Tungdil said:Of course, there are other potential reasons, like some people might subjectively think legendaries are as special as GF want.
This is the primary reason why this idea is usually put forward and one of the reasons why it's always just eye-rolled at, as some people seem to think legendaries are somehow what's "wrong" with OU (regardless of if anything is actually wrong with it), and banning them will "fix" things. At the end of the day, legendaries are just Pokemon like any other and while they tend to be stronger than the average mon, that is certainly not always the case (See: Darm-G rofl that abomination is ripping up Ubers rn).
Tungdil said:This is not necessarily true in which regards to a potential similarity with
UU. A lot of UU and RU staples are legendaries (to avoid misinterpretation, I am using the definition of
Serebii).
I'm not saying it will have the same Pokemon in it, I'm saying it has the same basic goal. The root idea is "these Pokemon are outclassed by other Pokemon, let's ban the ones that outclass them and see how they do without them". That is UU. Except instead of seeing what is actually outclassed, you just ban a subjective group of Pokemon.
Tungdil said:Concerning the problem of banning some weak legendaries and not banning strong not-legendaries, I agree with you. But supposing this meta would ever exist, there would also be a council that would determine the additional bans
I'm not saying you couldn't ban non-legendaries, I'm saying half the extra bans you'd impose are pointless because those Pokemon would be useless garbage anyway. You are unironically having to put Arcticuno and Uxie, two Pokemon so bad they are not used in PU, on a banlist for an OU-level tier. If this doesn't sound silly I don't know what does.
Tungdil said:(e.g., . :Cinderace:)
The idea this Pokemon would even be considered to be let lose to mash the Pyro Ball button on a Heatran-less tier again is a lol.
Tungdil said:Furthermore, some weak non-legendaries could become important (e.g., in the absence of :Heatran:, maybe :Incineroar: would be more relevant - sorry for this silly example). The meta would self-adjust itself.
Again, this is exactly what happens in UU (and no, nothing replaces what Heatran does offensively or defensively).
Tungdil said:People might have fun with a meta without legendaries for various reasons, for example, being able to reproduce in-game strategies, as most legendaries can't breed (and then getting perfect IVs is way more difficult).
1. Bottle Caps and Nature Mints exist now so this isn't even a problem anymore. 2. BSS exists. 3. The Gen 8 battle timer kills 6v6 gameplay anyway.
Like, I could understand this point of view in past gens, for cart gameplay only, but this simply isn't a problem anymore. Also, I personally (and a lot of other people too) find it fun to able to use Pokemon that I couldn't normally obtain in online battles, like Volcanion and Mew (and yes breeding etc is a pain, this is another reason we play online). This leads back to a common statement in this thread: metas that restrict players are much less likely to be successful and interesting than ones that add new options.
Just for the fun of it, I'll tell you what this tier looks like.
Step 1: You banned Heatran so Volcarona is now obscenely OP. That gets banned.
Step 2: The return of WishPort Clefable. Battles become a contest to deplete your opponent's Wish PP faster than you lose the will to live. Clef is banned.
Step 3: Toxapex walls everything that isn't backed by FuturePort. Banned.
Step 4: Hey, Weavile is kinda dumb isn't it?
Step 5: You just banned all the Dragapult checks didn't you?
Step 94:
S Rank
Nothing for now!
A+ Rank
Aegislash
Amoonguss
Excadrill
Primarina
Slowking
I'm of course exaggerating, but you get the point.