My guess is it is coincidence. Dusk Ball capture bonus should be 4x at night or in caves; Quick Ball capture bonus should be 4x in the first 5 turns.
It seems unlikely, but when you think about the number of times you've been catching Pokemon, that something like this should happen is less unlikely. When you consider the number of Smogon members, it becomes vastly more likely that SOMEONE would suffer something like you did.
It's possible the mechanics of the balls are misreported.
Go back to your capturing tonight. Capture 10 Smeargle with Quick Balls, and 10 with Dusk Balls. Record how many tries each capture takes. Message me your results and I'll do the statistics. (Or do the stats yourself, if you know how.)
(Aside: Smeargle doesn't show up at Acuity Lakefront. Do you mean Sneasel?)
It seems unlikely, but when you think about the number of times you've been catching Pokemon, that something like this should happen is less unlikely. When you consider the number of Smogon members, it becomes vastly more likely that SOMEONE would suffer something like you did.
It's possible the mechanics of the balls are misreported.
Go back to your capturing tonight. Capture 10 Smeargle with Quick Balls, and 10 with Dusk Balls. Record how many tries each capture takes. Message me your results and I'll do the statistics. (Or do the stats yourself, if you know how.)
(Aside: Smeargle doesn't show up at Acuity Lakefront. Do you mean Sneasel?)