Rising_Dusk said:The first thing that suggests that you're incorrect here is that your "forseeable end product" is nothing like one of the possibilities I've been itching to see. Furthermore, it's not like the dozen or so that were discussed in IRC the other day. Steel doesn't paint us into a corner any more than any other of the types do. There are tons of options in stats, abilities, and secondary typings - far more than you give credit for.
Steel paints us into the corner of building an all-purpose wall. Plain and simple. We've already built a CAP with Steel typing, decent coverage, and a more offensive outlook. I'm talking about Kitsunoh of course, and we had no illusions that mon was setting out to have the bulk to switch into an array of attacks.
I'm sorry, but you're making the argument that if Steel is chosen as the primary typing, it will have to be utterly broken. That's bogus. We have in our control here every aspect of the pokemon. It can be balanced very easily in many different ways. Surely you, of all people, realize this.
Steel is the most unbalanced type in the game. It trades a cart of random resistances for three of the most ubiquitous weaknesses.
This is a very unprofessional, immature, and inappropriate attitude to take. "If I lose this poll, I'm going to try to ruin this CAP!" That isn't the essence or spirit of CAP. Please, for the good of the CAP, the process, and the community I ask that you rescind this remark.
Why shouldn't I do what I always do, which is to optimize the mon's chances for success at every point in the process? If we want our "utility counter" to be resistance king, we should give it the king of resistance types. I thought resistances were the most important thing? Suddenly we'll have to cripple it instead by picking a proxy type known for attributes that either place it outside the realm of OU (Steelix, Aggron) or traditionally lend themselves to a more offensive playstyle? (Lucario/Kitsunoh)
This sort of sweeping generalization can be made for every single type in the game. There is no merit here.
There are 17 Types. Steel comprises 20% of OU (10 of 50ish). That leaves 80% for the other 16 types. Steel is in an entirely different class of its own, when its devastating weaknesses are properly accounted for. Its usage in OU (all among Dual types I might add) should make that abundantly clear. On average you are four times more likely to see a Steel pokemon than any other individual type.
And Magnezone. And Scizor. And Forretress.
Magnezone exists largely for eradicating the other 9 Steels. Scizor and Forretress bait Fire moves for Heatran to eat. Otherwise there is no effective means to attack them because Bug cancels out the other two devastating weaknesses.
This is blatantly incorrect, though. You can tailor its base defensive stats so that they are ineffective unless focused upon in EVs. There are many threats that you might have to tailor the CAP's speed in order to immediately threaten them out after getting in. There are also many Pokemon where you'll want to threaten them on either the physical or special side of the spectrum. The versatility of such a Pokemon lies in its ability to switch in, firstly, and then its ability to threaten out the opponent. You cannot prepare for all threats if this CAP is developed properly - even with Steel as an available option.
So not only will this get an overpowered, overrepresented type (again, assuming Steel's weaknesses are balanced and not exacerbated), it will also presumably get a movepool superior to that of even Jirachi. Thats what it will need to deal with the level of anti-Steel attacks in the metagame. When I did Colossoil's stats they were defensively superior to Hariyama. Colossoil had no actual impetus to use defensive stats, so why would a more offensive Steel mon do so? Lucario and Kitsunoh don't. Scizor runs 248 HP since it doesn't require Speed for Bullet Punch, but beforehand never did so. Jirachi barely invests large amounts of EVs in defenses (Wish set is most defensive). Heatran does have bulky sets but it follows the general Steel paradigm I have argued of required canceling out a weakness (and in fact capitalizing on other Steel team member's weakness to it).
Furthermore, there are still numerous options available to us. For instance, the secondary typing could resist one of those few types that Steel is weak to. Then, the abilities might not be forced to be so clear-cut as Levitate, Flash Fire, Motor Drive, or whatever. Heck, the Skarmory model is exactly what CAP10 doesn't need to be. Just because a Steel needs to address its weaknesses does not imply that it will have to become Skarmory 2.0 or Bronzong 2.0 to handle itself. Those Pokemon function entirely different from how I envision CAP10 working, and that's already factoring in its clear weaknesses.
Few weaknesses? We're talking Ground, Fire, and Fighting here, three of the most used attacks in the metagame on almost every OU Pokemon. You can't address all 3 at once without using one of Levitate or Flash Fire, depending on what you choose for a secondary type to plug up the other ones.
The fact that you even call it easy mode stands testament for how perfectly Steel typing fits the CAP concept. It needs those resistances to switch in on. If it does not have those resistances, then its stat distribution is forced to be heavily defensive so that it will not be 2HKO'd by the threats it should be countering. If that's the case, then it will result in a Pokemon with little offensive threat and no speed with which to immediately put down the threats it's focusing on. I feel that such a forced defensive spread is far more limiting than having to address Steel's weaknesses.
The fact I call it easy mode implies that like Multitype it is a pre-completed end product if done in the manner I prefer, which is to maximize efficiencies. By all means if resistances are to be king of the hill, let them be so. I cannot seriously take any CAP project that requires an immunity-conferring ability not to fall victim to Hidden Power Fire (or otherwise share the current best defensive type in the game with the time-tested Skarmory)
I don't care to argue opinion with you - nor would I want to - however, I only want you to see that your carpet-perspective on what Steel will do to this CAP is incorrect. Steel is incredibly viable for the concept, what it intends to do, and offers us, the community, the flexibility to do it in numerous ways.
Steel is rigid and offers no flexibility. You either make up for Steel's massive, multifaceted shortcomings or you will find the project a failure. The very fact in order for this to be competitive you have to justify immunity-enabling abilities should be a clarion call. Steel either counters very, very little or it counters everything. There is no middle ground with Steel. By its very nature it either inflexibly loses to most pokemon with decent move coverage or it counters everything well. Steel is all or nothing.