Totally untrue. A lot of muscles get there FROM fat. You have to have something to turn into muscle, and if this was true, people who become obese would never leave that.
Are you trying to say that the fat converts to muscle? Because that's pretty ridiculous. If you had to convert something into muscle, how would you build muscle in the first place?
Your body has amazing ways of converting different substances the way it needs. I'm not saying your going to pull a lot of nutrients from those cells, but when your body has no where else to pull it from, it has to take it from somewhere. These nutrients can be as simple as water, but it still pulls them.
I have been physically fit for almost my entire life. I do get my lulls where I don't work out, and I gain more body fat than I would like, but I don't change my calorie intake when I go from a lull to working out, if I do change it, I will increase my calories if anything so that I have the energy. And I still burn fat while building muscle.
Physically fit =/= fat turns into muscle, or whatever theory you're trying to prove here. Also, looks like you amended your statement to "Burn fat while building muscle."
But let me see if I get this straight:
1) You eat a certain amount of food while working out.
2) You stop working out.
3) You gain fat.
4) You start working out again, still eating the same amount of food.
5) You lose weight.
So you're eating maintenance (from what I can gather), then you stop burning calories so you're eating more than maintenance, so you gain weight, then you start working out again while eating under maintenance (since you've gained weight), then you lose weight and are back to where you started.
Seems like the regular "eat more calories than I need so I gain weight" and "eat less calories than I need so I lose weight" thing.
Wouldn't mind seeing your lifts, workout, and a picture to accompany (I reccomend blotting out your face if you care about that). Also wouldn't mind knowing about these gains you make, because it looks like you've had multiple lulls while working out, yet enough confidence to post that you're still making gains each time. So based on my progress over two months earlier this year, I'd say it wouldn't be out of your range to be at intermediate lifts.
Finally, a little something from bb:
Getting rid of the fat and grow the muscles. Unfortunately, it is almost impossible to achieve both goals at the same time. The reason for this is that in order to maintain an environment in your body that facilitates fat burn, you must deplete yourself of calories. Growth requires extra calories, much like you'd need extra building material to add a room to your house.
In addition, insulin, which is a key component of growing muscle, is the anti-Christ of fat burn and is released whenever you eat carbohydrates (how much and how fast depends entirely on the type of carbs, however.)
a little something for those of us at #lifting:
/me summons tof
I don't mean to be trying to run you off, but you're speaking against basically everything anyone has ever said, ever, offering no proof besides "i do this and that and this happens therefore this must be true." js bro