Arael said:Well, the mormons were a religious group that was violating the law; if this Prop 8 gets rejected, the homossexuals won't violate *anything*; the State endorses them the right to marry, so what's the problem?
Okay, I know the problem: Marriage is a religious ritual, it's sacred, no homo, yadda yadda. But then, it's more of a matter about the state-church separation than the gays (or mormons) themselves.
The problem is what i posted above, it takes away more rights of the people that have already voted against it. It takes away the church's right or freedom of speech and anyone's freedom of speech for that matter. If it fails it will open up for anyone saying anything against gay marriage to be charged with a hate crime. That violates the freedom of speech. They have the freedom to call themselves married. They have the freedom to say whatever they want. But it isnt right for them to be able to say that anyone that is against gay marriage is guilty of a hate crime. I dont care if they want to go and have a wedding ceremony, thats fine.
“ In Madison, Wisconsin, a recovered homosexual who had left the “gay” lifestyle to start a family got into a heated discussion with an open homosexual about homosexuality at a gas station. The ex-“gay” man, David Ott, was holding his child in his arms during the entire incident, and neither man touched the other. The homosexual activist later told police he had felt threatened by Ott, and local prosecutors charged the man with “disorderly conduct” with a “hate crimes” enhancement. The “hate crime” aspect, stemming from Ott’s belief that homosexuality is morally wrong, raised the potential fine from $1,000 to $10,000, and jail time went up from a possible 90 days to one year. Fearing the possibility of substantial jail time, Ott settled, and received 50 hours of community service plus a mandatory attendance at “tolerance” sessions conducted by
lesbians at the
University of Wisconsin at Madison. A ground rule for the session was the premise that homosexual behavior is not immoral.
The entire process cost Ott almost $7,000 in legal fees.
[56]
That is wrong. He once sided with the other man and still was charged.
The issue here is not about letting them have ceremonies. They can go and have friends and familey gather to marry them. The prop only doesnt recognize it as a legal marriage. I call myself married and I havrent signed any paper or had a wedding, but i still consider myself married to Syberia. But to be able to toss someone into jail over this issue is wrong or to force someone's child to be taught about it when the parents dont want it is wrong.
Surgo said:The implication here is that it's totally okay for them to take their kids to a straight wedding (I went to one of my teacher's weddings, before gay marriage was even talked about), but not a gay wedding? What?
Actually no. I have never heard of a school having a field trip to any wedding and it has no business what so ever in school, straight or not. No wedding is relevant to education. I would not have my kid going to a teachers wedding during school time. A class has no business at all attending a wedding and im sure schools wouldnt consider a straight wedding worthy of having a field trip to. If i were a principal i would not allow field trips to even a straight wedding. A teacher'
s personal life is outside of school. None of my teachers ever invited students to their weddings and i had a few get married. So no it doe34s not imply that it would be ok for a straight wedding. I repeat, it is not ok for a school to have a field trip to any wedding. Before this prop, field trips to teacher's weddings were unheard of. I went through school, spcifcifically life studies classes, and they never once talked about marriage. If they didnt talk about it then then they dont need to talk about it now. I would be prefictally fine with schools not talking about marriage at all and they can call tehm civil unions instead if tehy mention them.