Skankovich said:Except none of them really like eating up a foul play? The top two fighting types in the tier both struggle more with umbreon than with pory2 yet it's 2 ranks higher. They're also commonly choiced, which again gives umbreon the advantage. If pory isn't running tri attack umbreon hits every common fighting type harder on the switch, and if it is running tri attack it's not running thunder wave which honestly just leaves it outclassed. Thunder Wave is really nice I'll admit, which makes pory harder to play around, but it's still not enough to prove to me that umbreon deserves to be so much lower than pory when its utility lets it be far more splashable.
I agree Umbreon should be B+ for it's specially defensive set. It is a much more reliable switch in to M-Pidge due to Leftover recover, and the Work Up sets are Punished hard by Foul Play. In addition, Synchronize is such a useful ability, which cripples scald spammers such as Empoleon, Tentacruel, and Swampert, and it makes people think twice before clicking Toxic. The Specially Defensive set also takes on Alakazam much more reliably than P2, which is in danger of being KOed with prior damage + psyshock + focus blast. Umbreon, due to immunity to Psyshock and LEftovers, and Wish stall Zam till it switches or runs out of focus blasts. SubCm Chandelure, while literally hard walled by Trace P2, can PP stall P2 whereas Umbreon can smack it with Foul Play. Finally, it can Wish Pass, which means it can support its team better than P2 (however T-Wave is really nice for P2)
The Phys Def set isn't worth it IMO. P2 does it much much better due to T-wave and better bulk.
+1 252 Atk Salamence Outrage vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Umbreon: 204-241 (51.9 - 61.3%) -- 96.9% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
+1 252 Atk Salamence Outrage vs. 248 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite Porygon2: 156-184 (41.7 - 49.1%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
Although I personally am a fan of Mixed P2, which blanket checks much more things better than SpD or PhysD P2
+1 252 Atk Salamence Outrage vs. 248 HP / 204 Def Eviolite Porygon2: 178-211 (47.7 - 56.5%) -- 87.5% chance to 2HKO
P2 can then T-wave and Recover spam, whereas Umbreon must take an Outrage to kill Salamence
Also M-Pidgeot needs to be S rank. Aero doesn't even check it that well since it can't switch in without being pressured to Roost if rocks are up. Plus it risks confusehax. Every team NEEDS a Pidgeot switch in or it will be destroyed. The argument that Aero is keeping Pidgeot out of S rank is really stupid, especially since you can slap a Cune, Bronzong, Swampert, Hippo or any other check and call it a day,