reachzero
the pastor of disaster
Holy smoke, the thread is totally dead for days at a time, then I get home from church and more than fifty posts since the last time I posted.....so anyway, it seems I need to explain my logic a littler further. In a game in which we know absolutely nothing to start out, you want to talk as much as possible before you make an accusation, to give someone guilty enough time to say something stupid or suspicious. You don't want to roll someone random with literally no evidence. To suggest a totally blind vote in the very first post is totally illogical unless you're trying to deflect the lynch away from yourself (which admittedly might not be such a bad idea if your name is "Chris is Me", and therefore rather vulnerable to namerolls yourself). In fairness to CIM, Tenken has indeed revealed himself to be a rather shaky player, considering how incredibly questionable his style of defense has been, especially his accusation of billymills (he's defending me, that seems suspicious?). I'm still very suspicious of CIM, but I have to admit that Tenken looks like a very bad mafia player trying to cover up the fact that he is mafia. It's true that you would expect the mafia to stop one of their teammates from acting that ridiculously stereotypically mafia in the thread, but to be honest it's kindof hard to imagine any non-mafia logic at all that would propose billymills as a target in the way that Tenken did. So even though I realize that it is highly improbable that both CIM and Tenken are mafia, the evidence against Tenken is pretty overwhelming, in my opinion, so Chris looks pretty good by comparison. Basically, if Tenken is bad, I think Chris is "good" but not very bright; if Tenken is good I think Chris is very likely bad. However, I have a very hard time believing that anyone would say the things that Tenken has said if they were clean.
tl;dr, "I still don't like what Chris did, but Tenken has acted too suspicious to ignore now, so maybe Chris got lucky"
Withdraw vote
Fire Tenken
Edit: just realized I forgot to include an answer to the question of who I would recruit if I were mafia: I would pick someone whom I knew to be good without being such a big "name" that they were a likely kill (and ironically, lynch target). So I think I would take someone like HD.
tl;dr, "I still don't like what Chris did, but Tenken has acted too suspicious to ignore now, so maybe Chris got lucky"
Withdraw vote
Fire Tenken
Edit: just realized I forgot to include an answer to the question of who I would recruit if I were mafia: I would pick someone whom I knew to be good without being such a big "name" that they were a likely kill (and ironically, lynch target). So I think I would take someone like HD.