YABO said:I really don't see Mega Pidgeot as S-Rank material. If you really want to get nitty gritty with it just look at its stats. 83/80/80 defenses with a typing that leaves much to be desired alongside a middling speed stat and not too much power backing it up. That previous sentence is a jumbled mess of all the foreseeable downsides of Mega Pidgeot so I'll get into them a little bit here. 83/80/80 defenses AFTER the mega evolution. Prior to mega evolving you're left with and even worse 83/75/70 stat distribution. This is pretty poor for something that usually has an argument of natural bulk thrown into why it's so good all the time.
For example, the once touted absolute best Mega Pidgeot set was the whole "Fuck Stall it's lame and I hate it so I'm going to run only Hurricane and a bunch of other shit set", still working on the name. Anyways, it was the Work Up + Refresh set that supposedly ran over Balance and Stall. This set, like any other Pidgeot set, struggles from lacks of opportunity. Pidgeot thrives when it is facing up against passive mons that it can switch in safely on and threaten out. THERE ARE NONE IN THIS TIER. That's a bit of an exaggeration but when you really look at it am I wrong? Defensive Scalds are doing upwards of 30% while threatening burns, Florges' moonblast does almost half and lowers Special Attack, Krookodile's Dread Plate Knock Off does over half, etc. There is nothing for it to come in on, especially pre mega.
This ties into Pidgeot's shitty defensive typing. Normal/Flying is garbage in this tier, lets be honest. You pack an immunity to ghost (Oh Boy!), a resistance to grass (neato!), and an immunity to ground (this is actually useful). At the same time, you're subjecting yourself to getting smacked around by Electric moves (not too relevant), Ice types (Hello Mamoswine), and hard body rock types (the always mentioned Mega Aerodactyl). On paper, 2 immunities and a resist is great but in practice not so much. What even uses Ghost type moves? Off the top of my head you have Chandelure and thats about it, not much of a consolation as Fire Blast damn near OHKO's you.
252+ SpA Chandelure Fire Blast vs. 4 HP / 0 SpD Mega Pidgeot: 258-304 (83.7 - 98.7%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
Grass types of the tier include Chesnaught, Roserade, and Tangrowth. Two of these sleep you as you come in, and one of them does a fuck ton with Sludge Bomb (Hint: It's Roserade). Now the Ground immunity is actually really nice, as it is with all Flying-types. However, when you look at it, the ground types of the tier still threaten Mega Pidgeot and it really doesn't want to come in. Swampert threatens Scald burn while dealing 30%, nothing to scoff at. In addition, Swampert could very well mega evolve itself and fucking demolish Pidgeot with a strong attack. Krookodile deals over half with Dread Plate Knock Off while not getting killed by Hurricane even after rocks. Finally, Gligar at the very least guarantees momentum for your team by chewing a Hurricane before U-turning out (Substitute variants are a nightmare for Gligar). So all in all here, middling bulk + garbage typing leave a lot to be desired.
Now, this third point also ties in to the previous ones. Pidgeot can't Mega evolve safely. If you've played with Pidgeot you know exactly what I'm talking about. Unless you're against some slow ass team then it is a pain in the ass to mega evolve. This is obviously due to the shitty bulk and typing that I just talked about. This point holds especially true versus offensive teams. Offense can pretty much OHKO Pidgeot whenever it gets to fire off a hit. This is true so much so that especially on the ladder, Pidgeot users attempt to evolve turn 1 against the lead (smart). However, simple tweaks make Pidgeot utterly useless by OHKOing it with TBolt from Azelf. From there it Hurricanes against something and then dies because it isn't strong enough to OHKO that many things.
These arguments thus far still fail to mention any of the counters in the tier such as Ampharos, Aerodactyl, Empoleon, Porygon2, Blissey (some sets), Florges (kinda), among others. Furthermore, you're still taking up your mega slot and all these together make for something that isn't quite S Rank material. For anybody who is having trouble against Mega Pidgeot I would suggest to play proactively and not re-actively. No shit you're going to get beat by it if you try to switch in on Hurricanes every time. Force that motherfucker to roost instead of hitting you and your problems are solved. Either that or bring an Ampharos and laugh as you get free momentum every time it comes in.
edit: holy fuck thsi got really long really fast
Pidgeot Stays A+ or wherever it is I didn't check.
I just going to say one more thing as you have made a very compelling argument and everything you have said are facts. The confusion hax
ARE enough to put M-pidge into S rank. I've seen it not once but multiple times flip a game on its head because a special wall got confusion. Hurricane is a really good move, that's why to balance it out, game freak gave it 70% accuracy. Its powerful and easy to spam with Pidge and with this meta where electric types are rarely on a team and rocks types can't take special hits. This pokemon is not skilled based. Its easy to use and easy to spam. It has a set to beat stall while still keeping the same offensive pressure but leaving you susceptible to steal types.
Last thing and I'll shut up about this. Pidgeot has 101 base speed. It can get the mega off on a lot of pokemon. The bulk is not enough to tank moves but its can't get KOd by most pokemons stabs leaving it able to 2hko or KO. Predicting the roost is risky af! you could lose a heracross or a roserade because of it. Pidgeot is usually in a position where is can just spam Hurricane. What rank do you think Pidge would be if it couldn't confuse? I think it would be A+. Thats all. I really am shutting up now. I kinda just wanted to bash Lord of the Bay's argument with Maero.
Lord of Bays said:I do think Pidgeot is a top tier threat. That's why I agree that it is in A+ and not something like B-. But confusion hax is NOT enough to let Pidgeot beat all its answers. If it always confused and you always hit yourself like some of you are very clearly acting like it does, then Pidgeot would belong in S as defensive answers would no longer be viable, you would HAVE to use a Pokemon that outsped, which is limited to a few of our Megas (including Aero) Crobat, and any number of Scarfers. Even then, I wouldn't look down on someone who thought Aerodactyl was reason to not use Pidgeot, because as Pidgeot gets better Aero gets better even faster because it is such a good counter.
For the record, every time I've run Mega Pidgeot and my opponent has had Aerodactyl, Pidgeot at best put some pressure on his team and at worst did absolutely nothing but get forced out every time it was in before it landed a single meaningful blow. Lastly, luck is not a good argument for placing as fragile as Pidgeot. Suicune, Quagsire, Swampert: All of these Pokemon has very serious bulk that lets them fish constantly for Scald burns. Mega Pidgeot needs a first or second turn Confusion AND the self-hit or it gets shredded like tissue paper.
You switch your infamous Aero into a hurricane and by some string of luck you get confusion. The pidge switches out into its Mero counter (most teams have it) as you get confused on the roost. You can't stay in and your survivability has greatly decreased. Pidgeot is the greatest underdog there ever was because you can make so many mistakes but ultimately win because of confusion hax. The speed is great even before mega. Read above for my argument against a more precise rebuttal. I'm done with your Maero argument. It is not a valid argument in the slightest. I've stated why and I won't repeat myself.