The theme of this post is:
I never said that Raikou is broken.
Lemmiwinks MkII said:I'm getting sick of people saying that Raikou needs to be banned without providing any first-hand evidence from their battling experiences to back up their claims. I've not had any problems with it whatsoever (I've had more trouble with CM Mismagius, but still not nearly enough to consider it broken), and I am eager to see some battle logs demonstrating Raikou's overpowering brokenness. All I've seen so far is baseless, and in many cases plain wrong, theorymon arguments (see Erazor and yokie's posts above in particular).
Remember, the burden of proof is on the accuser, not the defender.
My main concern is that Raikou isn't meant for UU play. Raikou would displace the already seldom used Pokemon in obscurity. It's better suited for BL or OU play. UU play is supposed to be distinct form OU, not a peewee OU metagame. UU used to have its own style of play. 'Broken' implies that nothing can stop comfortably without severe risk. Chansey and Steelix come into Raikou with minimum risk, but obviously repeated hits will take their toll. Raikou isn't meant for UU play, not because of brokenness, but because it ruins other true UU Pokemon's chances of play like Ampharos or other Special Sweepers or even walls. Clefable has a tough time taking on Raikou, whereas before Clefable used to be the stop to nearly all UU Special attackers. Raikou is much better suited for BL/OU play, not UU. Raikou is UU would trash plenty of previously UU-viable Pokemon in the NU pits. Stop the OU-tizing.
Chris is me said:Battle logs won't prove anything either. I just don't like people claiming that listing good things about a Pokémon is a valid "it is broken" claim.
Hate Sub/CM? Then run Special Defensive Drapion! It'll be in Creative Moveset written up soon enough. Basically, EQ / Crunch / Taunt / Toxic Spikes with a ton of special defense ruins both Raikou and Mismagius and supports the team very nicely. You have to predict against Raikou a bit but otherwise it's a great set.
Also Clefable needs to stop being popular and ruining stall teams.
I'm surprised that Drapion is used at all for taking Special hits. It has 70 HP / 75 SpD with notable resistances to Grass and Ghost, and maybe Dark too (Dark attacks are usually physical). Drapion can EQ but it doesn't take +1 Thunderbolts well, especially without reliable recovery. Offensive sets like CM LO would scrap Drapion quickly.
TVboyCanti said:Raikou is starting to look like UU Garchomp. A seemingly one dimensional pokemon that has multiple effective sets (sub+lefties, specs, shuca+3 attacks, Life Orb). All of them will do a lot of damage if you try to counter the wrong set. 252/0 neutral Cladyol takes 90.12% - 106.17% damage from specs boosted Signal Beam, or it lets Raikou get 2 CMs if it Earthquakes the shuca version. If you assume its the shuca or LO version and try to status it, you risk having a sub thrown up in your face if you can't beat 115 base speed, and will forced out if you can't break the sub.
Steelix can take down all Raikous, taking 36.72% - 43.22% from +1 HP ground, though Steelix will lose to the shuca sweeper if it has taken 30% residual damage or if it isn't running Sassy nature with 252/252 sp def. For anyone that is thinking about running max sp def on claydol, that's pretty questionable considering Claydol's ground, rock and fighting resistances, and its water ice grass dark and ghost weaknesses. Chansey can beat all versions, except for the inevitable RestTaikou, although the fact that Chansey is beaten by all Resting Calm Mind tanks makes Chansey a pretty specific counter. The only other way to beat Raikou is by revenge killing it or switching in a faster threat while it uses Calm Mind. Kinda like Garchomp.
I would like to emphasize that I am not saying Steelix and Chansey are the only ways to beat Raikou, but that they're the only things that can beat all versions of Raikou. If you try to use the right counter against the wrong Raikou, you are going to get fucked. I actually came into UU thinking that it would suck or only be decent.
And if anybody posts something like "special defense Drapion counters Raikou, because I could Be Banned!" without posting damage calcs...
I don't think Raikou in UU is as dangerous are Garchomp in OU, but Raikou will likely destroy teams pretty easily without Steelix, Chansey, or Camerupt. Careful prediction applies as always. HP Grass vs Ice is real problem for CM Sub sets, so Raikou can get outsmarted.
Again, I am not saying that Raikou is broken. Raikou is better suited for BL/OU play.