With DLC 2 on the horizon tiering actions are usually on hold due to significant meta shifts that are coming, but I believe there are two aspects that can be tackled prior to DLC dropping. I will also share my thought on some other problematic aspects. These are all my own opinions and not representative of council and such. Stuff are ordered in my priority. Yes I know this is a double post but I wanted to get this out fast.
1. Liquid Ooze - Quick Ban
Liquid Ooze is uncompetitive. This ability might not be broken (depending on how you view sapblocking as a whole) but it is undoubtedly uncompetitive with the interactions it creates. I would compare it to a (lesser) version of Innards Out. I've proposed this already in OM cord a few times at this point. One of the main points that people have brought up is how significant is the difference between Liquid Ooze and other sapblocking methods, namely Magic Bounce and stat based sapblocking (with a hint of stuff like Sap Sipper), to warrant banning Liquid Ooze and not the others.
I think that sapblocking in general is bound to be an aspect of the metagame. Strength Sap is simply too necessary on physical walls to neutralize the obscenely powerful threats, and a lack of decent setup control also further mandates the move (I will cover more of this in a later part of this post). However, I do find general sapblocking to be reasonably healthy currently (and any problematic elements are the enablers/abusers of sapblock), and I think that the thinking required behind picking appropriate sapblockers and doing the contrary for physical walls to attempt to bypass sapblockers is an interesting part of teambuilding. Liquid Ooze however, does not fit into this "healthy" interaction.
The biggest problem with Liquid Ooze is that, unlike the other sapblocking methods, Liquid Ooze's punishment is significantly harsher. While Magic Bounce reverses some momentum by healing the Bouncer and Sap Sipper boosts their attack, Liquid Ooze straight up deals a huge chunk of HP and can very often kill. What this means, is that there is no room to play around the sapblock. Against Bounce, if you clicked Sap into the Bouncer, they healed, you did not and wasted a turn, but you can still play the game from here. This is extremely important. You still have the opportunity to pressure the Bouncer or switch out and find another opportunity to heal up. Worst case scenario, your Sap Pokemon is stonewalled by their Bouncer, you still have the Sap Pokemon and can maybe use it to check the threat one more time or use it as a double switch potential. Ooze denies all of this, if you clicked Sap into the Ooze user, chances are that Pokemon is now fainted.
It is also important to realize that the Ooze user is basically irrelevant here, as long as it has enough Attack. If the Ooze user has a favourable matchup into the Sap user, great, the difference between Ooze and Bounce is not significant. However, it is when the matchup is neutral or favoured towards the Sap user that we can see the issue. The mere presence of an Ooze user makes every turn where a Sap user wants to click Sap a dangerous mind game. Should it click Sap and risk dying to the Ooze user being on the field, or should it click the appropriate punishing move and risk being punished because the Ooze user is not on the field and it didn't get to heal up. Effectively, every such turn becomes a 50/50, and these turns are every turn while
any Sap user is on the field. In fact, such interactions can be present even if Ooze is unrevealed. If a player is uncertain about a Pokemon with a reasonable attack stat (think 300+)'s ability, should this player need to play around the potential of a randomly revealed Ooze instantly granting the Ooze player a significant advantage?
These interactions are also exclusive to Ooze. If we consider Magic Bounce, then the interactions between a Sap user and a disadvantaged/neutral Bounce user is much more favoured towards the Sap user. The reason is that after a Bounced Sap, the Sap user is still alive and can pressure the sapblocker in front of it. Thus, not only does the sapblocking side have to accurately predict the Sap turn correct (which is also present with Ooze), but they then have to get subsequent turns correct as well, as mispredicting can either reset the health progress on the Sap user or cost the Bounce user significant health, while the Sap user is still intact.
These interactions caused by Ooze and only Ooze are what I would consider as uncompetitive and unhealthy for the metagame. It, in a way, albeit lesser, resembles Innards Out forcing every Pokemon to consider clicking any physical move, and Terastallization forcing revenge-killers and sweepers to consider clicking moves into their targets, and Dynamax forcing players to consider if the choice-locked breaker is going to DMax and break the choice-lock. Ooze is also going to be minimally affected by DLC, unless in a miracle we get dropped a 16 PP recovery move, Sap is going to be a defining part of the defensive meta and thus Ooze will continue to do its thing.
Replays
I don't actually have good replays to showcase here, not that I don't have any but because I'm not sure if my opponents want me to share the replays.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9balancedhackmons-1988962365
Me vs Clas, Ooze doesn't do a whole lot here but it enables a bunch of improofing and it permanently cripples Clas's wincon.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9balancedhackmons-1989261289
City vs QT, Ooze on turn 64, despite being revealed, kills a +2 Groundceus with a Ooze mon that takes big damage from the Groundceus and has Jungle Healing as its recovery
[Redacted Replay 1]
Me vs Tester1, Kartana Headlongs Miraidon and leaves it at 6%, I lose the predict and lose my Ooze Yveltal as the Miraidon clicks Thunder Cage. However consider if I predicted opponent to click TCage and click Headlong again and kill the Miraidon. Opponent cannot midground with Torch Song well because Torch Song into Yveltal doesn't deal good damage and next turn is forced into "Does Yveltal stay in".
[Redacted Replay 2]
Me vs Tester2, Kartana wins through MG Sap Mirai, FC Yveltal, and FC Poisonceus. Notable Ooze impact is killing the Poisonceus that would've otherwise reasonably checked Kartana.
[Redacted Replay 3]
Me vs Tester3, Kartana chips Lunala for 51% and then Ooze Yveltal kills it, eliminating the check and allowing Kartana to click buttons freely and clean.
2. Mega Diancie - Suspect
To the surprise of absolutely no one, Mega Diancie is oppressive. Its combination of typing, high mixed offenses, and the meta environment turn it into one of the most restrictive elements of the meta currently.
As shown from my previous post, Mega Diancie has extremely few reliable, viable counters, namely, Arceus-Poison and -Fire. Every other answer is either exclusively used to deal with it, such as Soundproof, and/or is unreliable and either gets blown apart by a perfectly viable coverage move or is 2HKOed after the slightest chip. Even Arceus-Fire is bordering on a more fringe Pokemon due to its Rocks weakness. Furthermore, both Arceus-formes actually need the correct ability to reliably answer the Diancie variant, as Scales would be susceptible to huge damage from V-create/Headlong Rush while Fur Coat gets worn down by Boomburst, Volt Switch, and 2HKOed by Earth Power.
The alternative to not committing your Arceus slot into checking Diancie, is... having multiple softer checks, with generally one of them being Scales Arceus. Which, by the way, is not a great check and absolutely mandates other checks on a team since Life Orb Neutral V-create + Extreme Speed does 83.7 - 99.0 and +Atk LO does 92.3 - 109.1 and Specs +SpA Boomburst deals 41.2 - 48.6. Similarly unreliable are Fire-immune Steels, which apart from dying to Ground-coverage, also take huge damage from Boomburst and can get Volt Switched down by Specs if not eliminated by Earth Power (+SpA Boomburst basically can 2HKO every Steel not named Registeel who needs to be +SpD). All these also do not consider the notably rarer but nevertheless viable Population Bomb, comfortably 2HKOing non Fur Coat Ho-Oh and dealing up to 96 to Scales Arc. Also, Diancie's moves are so strong and when combined with the threat of Extreme Speed means the Diancie user loses little momentum considering the opponent generally needs to heal less they want to get cleaned.
Mega Diancie practically mandates the Arceus slot be dedicated towards checking it one way or another. If you do not commit to such, you pretty much are forced into suboptimal options like Soundproofs (issues mentioned above and by Tea previous page), some other Poisons (generally passive and still fold to coverage or brute force), Fire-immune Steels (see above), as other misc. Ice Scales mons have worse mixed bulk than Arceus, meaning lower SpD leads to extremely shaky Specs Boom and Mixed Boom into ESpeed matchup, while lower Def means high vulnerability to 2x ESpeed or V-create into ESpeed.
Additionally, despite Poisonceus being quite a good Pokemon right now, it's status and position in the VR is practically mostly due to Mega Diancie. Poisonceus as a Fur Coat user does not reliably check Kartana nor Kyurem-B and cannot check Mixed MMX or Garchomp, and often can invite Garchomp in. This means that as a Fur Coat user, Poisonceus doesn't actually matchup that well into the 4 main physical breakers. I've been doing a lot of "teambuilding" involving Poisonceus recently, and the glaring weakness to Mega Garchomp on top of practically being forced into Strength Sap for improofing and helping to handle Kartana and Kyu-B makes it awkward to actually handle Chomp on less offensive teams. Chomp's setup and power basically forces Strength Sap as an answer (it can 2HKO FC Mega Slowbro), and running two Sap Fur Coats directly leads into the team being susceptible to Sap blocking (hey look at Ooze), thus forcing the team to consider alternatives like the very few Fur Coats that can both take a hit comfortably and kill back (can't use Fairyceus), or Celesteela, or pivoting into Mega Diancie to ESpeed.
A bit off topic but basically the point is that Poisonceus isn't actually very good outside of checking Diancie, and is only that good because it checks Diancie well compared to the alternatives.
For those that are familiar with other metas with Mega Diancie, some major differences that SV BH has in comparison that I believe pushes Mega Dianice over the edge are a combination of:
Nerfed Recovery PP, can't just heal up on Boomburst with faster walls like Arceus.
No Zac-C (ND), one of the best checks to Diancie, pretty much forces Fire moves as Ground moves don't punish as hard
Less offensive checks, along with Zac-C there is MMY and MGar, both don't die to ESpeed (latter comfortably) and can KO back
Less threats to Diancie, this is mainly Anchor Shot and Thousand Waves, especially the former.
Why before DLC, potential spoilers
I think it is perfectly valid to tiering action Mega Diancie prior to DLC because it is very reasonable that nothing in DLC will actually contribute to nerfing Diancie to a healthier state.
Anchor Shot is practically confirmed to not be returning, and while Thousand Waves is extremely likely, Thousand Waves doesn't usually OHKO Diancie anyways and is not going to affect defensively checking Diancie. In fact Thousand Waves can serve as a coverage option on Mega Diancie itself due to its trapping effect, preventing Steels from escaping.
Basically guaranteed no good checks will be released. As shown, not even Arceus level bulk is generally sufficient at handling Mega Diancie, and so it is quite reasonable to assume that none of the new DLC Pokemon would be able to do so. Highly highly doubt Terapagos has a typing/bulk to deal with Diancie, and even if so, I still think that the number of good Diancie checks is too few.
DLC introduces a lot of strong coverage moves that could just be beneficial to Diancie, examples being Blue Flare/Bolt Strike.
DLC generally introduces more offensive stuff, do not see stuff like MMY and MGar being balanced. Even still not a great point to keep Diancie because "MMY/MGar" offensively checks it.
There is no way we get good PP recovery back.
3. Kartana - Wait
Again to the surprise of absolutely no one. Kartana is absolutely crazy, probably more than Diancie. Gigaton Hammer practically never loses momentum even with its effect and slower, less bulky walls can sometimes just be picked off by the Struggle afterwards. The 4 coverage set has basically no reliable answer other than Fur Coat Ho-Oh as Arceus-formes take enormous damage from Gigaton or coverage, while the much rarer setup set can also just claim kills against teams without Ho-Oh or Water-types.
Kartana is basically one of the biggest abusers of Sap blocking. Almost every Kartana check needs to utilize Strength Sap to not fold which immediately leads to a problem if it gets sapblocked. Kartana's Rock's resistance also eases its switch-in and its sheer power compensates for its lower speed tier by threatening out stuff like non Torch Song Fairyceus, Groundceus, while slower Pokemon are even more bait for it to switch into and start tearing holes.
However the reason why I think Kartana should not be tiering actioned prior to DLC is because
DLC
Sunsteel is very very likely to drop and that automatically pushes Kartana over the edge for a QB, forcing Ability Shield meta is not ok. Other Steels can potentially be broken with Sunsteel but A. I think Kartana is banworthy regardless and B. Tier those other Steels/Sunsteel separately is fine IMO.
4. Arceus-Ghost - Wait
This might be surprising to some people. The main reason I put Arceus-Ghost above Take Heart in general is because I believe Arceus-Ghost is more restricting than the other Take Heart users in general. Disclaimer though, I think Arceus-Ghost is not in the best state right now due to what I previously mentioned in Mega Diancie since Ghostceus is not an Arceus that checks Diancie (unless the rare Scales)!
Arceus-Ghost's main difference with other Take Heart users is its Knock Off resilience (shared by Arceus-formes), its unique typing, and its Imposter matchup. Knock Off resilience is a minor point but its mainly to compare to the other Ghosts who can immediately be neutralized by Knock Off.
Typing-wise, on first glance Ghost isn't that great of a defensive typing with few relevant resistances. But the more important thing to consider regarding Take Heart users is the weaknesses. Ghost is weak to two types, Dark and itself. Obviously, using a Ghost-type to attempt to offensive check Ghostceus is not a good idea when Ghostceus likely has Fur Coat and Take Heart boosts. Dark types are practically non existent with the sole exception being Yveltal (more on that later). Non STAB even coming off strong threats like MMX typically lack power and defensive Pokemon don't even run these moves outside of Knock Off, which does little damage. This, combined with Ghost's lack of weakness to common priority, makes it virtually impossible to offensively deal with it after it gets even one boost up. This is different when considering the other common Arceus-formes, with Poison being weak to Psychic and the rarer Ground, Fairy being weak to Steel, Ground to Grass and Water, Fire to Water and Ground, and Water to Electric, Grass, and Salt. Even if the offensive threat carrying these strong moves cannot OHKO immediately, such as Mixed MMX into Poisonceus, it can 2HKO and not get OHKOed in return, something that is pretty much absent for Ghostceus.
Yveltal is the only relevant Pokemon in the meta that can reliably hit Ghostceus for SE damage, but its relative lack of power and Ghostceus's boosting means Yveltal needs Take Heart of its own to reliably deal with Ghostceus, severely limiting its moveset (Rev Dance, Take Heart, Recovery, one free move). Thus, to actually handle Ghostceus, either a rather mid Yveltal set is needed, or an Ice Scales with the passive Haze is necessary unless the plan is to go into Take Heart war into crit fish.
Ghostceus's perfect matchup into standard Imposter also means its both more resilient to effects like Salt Cure, since Imposter still loses unlike other formes, and its last coverage move is customizable. Most other formes typically use Thunder Cage due to its trapping and percentage based damage to improve the matchup against Imposter, but Ghostceus isn't locked into this and can consider options like Knock Off (very strong support, beats Plate Imposter), Sludge Wave (tech for Audino and Fairyceus), Thunder Cage (generally good + beats Yveltal). It also can consider regular Recover if it chooses to build its setup around it to avoid sapblock, or even the niche Nasty Plot. No Retreat is also a Ghostceus set but I don't think is particularly big in terms of Ghostceus's restrictiveness, though it is still relevant.
All in all I think Ghostceus, while probably not as good as certain Arceus formes in the current meta, is more problematic and restricting than any other Arceus forme. As a bonus it also heavily limits Rapid Spin's reliability due to, again, difficulty of actually pressuring it. However its definitely not like the biggest issue right now and DLC can introduce some tools as well, but do think it could be looked into in the near future.
5. Take Heart - Wait
Kind of explained by Tea and tzaur already, Take Heart is pretty restrictive in terms of good answers and we've seen multiple games where players engage in Take Heart wars. Its basically Poison Heal but slightly worse (Poison Heal is still stronger even though you can't run like Fur Coat as well because passive recovery is insane, not taking poison damage from slow Mortals end of turn is good, not having all recovery denied by sapblock is good, improof and denying Imposter of recovery is good, and you have extra move because not forced into Sap.
--------------------------------------------------
Other stuff
Salt Cure I don't think is an issue at the moment. I had strong opinions a while ago but I think right now its a welcomed soft check into Take Heart so would rather wait. Salt Cure's issue is that it has no counterplay outside of MG and Cloak. Mortal Spin in comparison also had Poison types, Steel types, and Take Heart. Salt Cure is moderately more "Cloak-forcing" than Mortal Spin. Can see action on this a while into DLC meta.
Substitute is something I think is broken and stay banned. There have been numerous occasions recently where I was like "hey this would be nuts if I put Sub on it before realizing its banned". Substitute is arguably even stronger than Take Heart by denying all passive utility moves and even more than Take Heart such as blocking Knock. It also denies slow pivoting into offensive check types of counterplay and instead turns those mons into Sub fodder. I don't even think GaG or Soundproof is like the ideal stuff, you can literally stuff Sub with any defensive ability, forcing Parting Shot to slow down Sub users is obviously too much. We've also seen non GaG SProof Sub being used before Sub was banned and in ND (which by the way has stronger moves from defensive mons and the ubiquitous sub-bypassing Spectral Thief).
Poison Heal is something I've seen a few people bring up as something that can be revisited with new moves and such. But see my points on Take Heart. If Take Heart is already as problematic as it is Poison Heal is only going to be worse. Don't want to hide tag for spoiler again but the new moves that can drop are not even that good outside of specifically answering Poison Heal and all have weaknesses to stuff that are easily fitted on by Poison Heal sets with the sole exception of one move that A. might not even drop and B. needs to be combined with specific other moves to actually threaten. The sheer diversity of potential PH users also means that every team needs to fit multiple PH checks, and no Toxic Orb Imposter is not a representation of PH being healthy. (Also I think PH is like at least borderline in ND which has all the tools we don't have and stuff we will never have so like...).
DLC stuff
Photon Geyser seems pretty crazy with the number of Psychics we have. However...
MMX and Deo-A both seem banworthy with the amount of stronger coverage (like Bolt Strike) coming in, currently MMX already is pick your checks and Deo-A is unscoutable. If both of these are gone theres a chance Photon is not oppressive but its still reasonably likely.
With MMX and Deo-A gone then Lumina should be unbanned as everything that it supposedly broke would be banned.
Bolt Strike and friends on their own seem fine.
Moongeist Beam is very strong, but the best abuser we have are Flutter Mane and Spectrier?! Potentially banworthy because AS meta bad but this is more uncertain.
New moves like the Heal Block thing (very likely bannable) and the Electric move that is super good under rain (also seems bannable).
Triage OWing is back and this has traditionally been very strong but without Tail Glow and particularly good abusers it might be ok.
Don't see anything on banlist that looks plausible for free other than Lumina.
More detailed discussions can be held for these aspects in terms of Day 1 Prebanlists when DLC is closer and the stuff is more or less confirmed.