All gimmicks are underrated. In the dictionary gimmick is supposed to mean something ingenious. "an ingenious or novel device, scheme, or stratagem, especially one designed to attract attention or increase appeal."
However, you guys agree with going with Tobes definition of a gimmick. Puts the name in a bad light. So what you say is subjective and to delete a long winded post with real battle results linked to show that it works and then deleting it shows no respect on Tobes part, or whoever deleted it or whoever agrees with him.