I haven't had one of these debates in months.
Yeah, and with a 33.3% chance of hitting rest, close combat, plus a 15% chance to miss megahorn, I am pretty sure ghosts will happily switch in on Heracross. Zapdos, I'll give you. But you can't deny that losing pursuit/stone edge really takes a way a lot of the scare power.
It's not like the Ghosts in question can actually beat Heracross before being on the likely end of a Guts Megahorn.
Froslass's Ice Beam does 35% maximum, it's not likely to 3HKO Heracross. The only way it's likely is if Heracross lands a Life Orb Megahorn on it, but that way Froslass feints anyway. It would honestly have to risk switching in .33x.85 chance of dying in order to just Taunt Heracross. It would have to switch out immediately after. It's only a good switch in for the Scarf variant ironically, since it can take every single attack CS Cross has.
Mismagius is in a similar boat but it can 3HKO Heracross. The only problem is that it's switching in and it needs to 2HKO Hercross otherwise Heracross wakes up and, again, kills it. Substitute works well though, but again, switching in with more than ~30% chance to die.....a counter?
When did I ever deny that losing Pursuit and Stone Edge takes away a lot of power? Pursuit in particular is one of the most useful Heracross tools simply BECAUSE it can otherwise beat these ghosts one on one.
Mishra said:
My point was that if I see a life orb, heracross is no longer scary. When you see a heracross on the oppisite team, unless you already know there are 2 scarfes, the assumption is the cross is scarfed, not only because it is, imo, its best set, but it is the most common set. Who cares if it can switch moves, if it only has two to choose from? If you want to roll the dice with rest talk, that's fine with me.
My point was that you made a baseless assumption about the observational skills of the average opponent. You cannot prove that people overlook the Band's power and assume Scarf or lack of power and still assume Band....when they don't ignore Life Orb recoil. I can prove that there is a difference in power and that people can tell the difference.
If you use a move other than Close Combat / Megahorn more than ~20% of the time then you are not using Heracross to its fullest potential. Those two moves are its bread and better. One takes out 90% of the Pokemon that would switch into the other. Not that Pursuit and Stone Edge don't help, but they are by no means "necessary".
Who cares if it switches moves? What happens when Slowbro switches into CC and you're forced out because you can't switch moves? What happens when Registeel switches into Megahorn? Those Pokemon can no longer
ever switch in safely. This is why basically
every set uses a Life Orb over Choice Band/Specs UNLESS there is something gained by the HP retained or by the extra 2% of damage given. In Heracross's case, there is, so the Band is definitely a more than viable option. However that doesn't rule out Life Orb.
And discussing Scarf here basically irrelevant they are two different sets doing two very different things. That is a different discussion altogether (not that I won't have it, it's just not exactly relevant right now).
Mishra said:
My claims are valid. A base 85 heracross is much less threatening then a scarfed, ~400 speed cross. Losing the coverage moves are also bad. Sure, you can hit harder then the band set, sometimes, but the band is more reliable in comparison.
Ignoring the strengths of the set you're criticizing while over-exaggerating the weakness does not make your claims valid.
A base 85 Heracross with the ability to KO and beat Heracross' (and most importantly, other Pokemon's) usual counters is not anywhere near "much less threatening" then the Scarfed set. Gaining immense switch-in capabilities and power is not anywhere near "bad" compared to the reliability of the Choice Band set.
No set is "much" better than the other. Maybe you prefer the Scarf set, but that does not mean the other sets are bad.
EDIT: On a different note, I haven't even seen Victini on the ladder since last round.