I decided after lack of feedback, and not liking the design at all, for the waratah, I decided to stick with leafy tornado. I'm still uncertain as to whether making certain the Pokemon would be appropriate for the Field egg group is absolutely mandatory or not, but I'm not too worried about that right now.
I decided to try a completely different style of shading and colours, while keeping the basic shape until I can finally draw a new, better, possible more dynamic pose for it, especially for the hands. Personally I think it looks much better than the last version/s I posted, but I am uncertain as to whether I need to pay more attention to the swirling leaves. I.e whether I should individually redo them/colour them (oh god) or if I should leave it. (
haha get it, i so funny) I've also tried to experiment a little bit with a possible shiny design, where the body is made of dying/autumn leaves,
Possible shiny colouring
And while going feminine and child like with the design seems to be the new thing for this thread, I can't really think of anyway to make the tornado feminine without going stereotypical, like giving it eyelashes. As always, any critique is
MANDATORY welcome.
I'll be going backwards through posts to critique, just so it'll be a little quicker:
Feedback
Yilx Awesome supplementary material again. Though like last time, the head branches appeared to be the main face again, initially confusing me, but that's because it's mainly a sketch. You are really good at putting your designs in dynamic poses. The colours you've ended up with look quite good too, even though had I been given the chance to vote, I would have liked to see the green head and green body together to see what it was like. Ah well.
Dust7 Pardon me if I'm mistaken, but didn't you already make a Final Submission post? Anyway, the Chikorita-like thing is pretty cute, but the scythes could be incorporated into the main body much better, rather than looking like random scythes drawn on. I also think the second pose is better, as it feel more dynamic. Also, you're not supposed to quote images in full - just link back to the original post.
mayatrease The new design is good, though like Yilx I think I prefer the original. On the new concept, however, I am kind of having difficulty telling what black parts are what - At first, I thought the second pose had it wearing a Black Mage style hat. I think slightly better colouring would clarify that. It may also just be me, but I think the brush tail might look better if it was coming out of the lower back pod when the thing is shown sideways. As for the renditions of the original design, I like the one with the green tail better, though the tips might use one more splash of colour on the end.
MektarTheOverlord Were you, by any chance, the same as the person who came up with the anvil on a parachute for the last CAP? xD Even though it is silly, I like it, and it works because it is reminiscent of designs like Vanilluxe and Klinklang. I'd suggest either putting a shadowy element or at least giving them some sort of eyes to unify the things better than just the smiles (which I didn't notice at first).
Wyverii I kind of have to agree with that one poster who mentioned the human shape similarities to Smeargle, but it's not that big of a problem. I feel that the bark clothing could be a bit more detailed, but I suppose I'll wait for the full digital rendition you promised before really going into detail. I can't really think of any problems I have with it though as it is.
bugmaniacbob Out of the three possibilities, I prefer the first one much more, though the 17 different flames is a cute idea. However, on the first one, I feel that the long hair is a bit too much. Maybe it could be toned down a bit.
Mos-quitoxe I really like this design for it's uniqueness and origami touch. My main nitpick is with the kanji you decided to use for the face - there's nothing particularly wrong with it, but it just kind of bugs me a little. Maybe it's the mouth, but otherwise it's looking good. Maybe it could be a bit yellowish to represent old paper.
CyzirVisheen It reminds me of Litwick, if only because it's adorable and creepy at the same time. I don't really have anything to critique on, besides maybe the unnatural looking way the arms perfectly stick out like that.
Paras Hilton The thing is bizarre and unique. I especially like the head axe. Without the supplementary material, though, I would have had no idea that the stump was like a helmet instead of being part of the Pokemon naturally. I also don't really like the tail, as it seems to be trying to be leaf-like but failing, but your mileage may vary.
tea and blues Cute design, but I'm uncertain whether the dress is meant to be made of plant matter (like Wyverii's), the body itself or a cloth like thing. I really like the face/mask, though, and the third supplementary picture/pose looks really good.
Last but not least, Spork The thing reminds me of both the bleeding waterfalls of Antarctica and of the fad where looking at creatures with those unnatural holes in them made you really itchy. I have to say, this is the design that creeps me out the most (and you just had to post the creepy reference, didn't you xD) My critique would be that it doesn't immediately suggest a grass typing - I'd suggest making the head a bit more mushroom like, but the bleeding tooth fungi really are shaped like that, so I don't really know.
If I had to choose my current faves so far, they'd have to be (in no particular order) CyzirVisheen, Yilx, DougJustDoug,and Mos-quitoxe's concepts, but there's a lot of great ideas in this thread!