- you overstate the want valiant has for more moves. cc+knock+sd+encore or moon+cc+knock+encore does pretty much everything it needs to, with any sort of tera necessary depending on the team (dark, fighting, steel, fairy, elec, whatever) patching most of the holes you listed. furthermore, it is not necessary for a pokemon to be able to have 12 moveslots or whatever. never liked that argument, people tried it back when gren & volc were banned & it was bad then - the point is that it can run these moves & does have these options, making reliable preparation for it a sizeable task. full disclosure, not really decided on whether or not val is or is not reasonable in this regard, though i lean towards it being unreasonable.
My point still stands on Valiant not being broken. Regardless if it is SD + Encore, Encore Mixed, CM, Specs, etc, most teams have a dedicated check to it. Colbur King, Amoonguss, Zapdos, Molt, Pex, and Lando can check the common SD set. Even Clod might I add. CM variants are easier to check with Glowking, Clod, and Amoonguss. Depending on the Tera, Treads, Molt, and/or Ghold can also reasonably check it
- ya i think ghold is actually excellent in terms of offensive prowess & you understate this massively. if not played like a dunce, even just plot+recover is one of the better breakers in the tier imo due to its typing+bulk+servicable speed vs slower threats - especially with tera allowing it a free kill after a sack once it gets one of the many advantages it does to plot. also, yeah, good as gold is bullshit lol.
I should’ve rephrased myself correctly but what I originally meant was that Ghold wasn’t “broken” offensively. Ghold is a fantastic and customizable offensive presence that also checks important targets like Garg, the Fairies, Bax (with Balloon), etc. I mentioned the issue with its speed because the meta is even more offensive than the last gen. More mons in this gen can tank a hit from Ghold and are bulky enough or fast enough to threaten back. An example is Samu-H who is both its best friend and biggest enemy. Obviously Ghold can switch out, but you give momentum to Samu. There are other checks added from Home like AV Hoopa, A-Muk, Molt, and Tran. Obviously Ghold can Tera to bypass them, but it traces back to the discussion that Tera is the problem.
- idk bro zapdos is kinda hard to deal with unless you dedicate a tera elec to something, even more so than last gen due to the cut of toxic. it's not about being haxed by cane, lol - rather, there isn't that much in the way of dealing with volt+cane in the first place considering the best & most common ground-type gets crushed by cane. just not an easy mon to play against.
Zapdos is a naturally difficult mon to be completely safe against. Volt Switch + Discharge + Hurricane are incredibly annoying to play around, but not to the point of being overbearing. Tran and G-King can threaten Zap back or make progress out of it despite fearing Discharge or T-Wave. Ting-Lu can chip it with Ruination and punish Roost attempts with EQ We also do have other dedicated Zappy checks, albeit more niche.
Treads is an alternative to Tusks as it can switch into Zapdos barring Heat Wave and threaten with Knock and/or Ice Spinner. With the added benefit of fairing much better into the two main spinblockers (Ghold/Pult) than Tusks.
Sandy Shocks can eat a Hurricane and make progress out of that switch in with either hazards, Volt Switch, or threatening the team with its STAB combination + Tera Ice.
Thundy who I dedicated an entire post to is a more offensive version of Zapdos that hits even harder than it with the added benefit of being able to go Modest due to outrunning offensive Tusk/Bax by one point. Its a strong breaker that 2HKOs mons Zapdos normally wouldn’t like Clod, Glowking, and more with Specs Tera Flying.
A-Muk is a strong special wall that can force progress itself with Knock Off + Poison Touch. It can tank a couple hits from offensive variants with Protect + Lefties while threatening to both poison and remove its boots. Plus it also checks with the ghosts, Enam, and specially oriented Valiant.
Have you also tried SpD Ghold? Been using it lately and it puts in the work. It shrugs off hits from defensive variants while also doing better at checking Enam and avoiding a KO from Specs Pult after minimal chip.
- idk g offensive tusk is silly strong lol. can't count the amount of times in this meta i've got a spin off with max atk booster cc/headlong/spinner/spin and just... won? with practically no brainpower needed. i guess this is a niche set though so whatever. point is it is strong as fuck.
Still not particularly sold on the idea of banning Tusk. Not only is it our only reliable form of hazard removal outside of Cinder and Treads, but its not particularly broken itself. Even if Tusk manages to chip Zapdos or even OHKO it with Tera Ice Ice Spinner, it still risks being crippled by Static or if it isn’t sped booster, Zapdos can shrug one hit and threaten back. Dozo easily 1v1s it. Zama can 1v1 with the standard set. The HLR/CC/Spinner Tusk set you described is also checked by Molt who threatens with strong Flamethrowers/Hurricanes or burns.
Keep in mind none of the mons I’ve listed are unmons. Molt especially is a fantastic anti-meta mon, better than it was in SS. Less mons this gen carry Knock Off and most of the mons it is designated to check apart from Valiant do not carry Knock, which was why it fell off last gen. It checks so much shit, even mons you wouldn’t expect it to. With SpD investment, it eats hits from Specs Pult in a pinch, and checks a bunch of meta shit. Its not even a passive wall either, Flamethrower + Hurricane/BB from its solid offensive stats still stings, plus it can generate momentum with U-Turn. Heck it even checks non Lum/non-Tera Fire Gambit. Burn is even more affective than paralysis in this tier just cause how much of the tier is physically oriented.
Apart from Bax, Tera, and Gambit (yes I was finally convinced to vote ban on it) I don’t there is anything I find banworthy atm, and even if I do, its mostly cause of Tera making them more bullshit. Have you ever tried switching into a Modest Tera Dragon Draco from Pult without a Fairy? Not fun.