so ive been wondering, if you suck at sports, is there any chance of getting into a good college like at all? I have a 4.46 GPA (second in class), 2300 SAT (plan on retaking it, 740 in math bc of two missed questions >_<), 240 PSAT, i'm an Eagle Scout, i've done track/xc every season since I was a freshman, but that's the extent of my credentials and i really feel like if I don't have a sport to offer, I'll never get into any college I want. To make matters worse, everyone I talk to about the problem is completely oblivious and is like "oh come on you can get into whatever school you want" which i just know is UNTRUE AS FUCK but they're all pressuring me and really do think I can get into MIT/CalTech/Carnegie-Mellon which makes it even worse; it's bad to the point where I freak out every time college is mentioned because I really don't want to get stuck going to UMD but I probably will just like every other goddamn person from my school who isn't an athlete. is there a shot for people like me / why is college so fucking unfair and when did it turn from a learning institution to spring training / is there anything I can do outside of magically becoming a good athlete that will make a college like MIT or CalTech want to accept me
edit probably worth mentioning i'm a junior
yo
chill
First of all, your scores and grades seem great. That's always a plus for the list of schools you named.
Second, Cal Tech isn't really looking for if you're an athlete. I'm from Pasadena, their basketball team had a 10 year losing streak.
Third, don't stress out about which schools you will and will not get into. If you apply to enough places, you'll get in somewhere. And honestly, most schools aren't all THAT different, outside of size, location, majors offered, and whether the school is a commuter school or not (there are some other factors too obviously, but I think those are the big ones). You're going to get an education pretty much wherever you go. It will not be the end of the world if you get accepted to Brown instead of Harvard.
Let me repeat myself: you're going to get accepted somewhere, and you're probably going to get rejected somewhere. Do not set all of your hopes on one school, since that might be the one school whose admission officer is having a bad day when they get your app, or whatever. On the other hand, don't sweat which one of your "reaches" is going to reject you. If they reject you, they're missing out.
As for what sorts of things you can do to increase your stock for colleges, you can work on your writing ability. If you write well, then you can sell an admission officer on why their school needs a student like you. A lot of colleges put a good bit of weight into your essays. If you practice your writing abilities and can write an essay about yourself or your experiences that isn't boring, that's a huge plus. Being able to communicate something about who you are, what you're interested in, why you're interested in it, and what you can bring to a school can help make it a lot less likely that admissions officers don't see exactly what you're bringing to their school and why you belong there.
You seem to have a good variety of interests, with track/xc and Boy Scouts outside of the classroom. That's good too.
As I mentioned before, there ARE differences in collegiate experiences based on size, location, commuter status, and majors offered. Before you apply to a school, figure out whether you'd do better in a more close-knit community, or would rather have the amenities and often the more specific majors at a big school. Figure out whether you need to live in a city or near a city. Figure out if you can handle the cold or want to handle the cold. If you want to live with people and make friends that live on campus, try not to go to a school where everyone commutes.
When you find out more about yourself and about the school you're applying to, it makes it a lot easier to communicate in a way that makes it more likely that you'll get in. It's easier to sell yourself when you know what you have to offer, what the school is looking for, and how you bring that to the table. And can do that in a not boring way.
Think that's a decent post about stuff you can do. But seriously, relax.