I'm on the fence with dynamaxing, I do think the mechanic opens up a lot of interesting builds and helps a lot of pokemon muscle their way into viability, but that's kinda the issue.. it lets pokemon muscle through would-be solutions to them, and in the case of already decent ones, thats terrifying.
Counterplay is pretty restricted to using your own pokemon with max guard moves to stall out the dynamax turns, but then you're still looking at a sweeper without a direct way of switching out to stop it from setting up more and sweeping as a base mon, not accounting all the bonuses it got from using the max moves (speed, weather, damage).
I'm just not sure whether or not its as broken as believed to be, there's obviously some major abusers like gyarados, and some meh dynamaxes. Is the list of stuff thats just too much to handle big enough to take the mechanic removal approach, or small enough to just cherry pick out hard abusers similar to SM Z-moves (dyna Gyarados being this gen's Z-draco Naganadel)? In national OU, I can see nearly half of previous OU being way too difficult to counter without either running the same defensive cores every game to deal with them or straight up losing team select immidiately (volcarona vs. a nonchansey team comes to mind, especially since heatran can't phase it, also kartana, by the time you deal with them, the damage is already done and half your team is missing.), but in galar OU, I think the what-the-actual-fuck pool is a lot lower.
EDIT: Side note - Aegislash feels way less effective. Its still good as a defensive switch in, but I feel like thats it, it can't beat some of the dynamax pokemon head-on and it can't utilitize dynamax well itself beyond just to stall turns with its stats and max guard. 50/50s aren't too much of a concern because a lot of pokemon that do make contact with it either still threaten it, or can setup followed by a dynamax dark move that aegislash can't one shot to retaliate. Bisharp got a lot better with the King's Shield nerf, and with nothing to switch into knock off, aegislash switching out isn't as free as it used to be with mega stones and z-crystals. The only thing is that it still hard walls a lot of potential pokemon that would shine (namely hawlucha) but not an unhealthy amount like ORAS (where half the tier didn't exist on account of how ridiculously hard aegislash blocked them, and from memory most of the ones brought up were megas with celebi, starmie, and hawlucha anyway). Confident a lot of what he's currently walling wouldn't make OU material without him, or would open the flood gates to making a few other things in the tier a bit too much (D-max hawlucha). I think the fact somebody hit #1 without using it says a lot compared to X/Y where aegislash was being splashed on every team and a lot of what decided a team's viability was if an aegislash was on it to handle the metagame.
Counterplay is pretty restricted to using your own pokemon with max guard moves to stall out the dynamax turns, but then you're still looking at a sweeper without a direct way of switching out to stop it from setting up more and sweeping as a base mon, not accounting all the bonuses it got from using the max moves (speed, weather, damage).
I'm just not sure whether or not its as broken as believed to be, there's obviously some major abusers like gyarados, and some meh dynamaxes. Is the list of stuff thats just too much to handle big enough to take the mechanic removal approach, or small enough to just cherry pick out hard abusers similar to SM Z-moves (dyna Gyarados being this gen's Z-draco Naganadel)? In national OU, I can see nearly half of previous OU being way too difficult to counter without either running the same defensive cores every game to deal with them or straight up losing team select immidiately (volcarona vs. a nonchansey team comes to mind, especially since heatran can't phase it, also kartana, by the time you deal with them, the damage is already done and half your team is missing.), but in galar OU, I think the what-the-actual-fuck pool is a lot lower.
EDIT: Side note - Aegislash feels way less effective. Its still good as a defensive switch in, but I feel like thats it, it can't beat some of the dynamax pokemon head-on and it can't utilitize dynamax well itself beyond just to stall turns with its stats and max guard. 50/50s aren't too much of a concern because a lot of pokemon that do make contact with it either still threaten it, or can setup followed by a dynamax dark move that aegislash can't one shot to retaliate. Bisharp got a lot better with the King's Shield nerf, and with nothing to switch into knock off, aegislash switching out isn't as free as it used to be with mega stones and z-crystals. The only thing is that it still hard walls a lot of potential pokemon that would shine (namely hawlucha) but not an unhealthy amount like ORAS (where half the tier didn't exist on account of how ridiculously hard aegislash blocked them, and from memory most of the ones brought up were megas with celebi, starmie, and hawlucha anyway). Confident a lot of what he's currently walling wouldn't make OU material without him, or would open the flood gates to making a few other things in the tier a bit too much (D-max hawlucha). I think the fact somebody hit #1 without using it says a lot compared to X/Y where aegislash was being splashed on every team and a lot of what decided a team's viability was if an aegislash was on it to handle the metagame.
Last edited: