^sorry about doing this, Acast, but i missed this discussion, and I have been preaching about a Scizor ban for weeks if not months on PS!.
Articuno I said:There was a large discussion on Scizor and Mega Scizor a while ago, with emphasis on how it treated ice. The conclusion was that firstly, Scizor could be beaten, only Mega Scizor was unbeatable. Secondly, only Ice loses to Mega Scizor. Talonflame was banned because it was stopping three types from being able to do anything, and moreover that two of those types would be good were it not for Talonflame. Mega Scizor only truely stops one type from doing well, and that type will unfortunately still be bad even if we were to ban Mega Scizor. For that reason, I'm not going to be supporting a Scizorite suspect anytime soon.
The problem with Scizor isn't only his ability to decimate Ice teams, but Rock teams lacking Mega-Aggron[which most are], Fairy, and even Dragon teams. Scizor is a monster. It has the offensive prowess of a sweeper and the defenses of a wall coupled with recovery, strong priority and unresisted coverage. You can't ask for a much better mon in this tier.
When we look at their base stats, we see:
Hit Points: 70 Hit Points: 70
Attack:
130 Attack:
150
Defense:
100 Defense:
140
Special Attack: 55 Special Attack: 65
Special Defense:
80 Special Defense:
100
Speed: 65 Speed: 75
These base stats are insane. When we look at Scizor, we see that a LO + Swords Dance set can plow through teams, while Mega-Scizor has the bulk to set up multiple Swords Dances to proceed with a sweep. Since you guys have deemed Mega-Scizor too powerful, I will be giving calcs against a regular, LO Scizor. Note that I will be using one spread for all of the calcs to avoid criticism and bias.
Ice:
It has already been established that Scizor destroys Ice, so I won't be redundant here.
Rock:
I have just seen that, even with Mega-Aggron, Rock has no real defense against Scizor, because Scizor can set up against common Rock mons, such as Cradily, Diancie, and Terrakion.
252 Atk Terrakion Stone Edge vs. 248 HP / 140+ Def Scizor: 129-153 (37.6 - 44.6%) -- 2% chance to 2HKO after Stealth Rock
Given his spread, Scizor can set up to +4 on Terrakion while baiting a Stone Edge Miss, and then proceed to sweep, OR the Rock user can switch out the Aggron, as Scizor sets up a Swords Dance, and set up another Swords Dance on the Fire Punch.
0 Atk Mega Aggron Fire Punch vs. 248 HP / 140+ Def Scizor: 228-272 (66.4 - 79.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock
+4 116 Atk Life Orb Scizor Superpower vs. 248 HP / 8+ Def Filter Mega Aggron: 298-353 (86.8 - 102.9%) -- 56.3% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock
One rocks switch in and thats basically a dead Aggron, if Aggron was even being run. At this point, nothing can survive a +2 or +3 Bullet Punch, and Scizor can be switched out at a rocks HP to roost back later if possible or just go for that final KO once Life Orb and Fire Punch have eaten its health.
Fairy:
Fairy literally has zero switch ins to Scizor. If Scizor comes in, something dies. If you stay in to try and damage it, it can set up. Azumarill and Klefki CANNOT switch in. Yes, Azumarill and Klefki can win in a 1 v 1 scenario, but they are NOT the counters. I've heard users say: "Just set up Reflect with Klefki and switch out to another mon." How does this even make sense? I set up Reflect, take a Bullet Punch on the switch, and take another one the next turn to make the screens useless? "Just run HP Fire." Hello? Scizor EATS non stab HP Fires for breakfast, and can set up on the HP Fire user. In this case, lets say that the HP Fire user is Sylveonl.
252+ SpA Choice Specs Sylveon Hidden Power Fire vs. 248 HP / 0 SpD Scizor: 464-548 (135.2 - 159.7%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Oh, look, HP Fire OHKOs this spread(it won't to Mega, but thats a different story), but it doesn't matter because Scizor is FASTER.
Assuming that Scizor had set up on the switch(and if he didn't he has Heatran on Steel and Volcarona/Armaldo Bug to switch out to), Scizor OHKOs Sylveon.
252+ SpA Choice Specs Sylveon Hidden Power Fire vs. 248 HP / 0 SpD Scizor: 464-548 (135.2 - 159.7%) -- guaranteed OHKO
At that point, nothing really survives unless Klefki sets up screens and the Scizor user is bad.
Scizor is by no means unbeatable on Fairy, but it gets a kill EVERY time that it comes in WITHOUT good merit of counter play, which is something that I say so often. There are solid answers to Scizor on Fairy, but they require: a team member-a team member, NOT a move-slot and/or a semi incompetent Scizor user. Unaware Clefable CAN be used, but it can only be utilized as a check, and it is hard walled by every Steel teammate nonetheless, while allowing Bug to easily counter play with Mega-Pinsir on the Flamethrower sack. Another option to use is Mawile, as it is usefull against Steel in general, but that is a wasted slot. I have used Mawile on Fairy, and get rocks up with it maybe 3-5/10 battles, depending on the matchup. In fact, I often times see myself using Mawile as a sack. My spread is irrelevant, but I'll share it with y'all, because the spread is a joke, just like the fact that a type must sacrifice a TEAM slot to be able to check a single threat.
Open for Ungodly set
WheresMyMegaStone? (Mawile) (M) @ Life Orb
Ability: Sheer Force
Happiness: 69
EVs: 248 HP / 64 Def / 40 SpA / 156 SpD
Sassy Nature
- Stealth Rock
- Iron Head
- Fire Blast
- Super Fang
This set allows it to survive an Earth Power from Mega-Diancie most of the time. It can 2HKO Spd Mega Tyranitar and Togekiss, does about 70-75% to Skarmory, and can OHKO 248 HP Mega-Scizor AFTER Spikes. It can check +2 252+ Mega-Scizor after about two rocks switch ins.
Dragon:
Dragon has so many many choiced locked mons, so a +2 set up is easy. No, tank Chomp is not a valid Scizor counter, because tank Chomp doesn't have recovery, and I wouldn't be setting up a Scizor if tank chomp wasn't at the OHKO range.
+2 116 Atk Life Orb Scizor Bullet Punch vs. 0 HP / 0- Def Kyurem-B: 346-408 (88.4 - 104.3%) -- guaranteed OHKO after Stealth Rock
(i'll update these later if needed, I have to go to work :s)