A Cake Wearing A Hat said:Please expect a response to this in three days' time. It needs to be discussed with the dev team.
Please do not purposefully express intent to wait out the timer in battle for the express purpose of angering your opponent.
Fair request, I'll be a better sport in the future.
pyuk said:I have to disagree that that replay demonstrates a lack of available counterplay. Instead of going for the Tera Dark Poison Touch Knock Off, you opted to lock yourself into Gunk Shot which not only does less damage but also has lower accuracy and thus a lower chance to poison, to say nothing of the fact that Cosmic Power Deoxys-Defense is always Tera Steel. You also wasted Orthworm’s HP when Muk didn’t need to be pivoted in. Deoxys wasn’t going to use Stored Power after one Cosmic Power against a Glastrier, and even if it had, Muk’s natural special bulk means it would have been barely stronger than Night Shade at that point. Also, passing Muk a sub gave Deoxys every reason to just use Night Shade without worrying about Muk Terastallizing. I think with better plays you could have beat the Deoxys and only had to sacrifice Mienshao.
My goal with Muk was trying to poison it with Gunk Shot, however it also ended up serving as bait for the Tera Steel, which opened the door so I could start wailing on it with all of the Fighting type moves I had and pray for a Close Combat crit. Even if I had done the Tera Dark Knock Off play turn two, it's at two stacks of Cosmic Power, it's not going to make a big enough dent and then Deoxys just starts recovering and continues stacking. If anything, I got lucky my opponent took the bait and Tera Steeled the second Gunk Shot. I think going for the Close Combat crit is the only way I had a real shot at doing anything with that team.
As far as Mienshao, I don't see any plays where I was able to get the Deoxys to Tera Steel while keeping it under 4 Cosmic Power stacks to either get it low enough to sac something else to have Mienshao come in for the kill, or I can Shed Tail into Mienshao to sac it and then have Staraptor come in for the kill.
Obviously we could sit here and conjecture all day about possibilities, but my larger point is that these Cosmic Power sets depend on very specific counter plays and then otherwise you're walking a very tight rope, praying for luck or for your opponent to make a mistake, and that doesn't make for fun gameplay in my experience.
A Cake Wearing A Hat said:The dev council has voted not to ban Cosmic Power (7 no ban-1 ban, one abstain). I'll do what I can to make sure that we at least don't increase the rate at which cosmic appears on deo-d and chimecho, but no promises for my cohorts. I apologize if this result is disappointing to anyone.
Edit: we will be removing calm mind deo-d
I figured it was a long shot anyways. I hope this conversation has encouraged y'all to consider more thoroughly if a certain set just feels bad/annoying to play against though. I believe there are similar reasons for why evasion boosting moves aren't seen in the format? But at the end of the day it's Random Battles. Given how RNG is so core to the design of the format anyways, you're bound to get bad luck that costs you matches, and bad luck almost always feels bad; theres not a ton to be done about that. It's definitely an interesting game design challenge. Regardless, I appreciate the time and effort you devs put into the format.
What were the thoughts behind removing Calm Mind Deoxys-D, and more importantly, does that mean we'll see more Cosmic Power Deoxys-D...?