blunder said:darkrai sparked this discussion so its clearly darkrai that should be looked at in my opinion. made a vid with my overall thoughts on my channel but this was never a discussed issue before darkrai came around and it is very clear that that is the pokemon that has created an imbalance
Honestly, I see this the same as Kings Rock with Cloyster or BP with GeoPass.
Did one mon bring the topic to the forefront in particular? Yes, but that doesn't erase the issue being present still. Whether Darkrai is or is not in the tier, sleep introduces a lot of rng into the game. Darkrai has dumb cheese with Hypnosis, but the rng sleep brings and the cringe play pattern still remain. I'd compare it to stuff like Smeargle on BP and Cloyster with King's Rock because even if we kick Darkrai out of the tier, sleep will still be stupid.
People say Darkrai is the reason we are having this discussion, but the bigger reason is that we are dealing with the ramifications of Sleep clause. Sleep was attempted to be perserved over two decades ago when it would have easily attracted tiering action if it was left unchecked. Sure, we are discussing this right now because Sash lead darkrai is the current hotness on HO, but we have seen Sleep be dumb and cheesy plenty of times both this gen and in other gens. Mons like Venusaur and Valiant do similar cheese strats to darkrai, you are forced to sack a mon to Amoongus often.
Acting on Darkrai doesn't change the fact you have games that can be decided on massive RNG swings. Sleep in its current form is a massive RNG headache, and it has been for ages. It has been grandfathered into our tiering system because of clauses made almost two decades ago at this point. If Sleep came out in Gen IX as a new status condition and we did not have Sleep Clause and our history with it, it would have gotten tiering action unbelievably fast. We try to avoid complex bans as much as possible, so why should we bend over backwards to enable a massive rng mess like sleep? Sleep clause is already not representative of what's on cartridge; the only way it is is if two people shake on it as an informal agreement. The reason sleep clause even exists is because without it, sleep would be so obviously busted. Even without it, its clearly uncompetitive with how much RNG it brings to the table. If we were willing to act on Cloyster/King's Rock solely due to that, we should evaluate Sleep and its problematic aspects.
Sleep at its core is uncompetitive. Darkrai being in the tier is good because it finally gives us a good enough excuse to finally take down sleep clause, rip the band aid off, and just go after Sleep itself.