I bash A-Rod because the expectations are high and he fails to produce. He was hurt for part of the year, but he did have a mediocre year. Keep in mind that of A-Rods 11 outs in the postseason, 7 are Ks, which is an absurd amount. Cano may be struggling in the playoffs, but that is only three games, and he was on a torrid pace coming in. He was their best hitter all year as well. Granderson is proving himself to be an Adam Dunn type, and those tend to go on hot/cold stretches. If he has a big homer, people will tend to excuse the low average, at least somewhat.
As an O's fan, I'm more afraid of game 5 than tonight's game. We have Saunders on the mound, who has been hot lately, and I'm finding that the Yankees tend to be a bit worse against lefties (Ichiro, Cano, Swisher, and Granderson [as well as Ibanez and Chavez off the bench] all do better vs righties IIRC). Game 5, the Yankees get to throw CC out there and some of our bullpen arms (Johnson, O'Day, Matusz) could be a little tired if they go tonight. We'll also have a righty on the mound (I'm assuming Hammel goes again, but Buck might elect to go with Tillman, as he has not announced a starter yet). I know we need to get by game 4 first, but I am worried even if we get by game 4. I think though, that what this series has shown, is how evenly matches these two teams have been, which is why my gut says the Orioles win tonight and force an all-or-nothing game 5.