I havent been talking about prediction at all. I just stated that all the examples brought here regarding 50/50 arent 50/50 because there is a huge risk/reward component involved in each and everyone of them and therefor there is a right play to make. And whats more, the risks for the Aegiplayer were always higher than for his opponent.Please do not think that because you seem to have some mastery prediction skills that are able to transcend all the random factors that a person goes through before making a decision, that Aegislash does not promote more 50/50s. You did not explain anything, you used your opinion to say that people should be able to predict what their opponent will do and assess the risk/reward of each play, well congrats that is what every competent player already knows. What we are saying is that despite all those factors the predictions are too convoluted around aegislash at this point, you could assess and predict all you want but when Aegislash is involved he could pick any move and he could just guess randomly because the Aegislash user knows that the mindgames are too convoluted to make any reasonable prediction.
And yes every competent player should be able to see the risk/reward aspect in those szenarios but nonetheless they are brought up over and over again and claimed to be 50/50s. You yourself claimed that Conk vs Aegi is a 50/50 totaly ignoring that Conk is always better of in that situation even IF he runs into KS as even a -2 Knockoff does more damage to Aegi (in addition to knocking off his precious Lefties) as Aegi does to Conk. And all those random factors and mindgames simply dont matter, if you asses the risks and rewards of each play correctly and pick the best course of action you will be just fine even if you misspredict. Thats the whole point of it.
If you want to use the 50/50 against argument against Mawile and Bisharp and their Sucker Punch i am totaly with you, they realy create 50/50 a hell of alot and i wouldnt mind at all if Sucker Punch got banned because of it. But KS is a completely different story.
Last edited: