Okay I did some more sniffing around concerning the As One idea, and the more I look at it the more I'm convinced it will be completely unique from Inheritance. Yes, the act of attaching a movepool and ability to something with better stats does carry over, but it also shares characteristics from Shared Power, Camomons, and Cross Evolution. With every "As One" pairing, you are trying to design an ideal type combo, with two synergizing abilities, using one mon with good stats and another with good movepool. It's quite the feat and possibilities are endless. There is so much potential for sets that haven't been done before in other OMs.
I do still think that with so many components to be combined and synergized, there need to be some limits on what can be carried over. Namely:
- There should be a rule on which pokemon is the Rider and which one is the Steed (final stats are from the Steed, but buffed). My idea was that the one with the higher BST would always be the Steed, following the precedent with Calyrex and the horses, but we would still need a rule for resolving who is the Steed if they have the same BST. I think it is simplest to just not allow them to merge if they share the same BST--you wouldn't see a horse riding another horse, would you? Otherwise we could come up with something random, like the Steed is the one with the lower Pokedex #, but that feels too arbitrary.
- I think the meta will get too complicated if there is too much freedom to choose abilities. If you do get any choice at all, there needs to be a rule on which pokemon (the Steed or the Rider) automatically gives its primary ability and which one gives you a choice. Being able to pick the ability from the Rider is probably more interesting. However this still creates a ton of meta complexity when you're already combining types and movepools a la Cross Evolution and stacking abilities a la Shared Power. There is also no precedent for ability choice from Calyrex + Glastrier/Spectrier. For this reason I think that both pokemon should only ever be able to pass their primary ability. There are a few downsides to this, namely reducing/losing access to certain abilities that are mostly/entirely granted through the secondary/hidden ability slots, such as Drizzle and Drought, but overall I think this simpler ruleset will make a cleaner meta that still has more than enough options.
To prove my point that there are tons of exciting combinations even with this restricted ruleset, I have compiled a list of possible Steeds and Riders with the typing and ability that they contribute.
Possible Steeds and Riders
Steeds with Useful Abilities
These pokemon all have 600 BST, thus would almost always be Steeds
There are several other Steeds that can be well-utilized for typing, movepool, and stats, but have less useful abilities such as Pressure
:Mew: Psychic, Synchronize (used for movepool more than ability)
:Victini: Psychic, Victory Star
:Cresselia: Psychic, Levitate
:Latias:/:Latios: Dragon, Levitate
:Hydreigon: Dark, Levitate
:Dragapult: Dragon, Clear Body
:Kommo-o: Dragon, Bulletproof
:Salamence: Dragon, Intimidate
:Genesect: Bug, Download
:Volcanion: Fire, Water Absorb
:Heatran: Fire, Flash Fire
:Jirachi: Steel, Serene Grace
:Magearna: Steel, Soul Heart
:Metagross: Steel, Clear Body
:Landorus-Therian: Ground, Intimidate
:Tyranitar: Rock, Sand Stream
:Zeraora: Electric, Volt Absorb
:Goodra: Dragon, Sap Sipper
Steeds/Riders with Useful Abilities
These pokemon have 580-570 BST, so they can easily be either Riders or Steeds
There are several others that can be utilized for typing, movepool, or stats, but have less useful abilities
:Tornadus-Therian: Flying, Regenerator
:Tornadus: Flying, Prankster
:Thundurus: Electric, Prankster
:Thundurus-Therian: Electric, Volt Absorb
:Azelf:/:Uxie: Psychic, Levitate
:Articuno-Galar: Psychic, Competitive
:Zapdos-Galar: Fighting, Defiant
:Blacephalon: Fire, Beast Boost
:Buzzwole:/:Pheromosa: Bug, Beast Boost
:Celesteela: Steel, Beast Boost
:Kartana: Grass, Beast Boost
:Nihilego:/:Stakataka: Rock, Beast Boost
:Xurkitree: Electric, Beast Boost
:Guzzlord: Dark, Beast Boost
:Tapu Bulu: Grass, Grassy Surge
:Tapu Lele: Psychic, Psychic Surge
:Tapu Koko: Electric, Electric Surge
:Tapu Fini: Water, Misty Surge
Riders that provide an offensive boost (some of these can be Steeds)
:Porygon-Z: Normal, Adaptability
:Urshifu:/:Urshifu-Rapid Strike: Fighting, Unseen Fist
:Naganadel: Poison, Beast Boost
:Toxtricity: Electric, Punk Rock
:Copperajah: Steel, Sheer Force
:Darmanitan: Fire, Sheer Force
:Barbaracle:/:Lycanroc-Dusk: Rock, Tough Claws
:Conkeldurr:/:Machamp:/:Throh: Fighting, Guts
:Aurorus: Rock, Refrigerate
:Malamar: Dark, Contrary
:Ninjask: Bug, Speed Boost
:Araquanid: Water, Water Bubble
:Wailord: Water, Water Veil
:Togekiss: Fairy, Hustle
:Corsola: Water, Hustle
:Doublade: Steel, No Guard
:Galvantula:/:Butterfree: Bug, Compound Eyes
:Tyrantrum: Rock, Strong Jaw
:Boltund: Electric, Strong Jaw
:Drednaw: Water, Strong Jaw
:Dhelmise: Ghost, Steelworker
:Zoroark: Dark, Illusion
:Bisharp: Dark, Defiant
:Raichu-Alola: Electric, Surge Surfer
:Dunsparce: Normal, Serene Grace
Riders that offer defensive or supportive abilities (some can be Steeds)
:Arcanine: Fire, Intimidate
:Gyarados: Water, Intimidate
:Krookodile: Ground, Intimidate
:Stoutland:/:Tauros: Normal, Intimidate
:Hitmontop: Fighting, Intimidate
:Persian-Alola: Dark, Fur Coat
:Bewear:/:Dubwool: Normal, Fluffy
:Blissey: Normal, Natural Cure
:Roserade: Grass, Natural Cure
:Altaria: Dragon, Natural Cure
:Trevenant: Ghost, Natural Cure
:Ferrothorn: Grass, Iron Barbs
:Druddigon: Dragon, Rough Skin
:Sharpedo: Water, Rough Skin
:Volcarona: Bug, Flame Body
:Magmortar:/:Talonflame: Fire, Flame Body
:Electabuzz:/:Raichu:/:Manectric:/:Emolga: Electric, Static
:Stunfisk: Ground, Static
:Grimmsnarl: Dark, Prankster
:Whimsicott: Grass, Prankster
:Klefki: Steel, Prankster
:Salazzle: Poison, Corrosion
:Magnezone: Electric, Magnet Pull
Riders that provide immunity (some of these can be Steeds)
:Rotom: Electric, Levitate
:Flygon: Ground, Levitate
:Cryogonal: Ice, Levitate
:Bronzong: Steel, Levitate
:Claydol: Ground, Levitate
:Vikavolt: Bug, Levitate
:Weezing:/:Weezing-Galar: Poison, Levitate
:Lunatone:/:Solrock: Rock, Levitate
:Haunter: Ghost, Levitate
:Lapras:/:Vaporeon:/:Poliwrath::Politoed:/:Dracovish:/:Arctovish:/:Jellicent: Water, Water Absorb
:Heliolisk: Electric, Dry Skin
:Maractus: Grass, Water Absorb
:Jolteon:/:Dracozolt:/:Arctozolt: Electric, Volt Absorb
:Lanturn: Water, Volt Absorb
:Electivire: Electric, Motor Drive
:Pincurchin: Electric, Lightning Rod
:Centiskorch:/:Flareon:/:Ninetales: Fire, Flash Fire
:Chandelure: Ghost, Flash Fire
Riders that are primarily added for typing or movepool, but still offer an ability with situational use
:Milotic: Water, Marvel Scale
:Tentacruel: Water, Clear Body
:Toxapex: Poison, Merciless
:Shuckle:/:Crustle: Bug, Sturdy
:Aggron:/:Skarmory: Steel, Sturdy
:Gigalith: Rock, Sturdy
:Sawk: Fighting, Sturdy
:Gengar: Ghost, Cursed Body
:Froslass: Ice, Cursed Body
:Marowak-Alola: Fire, Cursed Body
:Cradily: Rock, Suction Cups
:Octillery: Water, Suction Cups
:Pangoro: Fighting, Iron Fist
:Golurk: Ground, Iron Fist
:Gastrodon: Water, Sticky Hold
:Slowbro:/:Slowking:/:Whiscash: Water, Oblivious
:Mamoswine:/:Jynx: Ice, Oblivious
:Eldegoss: Grass, Cotton Down
:Pyukumuku: Water, Innards Out
:Scrafty: Dark, Shed Skin
:Pupitar: Rock, Shed Skin
:Dragonair: Dragon, Shed Skin
:Aerodactyl:/:Onix:/:Sudowoodo: Rock, Rock Head
:Marowak:/:Rhydon: Ground, Rock Head
:Steelix: Steel, Rock Head
:Shelgon: Dragon, Rock Head
To show the vast potential of these pokemon in action, let's look at a few example combinations for one pokemon:
Flying/Steel Tornadus-T Pairings
We all know from Skarmory, Celesteela, and Corvknight what an awesome defensive typing Steel/Flying is, and in this, we can create multiple exciting versions by crossing Tornadus-T--a pokemon with Regenerator in the primary slot--with a Steel pokemon. Let's look at some options using Tornadus-Therian as a Steed:
:ss/Tornadus-Therian: + :Copperajah:/:Doublade:/:Klefki:
Stats: 79/120/100/130/110/141
Typing: Steel/Flying
Ability1: Regenerator
:Tornadus-Therian:+:Copperajah:
Sheer Force + Life Orb
Movepool Options boosted by SF: Flash Cannon/Iron Head, Air Slash/Hurricane, Heat Wave, Earth Power, Play Rough, Rock Slide, Sludge Wave, Additional Options not boosted by SF: U-turn, Heat Crash, Earthquake, Stone Edge, Brick Break/Superpower,
By using Copperajah as a Rider, Torn can deal impressive damage while simultaneously having great longevity from its typing and Regenerator
:Tornadus-Therian:+:Doublade:
No Guard, Leftovers or Choice Specs
Movepool Options boosted by NG: Hurricane, Steel Beam, Iron Tail, Heat Wave, Focus Blast, Rock Slide, Toxic
Another approach for dealing high damage from a defensive typing. It can choose to err on the defensive side to make use of fully accurate Toxics and confusion chance from reliable Hurricane, or take a wall-breaking approach. It can even use Steel Beam as a nuke that it can largely recover from thanks to Regen.
:Tornadus-Therian:+:Klefki:
Prankster, Leftovers
Priority Support Options: Spikes, Defog, Substitute, Taunt, Thunder Wave, Toxic, Switcheroo
With Klefki, Torn-T can fully lean into its defensive capabilities to make use of a multitude of priority supporting moves.
Now let's look at a set with Tornadus-Therian as the Rider
:ss/Jirachi::Tornadus-Therian:
Stats: 100/120/120/120/120/120
Typing: Flying/Steel
Ability1: Serene Grace
Ability2: Regenerator
EVs: 248 HP / 8 Atk / 252 Def
Impish Nature
- Iron Head
- Stealth Rock
- Wish
- U-turn
I made a set this time to demonstrate a specific role-- with Torn-T riding on Jirachi, it can pass large Wishes to its teammates while healing itself due to Regenerator, while also having the potential to be obnoxious through Serene Grace Iron Head.
Finally, there are also some Pokemon that may present programming problems in As One. Some rules or restrictions may be needed for these.
Special abilities
:Porygon2: Normal, Trace
:Aegislash: Steel, Stance Change
:Cofagrigus: Ghost, Mummy
:Runerigus: Ground, Wandering Spirit
:Mimikyu: Ghost, Disguise
:Cramorant: Flying, Gulp Missile
:Morpeko: Electric, Hunger Switch
:Eiscue: Ice, Ice Face
EDIT: This is fairly minor, but if this OM gets approved, a decision would also need to be made on how the As One pairing is displayed on Showdown. I think that if showdown can only show the image of one pokemon, it would actually be the Rider that gets displayed, since the two official pairings are both referred to as forms of Calyrex, rather than forms of the Steed, even though the stats are based on Glastrier/Spectrier.