In light of two recent posts made by
PhantomHurious and
Crystalites I figured I should be the first to make a post defending Aurora Veil, although there really isn't that much to it; I believe Morgrem is better than Alolan Vulpix, and I think the true issue lies in almost solely one mon; Rufflet.
Rufflet has been controversial for a while, mostly because practically nothing can tank Brave Bird (particularly from the Choice Band set) and Aerial Ace is pretty easy to click mid to late game without having to care about Hustle. Since Home, however, a new set has emerged in the form of a previously niche Bulk Up set, with Roost giving it incredible survivability and set-up potential.
the set
Rufflet (M) @ Eviolite
Ability: Hustle
EVs: 240 HP / 152 Atk / 16 Def / 100 Spe (or 240 HP / 152 Atk / 40 Def / 76 Spe)
Adamant Nature
- Bulk Up
- Agility (or Substitute)
- Aerial Ace
- Roost
This was the set given to me by
Crystalites when I asked for a basic Screens team to work off of when making my own. The set in question gives you an odd HP stat (to live four rounds of Stealth Rock) and enough Defense investment to take 49.8% max from Choice Band Piloswine's Icicle Crash after two Bulk Up uses. 100 Speed allows you to outpace Jolly Sneasel after a single use of Agility, turning it into legitimate setup fodder.
Alternatively, I used this spread; EVs: 240 HP / 152 Atk / 40 Def / 76 Spe
To save you time, I moved EVs away from Speed and into Defence, just investing enough to outspeed uninvested Palpitoad. This was because I opted to run Substitute over Agility, trading that specific matchup against Sneasel (and the general speed to beat out things like Haunter) for a better matchup against weaker Knock Off users like Ferroseed and Mareanie and a way to avoid status from the likes of Galarian Corsola and the aforementioned Palpitoad that might otherwise limit your sweeping potential.
To provide some calcs on how ridiculous this mon actually is:
252+ Atk Choice Band Sneasel Icicle Crash vs. +1 240 HP / 16 Def Eviolite Rufflet: 276-326 (80.9 - 95.6%)
If you Agility or Bulk Up on the switch you can just click the other move and outstall it with Roost (and Bulk Up again when you get healthy enough or if they happen to miss).
252+ Atk Choice Band Piloswine Icicle Crash vs. +1 240 HP / 16 Def Eviolite Rufflet: 288-338 (84.4 - 99.1%)
Same deal here.
252+ Atk Piloswine Icicle Crash vs. +2 240 HP / 16 Def Eviolite Rufflet: 144-170 (42.2 - 49.8%)
If they aren't Choice Band they can't even do half to you at +2. Now factor in Reflect.
Special Attackers tend to fare better, but not much better:
252+ SpA Hattrem Psychic vs. 240 HP / 0 SpD Eviolite Rufflet: 142-168 (41.6 - 49.2%)
Hatt isn't a breaker, to be fair, but this is a good example of how solid Rufflet actually is and on how many things it can set up. Short of SpDef drops, you're not breaking past Rufflet and it's slowly building up boosts against you.
252 SpA Life Orb Haunter Sludge Bomb vs. 240 HP / 0 SpD Eviolite Rufflet: 203-239 (59.5 - 70%)
+1 152+ Atk Hustle Rufflet Aerial Ace vs. 0 HP / 4 Def Haunter: 301-355 (130.3 - 153.6%)
+1 152+ Atk Hustle Rufflet Aerial Ace vs. 0 HP / 4 Def Eviolite Haunter: 202-238 (87.4 - 103%) -- 93.8% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock
Offensive breakers do more, but it's not like you're taking an Aerial Ace.
In short, Rufflet is incredibly bulky and its checks are incredibly limited. Klang wins, but it has to be Shift Gear and get a Gear Grind crit. Mareanie wins, but it loses to the Sub variant if it doesn't have enough PP or gets hit by a stray Knock Off (fairly easy to force in this meta; just pair Rufflet with Gurdurr). Corsola-Galar, but only if you're Haze, and you still lose to Sub variants unless you use Ice Beam also. Honedge is the best check by far, but lets be honest it's pretty terrible outside of the Rufflet matchup. Faster attackers, e.g. Pikachu and Sneasel can revenge kill it, but the former is 2HKOd by Aerial Ace (i.e. not a safe switchin) and loses if Rufflet gets too many boosts (or a sub up), and Sneasel is 1v1d by the Agility variant.
This is also unboosted by Screens. When you're getting Substitute up on Piloswine, something is wrong, and Rufflet really pushes these teams into dangerous territory.
It's also worth noting that Band and Scarf sets *do* still exist and are phenomenal in their own right. Band is able to cleanly 2HKO Galarian Corsola, Mareanie etc and can suprise Klang and Carkol with Close Combat for a OHKO (assuming SpDef Carkol).
252+ Atk Choice Band Hustle Rufflet Brave Bird vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite Mareanie: 229-271 (75.5 - 89.4%) -- 12.5% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock
252+ Atk Choice Band Hustle Rufflet Aerial Ace vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Mareanie: 172-204 (56.7 - 67.3%)
252+ Atk Choice Band Hustle Rufflet Brave Bird vs. 0 HP / 4 Def Piloswine: 427-504 (125.2 - 147.8%)
Not much calcs to show for Scarf, it's just a solid cleaner, and the scariest part of Rufflet is (outside of screens) it really shares the same teammates every time, so it's not particularly easy to scout for.
For a quick note on Morgrem: If the opponent carries anything faster, or strong enough to take it Alolan Vulpix through screens (Haunter, Sneasel, Raboot, Gurdurr, Machoke, Klang etc.), it's hard to send Alolan Vulpix out at preview, and due to a lack of Eviolite it can also be hard to find set-up opportunities that don't involve trading your life in the process, particularly if the opponent isn't running any passive, defensive Pokemon (e.g. Palpitoad, Mareanie).
As an example, see this NFE Open Finals game against zugubu royale:
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nfe-1067582491-6xhj28divp70fyczgd8u09wvx7fzdmtpw
In this game, had I opted to use Alolan Vulpix, I had a much harder time setting up; Roselia speed tied and could potentially knock me out before I even got screens up. Gurdurr and Pawniard OHKOd me through screens, meaning I was effectively trading my 6th slot for 7 turns of setup. In comparison, Morgrem came out twice, didn't risk speed tying (due to Prankster) or dying (due to Screens reliably being up) and I even kept it as a soft check in the back for Gurdurr. The only reason I didn't lead with it was because I wanted to try and force an early Knock Off on Gurdurr so that Pilo could threaten it later. That clearly didn't go to plan, but enter Rufflet.
This game is also a good example of what Rufflet can do when you get screens up. If I just clicked Aerial Ace on Turn 26 I'm pretty sure it beat out Shellos, but as I didn't calc I instead clicked Aerial Ace 15 times before being forced out and later winning with Piloswine. For the record, I had a 47% chance to crit Shellos at least once in those 15 turns (math done by 84percent) so on paper it should've 6-0d if I played it right.
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen8nfe-1067416180-e5wb0anxpck6m7mllbuoh8ei3at37tfpw
Here's a friendly practice game I had with Quags in the leadup to Finals. Similarly to the last replay, Morgrem got screens up twice and lived to sack against Sneasel (securing a risk-free win). Gurdurr also forced an eventually Knock Off on Mareanie here, again giving Rufflet an easy win, with Band Sneasel only doing 30%ish with Brick Break. This is another example of Substitute Rufflet just absolutely destroying a slower team; Quags really didn't have good counterplay here and I'm not sure many Pokemon exist that fulfil this criteria.
im done talking about rufflet now
okay so i've typed up way too much already but i'm in agreement with the others that sneasel is also extremely busted, with knock off pretty much never having a drawback and icicle crash being ridiculously dangerous with eviolite off the table and it kinda necessitates gurdurr on every single build. band and swords dance are both extremely strong, and i've even made use of sash counter in the past to lure and break physical attackers.
i also believe that
gurdurr is
unhealthy, with the ability to 1v1 any pokemon in the tier and taunt sets making traditional checks like mareanie and gloom incredibly unreliable, with additional room for exploration in the form of elemental punches and substitute as soon as sneasel goes, removing the necessity for priority mach punch.
i also think haunter, machoke and trapinch should all also be looked at at some point, but rufflet, sneasel, and to a lesser extent gurdurr are higher on my list purely because of how easy they are to use and how much of an efffect they have on what does and does not constitute a defensive mon.
thanks for reading and i'll probably post more eventually.