gonna keep this brief so it doesn't derail this thread from the topic at hand much more than it already had and will get to the actual topic at hand at the end of my post, but wanted to leave my .02 after my normal lurkish read through.
i think ya'll should take a step back from this discussion and think about things in perspective and maybe from a slightly different viewpoint for a moment. this is a next best thing thread - the purpose is to show cool, innovative sets to spread word and help everyone who wants to use them, not cause tension and get into disagreements, so let's work to all benefit from exposure to this thread.
i think that it's perfectly understandable that AM missed the set that was posted by littlelucario because he happened to have that user on ignore - he had no way of seeing that post, unfortunately. given that AM added some substance and a different EV spread onto the set, a simple fix to this would be combining the two nominations into one. nobody is being made or broken by winning/losing this round of the next best thing thread individually, as far as ik, so this makes it best for both parties and it sorta tears apart this whole argument above.
also, re: badge users getting more votes/recognition/popularity: this is an inherent part of the forums environment that you'll encounter in just about every subforum and that's because the people w/ badges generally have earned them and therefore, people automatically revert their attention to them. it's unfortunate for users who lack badges, but you should look at it as motivation to work and contribute yourselves to be like that or motivation to stand out and post things that will get attention regardless for good reasons to surmount this instead of as a negative. keep in mind that people like AM were probably in your shoes at one point or another, too, so there's no point in antagonizing him, esp. b/c it's not his fault he contributes and gets recognition.
anyway let me steer this back onto the topic, sorry if this derailed things a bit more than they already were!
my vote'll be for defensive volcanion in general, under the principal that both dudes contributed to the set being shown in this thread without seeing anyone do so beforehand and what i touched on beforehand.
defensive volcanion has a lot of physical bulk to check plenty of things you wouldn't expect it to and it's not too passive either, unlike some other walls in the tier, so it has a clear niche and gets my vote.