Stitch98 said:Will regional evolutions be added when Sw/Sh are out?
Samtendo09 said:I'm not part of the council or anything, but Aquatic said no on the Pet Mod Discord server, as he simply don't want new evolutions involved into the Regional Variants project. Although it can be done in a separate Pet Mod called Regional Evolutions, or being part of an evolution related Pet Mod. Just not as part of this Pet Mod here.
Back when Obstagoon and then Sirfetch'd were revealed, I'd thought that the Regional Variants Pet Mod could also introduce Regional Evolutions in the Gen 8 Regional Variants (assuming Aquatic or a replacing leader will carry it on for Gen 8)...
But as the quotes above tells you, no, Aquatic doesn't want Regional Evolutions involved in this Pet Mod. Several users of the Pet Mod Discord server and I accepted his decision as is, and this will not change in the foreseeable future. After all, it is about giving Regional Variants, not evolutions.
But what could we do for the Regional Evolutions, then? One way to go is to make a Pet Mod exclusivity about Regional Evolutions, but only as a separate, unaffiliated project rather than as a side-project of Regional Variants. Or even part of any Pet Mod involving giving new Evolutions for old Pokémon. But in either case, in a way of "standard Pikachu evolves into Alolan Raichu in Alola, but into regular Raichu everywhere else" method, to avoid stepping on Regional Variants Pet Mod's toes.
In other words, an AU situation, where ideas from Regional Variants cannot be used for the Regional Evolution Pet Mods, and vice versa.
This idea is not made to spite Aquatic or the entire Regional Variants Pet Mod, but rather fulfill a hole people wanted to make ideas of; Regional Evolutions. After all, they are cross-generational evolutions because it grants a new, generally stronger addition to a family line with only one or two stages. Pokémon being part of the evolutionary lines of three stages obviously can't receive one.
I don't think I am up for the task to lead this Pet Mod idea (though I would not mind being part of the potential Council), but for anyone willing to lead this idea, let me know. Usual slates and usual conducts aside, here's how it should work in theory.
- Since in Sword and Shield, the Regional Evos comes from the Regional Variants, you may have fairly more liberty on the Typing, the stats, the Abilities and even design of the evolution compared to standard evolutions. Be sure to keep it faithful to the original Pokémon and not make it completely different.
- As there are other regions involved, the upcoming National OU clauses will be utilized instead of the upcoming standard Galar Dex clauses.
- Be warned that this means past OU threats like the Tapus, Magearna and the ever infamous Landorus-T will also be available. As such, to take the National Tiers' Pokémon into consideration instead of Galar OU.
- Like Regional Variants Pet Mod, lores and flavors are the main priority, so there's no need to make it OU viable. Performing better than its' pre-evo is generally a better idea to go (so take Eviolite into consideration), but not to a broken level.
- Not every one-stage or two-stage Pokémon needed an evolution, so those who already works well in OU like Mimikyu, Pelipper, Skarmory, Excadrill and especially Volcarona don't need one.
- This may be an exception for those who were very good thanks to their Mega Evolution but then will inevitably lost their values after the retirement of Mega Evolution (as of this writing), which are Sableye, Mawile, Medicham and Lopunny. In this case, they could receive a Regional Evo, but those potential evos must have a playstyle that is different from the respective Mega Evolutions. This also applies to Kangaskhan, whose Mega Evolution is Uber to begin with.
- This will also applies to Pokémon that were one-staged or two-staged with BST lower than 520, and still isn't in OU despite getting a Mega Evolution. The following are Abomasnow, Absol, Altaria, Audino, Banette, Camerupt, Glalie, Houndoom, Manetric, Sharpedo and Slowbro. Again though, making them OU viable is not the absolute priority.
- Those who performs exceptionally well in either National OU or Galar OU because of the Dynamax mechanic will be an exception.
- Do take the Dynamax mechanic into consideration; while it only last for three turns, the extra HP and Max Move effects can end up making an innocuous-looking submission into a broken mess.
- Like in Regional Variants, don't give an insane stat or two unless you give them a serious drawback (i.e. massive Speed but average or even bad Abilities). The Council will have a right to warn any submission that went too far, and even lead to the submission in question to be disqualified if the submitter does not comply or doesn't fix the submission correctly.
- Likewise, tier 5 Abilities (based on AAA Ability viability list) are strongly discouraged, Wonder Guard is banned (or should be done very cautiously for a Shedinja evo), and legendary exclusive Moves and Abilities cannot be given at all.
- Like before, don't use ideas based of submissions that had won from the current Regional Variants Pet Mod.
As it will take place in Gen 8, the NatDex will be there, but whether or not Mega Evos and Z-Moves returns or if Dynamax/Gigantamax will be used instead is up to the host's own decision.
Any questions or suggestions?
UPDATE (2019-11-05): Aquatic maintain his stance on Regional Evos; no, they still won't be created for the Regional Variant Pet Mod, since it will end up shifting focus. The good news is, yes, he allows for a sister Pet Mod where we
can make Regional Evolutions while keeping up with evolutionary logics, i.e. no evos for a third stage.
This allows the winner stage 1 and stage 2 Regional Variants, preferably those with lower than average BST, to gain a whole new Regional Evolution. Keep in mind about Eviolite if you want to make your defensive Regional Evolution not to get overshadowed by your defensive "Now NFE" Regional Variant. Like I said, since it involves multiple regions, it would be downright illogical to not use the National OU clause.