SlimMan said:We all know that Landorus isn't broken and that was kind of a waste of a page in this thread so I didn't bother posting then but something was posted and its bothering me so here I am.
First of all, when looking at checks/counters, it's sort of unreasonable to assume they switch into hazards more than once. Hazards are always good to account for, but there's a limit. After 6 switch-ins to Spikes, Specially Defensive Jirachi no longer counters Specs Tornadus. That's a little absurd, because Jirachi could just Wish off the Spikes damage, but you get my point. When we start using multiple switch-ins to hazards, counters no longer even exist.
Okay, but onto my main point. Virizion still counters that set. The ability to U-Turn away and weaken it does not make any less of a counter. By that logic, Bulky DD Dos under Rain does not counter Scizor, because Scizor can keep U-Turning away until Gyarados is at extremely low health. If the best that a Pokemon can do is run away and do mediocre damage in the process, then it's countered. Virizion CAN switch in safely, because it will either kill Landorus or make it get the fuck out of there (basically the definition of a counter, switching in and doing that). So yeah, Landorus is countered.
Your logic is incorrect, because Landorus needs only 1 U-turn to weaken Virizion to the point that he won't be able to come in again.Gyarados is a counter to Scizor because it can take multiple U-turns without giving a shit. Do you think that if Gyarados took 39.19 - 46.29% from Scizor's U-turn, like Virizion takes from Landorus's U-turn, people would use him as a Scizor counter? No sane player would slap Virizion in his team and say ''now i am safe from Landorus''. It is a good check, but not a counter, in practice at least. Now if you want to go by the straight definition of : ''a counter to poke a, is a poke b capable of switching in any of poke's a moves and force it out'' , then Virizion is a counter. But this means nothing in real play so better acount him as a check when you are building a team.
And what is the point of nitpicking stuff like ''after 2 SR switch-ins''? I was only trying to show how Landorus can be useful even when not at full life, against the stronger priority users in OU. And acounting the nature of CB Scizor, 2 SR rounds are not hard to get at all. And anyway there is no point in discussing this, because Scizor cannot switch-in anyway.
Scarfwynaut said:What damage calculator are you using? Im using this
http://masara.byethost15.com/SilverlightDmgCalcTestPage.html and getting 22.9%-26.97% for smack down and earthquake for 33.85%-39.95% for earthquake after that. And someone verify here which one is correct?
And by the way, who the hell uses a rest talk Gyarados without rapid spin support? I know its always nice to factor in stealth rock, but for a pokemon that is so often paired with a spinner, I think its unfair to simply case it off as a counter in theory if it doesn't have it.
I used this calculator:
http://honko.freehosting.com/manly_calc.html. Your mistake is that you didn't account for Sand Force.
Of 'course Gyarados in practice can counter Landorus, but not for sure. that was my point. Without SR it can, with it it can't. And because when we talk theoretically about counters, we want them to always counter the poke we want, theoretically Gyara is not a counter. And anyway it sounds nice to say for a poke that it has no counters, so don't spoil my dream. xd
@DDR Master
Lefties heals after SS damage are applied, so Landorus has to do 93,75% damage to Gyarados, and then he will die from SS.