I've been reading this, and I'm noticing a lot of parallels to past "broken" strategies in other games. First of all, it's pretty clear that something's wrong when you have to run multiple checks/counters to deal with a single strategy in a metagame (assuming that strategy isn't something completely basic to the game, like using stall, which the extremely specialized RD certainly isn't). The post about how using sun is more powerful with everyone prepared for rain emphasizes this: it's possible to take advantage of the metagame by knowing that everyone has to be prepared for rain, the counter-counter strategy. To give you guys a comparison to work off of; in the Magic the Gathering a few years back there was a single dominating deck, called Ravager Affinity. It was very regimented in that it absolutely HAD to contain artifact lands, Arcbound Ravager, Disciple of the Vault, and supporting artifact cards. There were MANY ways to check or partially counter Ravager Affinity, even sometimes without compromising your own deck's integrity, but they were far from reliable. To quote a player from the era, Brian Kibler:
The reason why I'm playing Affinity is because everyone thinks that their decks deal with Affinity, and they honestly don't. ...you win nearly every single game 1 matchup in the format, and then games 2 and 3 are usually 50/50 or 60/40 against you, which is still pretty good odds when you are already up a game.
.
If you're wondering about the reference to games 2 and 3, it's because competitive Magic has you play with a "core" deck for the first game of every match and then a sideboard of 15 cards that can be switched in between games in a set.
In any case, this strategy WAS counterable (some decks based around nothing BUT countering it grew up and thrived during this era), but that didn't stop Ravager Affinity from being completely and utterly broken. If this example doesn't help because it's focusing on a different game, then let's bring up the famous issue of Garchomp. It had checks and counters as well: dual Ice Sharders for a revenge kill could usually take it down. That didn't stop it from being a huge centralizing force in the metagame, and powerful enough that it was banned.
That's all, really. I've seen things like this come up in the past, and I'm sure they will in the future.