.
This is more important than ever in the current meta compared to previous generations of Balanced Hackmons due to the PP reduction of healing moves. Now it is easier than ever for your 8 recovers to get drained by a persistent offense. This has led to many teams resorting to Strength Sap for its increased healing and pp as well as its ability to role compress as setup counterplay against some single-stage physical boosters. However the prevalence of Sap-blocking techniques like Magic Bounce, Liquid Ooze or simply mons with extremely low attack like Chansey makes it a struggle for Sap users to stay afloat over long games, meaning in any case it is important that defensive cores not just sit around doing nothing while their hp pool is drained.
Additionally, the movepools of defensive mons are even more strained than they would otherwise be by the presence of Imposter. Imposter is able to act as a soft-check to a majority of breakers and as such most teams seek to wear it down with damage and status. However when a defensive mon is brought in, that's an opportunity for Imposter to heal up and potentially even cure its status effects. Common counterplay like trapping moves are worse than ever with the only choices being the passive Mean Look or the inconsistent (due to covert cloak) and still weak Spirit Shackle.
Defensive cores are also often tasked with including pivoting, hazard setting and removal, status control and countering opposing defense with stuff like Magic Bounce. All in all that's a lot of roles to compress into very few mons.
In summary a defensive core is given the impossible task of
- Checking the myriad offensive threats in the tier
- Threatening them back hard enough to prevent them from spamming attacks and pp stalling your healing
- Not getting sapblocked if it uses sap (which is often mandatory with the power of physical breakers and accessibility of Victory Dance)
- Setting Hazards (not mandatory and offensive mons can help here)
- Removing Hazards
- All of the above while not allowing Imposter to benefit from copying them
If this was possible in only ~3 slots + Imposter, there would be no reason for stall teams to exist, you just can't do it.
The skill in building a defensive core comes from finding where exactly you can compromise depending on what your offensive mons can do.
My method for making defensive cores.
I, and I feel like this is the case for most BH players, generally build my teams around the offensive mons first, with the defensive core serving to complement them. You can build your defensive core first, there's absolutely no problem with that and I've done it myself a couple times, but this methodology is best when you already have an idea of how your progress will be made, you just need to figure out how to survive long enough to make that progress.
I'll be using
this team I used against RoFnA for the first match of our BH money tour set as my example of the building process.
Most teams require at least one "unusual" defensive pick, most often for improofing an unconventional breaker. However in my case the concept for the team involved one of the defensive mons. I wanted to use Choice Band Ash-Greninja as a physical breaker due to its high speed and ability to OHKO most common regenvests, meaning that the answer to it will have to be a Fur Coat user, unable to recover and pivot on the same turn and most relying on Strength Sap to heal.
As such, my first question and probably the most valuable question when building your defensive core isn't "how do I wall xyz?". The question is:
When my breaker gets walled, what am I going to switch in and how am I going to avoid losing my momentum?
On a lot of teams, this is the role of the regenvest user. Regenvests are naturally good at saving turns since they don't need to spend any to heal up and they have enough free moveslots to carry pivoting moves to allow them to switch in a frailer mon safely after the opponent has already moved. Regenvests are quite good when paired with highly powerful breakers, but can fall short when you need to slowly chip down Imposter or you need to sapblock the opposing physical wall, since few good regenvests have low enough attack to sapblock and struggle to avoid giving Imposter free health and a 50/50 chance to gain momentum whenever they come in. Not to mention even if you underspeed Imposter, if they didn't click pivot as well, few breakers are able to deal with a copied regenvest, lacking the power to OHKO it or the resistance to its utility moves. As such, regenvests are not a good fit for every team.
On this team, my goal was to block Strength Sap from Fur Coat Arceus, Miraidon and Yveltal while getting my fast physical breakers in Greninja and Kartana in as often as possible to force switches with their high power and speed (both able to OHKO common offensive mons), forcing my opponent to keep on the defensive and repeatedly bring in their Fur Coaters.
Sapblocking is most often achieved with an ability like Magic Bounce or Liquid Ooze, but I wanted my sapblocker to have Magic Guard, to be able to shrug off partial trapping moves and Mortal Spin without needing a Covert Cloak. As such, I went with Blissey for its ability to take any of the special hits the common Fur Coaters dish out and natural sapblocking with its pitiful Attack stat.
With Blissey as the one member of the defensive core imposed by the team concept, I looked at all the things Blissey could and couldn't do.
Blissey can:
- Check special attackers
- Sapblock against special attacking FC users
What can Blissey
not do?
- Improof Ash-Greninja
- Improof Kartana
- Check physical attackers
- Check mixed attackers
Generally the pillar of your defensive core is going to be an Arceus forme, although this obviously isn't mandatory as teams with offensive Arceus exist. I chose Arceus-Poison as my Fur Coater because it can help against Mega Diancie. You can't really have a FC or Scales mon that can check all the mixed breakers, so generally my goal is to ensure that the overlap of my multiple FurScales users can handle them.
Arceus Poison does check most physical attackers and improofs both of my breakers, however it has the following vulnerabilities.
- Ground-Type physical attackers
- Mixed Mewtwo-Mega-X and SNR Arceus-Ghost
- Sapblocking
As such, I needed to figure out how to pick something that could handle all of those. Fur Coat Mega Audino is the best I could do there. It isn't perfect as it struggles against Steel coverage mixed MMX, but I figured it was ok given both my breakers scare out MMX and I have Imposter to soft-check it in the short term. It also helps against Yveltal, the only common FC sap user that Blissey wasn't consistent against (it could handle Revelation Dance sets but not Knock Off sets).
Since I wasn't able to easily fit removal here, I decided to go with Court Change on Blissey. Court Change bypasses the usual struggles of playing the hazard game but has trouble with Imposter coming in and spamming Court Change itself. Blissey is a fun user because it has poor defense and so, with Teleport, bringing Imposter in against it is quite the gamble, given bringing in Kartana forces it right back out and lets me make progress.
So once I had this core, I ran down the checklist of offensive threats to ensure I wasn't missing anything.
Here's a list of all the threats to account (very much subject to change as the meta evolves)
List of common meta threats
Mixed
:mewtwo-mega-x: (Magic Guard)
runs HJK + Lumina Crash with 2 coverage moves commonly chosen between Gigaton, Astral, Fleur Cannon, EDrift, Steel Beam, Chloroblast
:diancie-mega: (Pixilate) :choice-specs: :life-orb: :pixie-plate:
:arceus-ghost: (Simple No Retreat)
:blacephalon: (physical fire + special ghost) :life-orb: :choice-scarf:
Physical
:kartana: :choice-band: :life-orb:
:kyurem-black: :choice-band:
:garchomp-mega: :choice-band: or Shift Gear
:mewtwo-mega-x: :choice-band:
:ho-oh: (Magic Guard)
Special
:kyurem-white: (Refrigerate) :choice-specs:
:eternatus: (Mold Breaker)
runs Torch Song + stabs or can use Final Gambit
:lunala: (Simple No Retreat) watch out for Final Gambit
:miraidon: (Beads of Ruin or Electric Surge) :choice-specs: :life-orb:
:arceus-ghost: (Fur Coat / Other defensive ability) Take Heart or Nasty Plot
Ghost is the primary threat but Poison Fairy Water and others can run Take Heart sets and be threatening.
:palkia-origin: (Speed Boost Nasty Plot)
Niche (Rare enough that not accounting for them is fine but you really should if you can)
:deoxys-attack: (various, primarily psysurge + 3 coverage LO)
:beedrill-mega: :choice-band:
:greninja-ash: (mixed Tough Claws / Sniper)
:aerodactyl-mega: (MGLO)
:gardevoir-mega: (Pixilate) :choice specs:
:sceptile-mega: (MG or specs adapt/beads)
In my case, I found that I was still pretty weak against some Deoxys sets and some MMX variants, but I figured since I had fast breakers and the surprise Scarf on Kartana, I'd be able to account for them. However this is absolutely a weakness, my team isn't perfect by any means, but hopefully the mentality behind how I build it can be of use to those struggling to make their teams work.
The problem I see with stuff like MARI cores.
My main issue with this is that it acts as a sort of trap for intermediate players that prevents them from really improving. Yes, you can absolutely plug two offensive guys into a FC Mirai / Scales Fairyceus / Regen MLix / Imp core and get to 1600 on ladder. However this develops bad habits that lead to people not really considering how the entirety of their team fits together. (Not to mention that the specific core I mentioned is dead weak to the physical dragons).
I think that you really can't define a good defensive core in a vacuum. It really depends on the team it's supporting. Maybe the mons can stay similar but especially the movesets will massively depend on what utility you need, how you're gonna play the hazard game, etc. A team that relies on Kart + MMX can choose to maybe trade rocks with Imp on their regenvest and not worry too much about removal in a way that a team with Blacephalon just can't.
You also have to consider that some offensive mons add defensive value to a team in a way that lets you soften up the defensive core. Moldy Etern or MG Ho-oh are great examples able to check quite a few threats that you now no longer need to account for with your furscales. The Importance of sapblocking will wildly vary depending on the team. Some teams need to get their breakers in as much as possible while others can step back and focus on the hazard / chip game until the breaker can get in and clean.
TLDR you really can't view your team as Offensive core + Defensive core and so long as the latter improofs the former it's all fine. Different offensive playstyles open up different needs for defense. There isn't one correct or easy way to build and looking to "solve" the meta isn't going to help you improve as a player.
What can we do to make building easier and more flexible?
Ban Lumina Crash. MMX is way too hard to account for with how freely it can pick its counters.
After that, I'm not sure, the problem is there's a ton of threats that put pressure in the builder, but nothing is really individually banworthy.
Losing a ton of utility moves makes it a lot harder for defensive mons to fit what they need without becoming passive or vulnerable to Imposter.
8 PP healing also just sucks but there's nothing we can do about that.
DLC give us spectral and zygod moves please please please...