I'll provide my thoughts on some nominations posted recently.
C to C-/UR: Disagree
pooyou123456789q said:The only reason this isn't D is cause it can wreck stall with specs, but stall is shit now, making this thing irrelevant.
Completely disagree with this one, I feel this argument point is very weak also, there isn't much substance to back this up. Arguably stall teams aren't as effective as they used to be, they still exist. Despite this, Kyogre isn't 'irrelevant' at all as far as its viability and niches are concerned. Specs Kyogre is very strong whatever way you look at it though I do agree its a very niche team choice. Even if it doesn't play against stall, Kyogre is still able to function as a breaker against balances and other slower Pokemon, its absurdly strong in the rain and can cause common Pokemon on defensive backbones to fold due to its sheer power such as Support Arceus' or Giratina-O etc. Players who prefer a slightly stronger matchup against faster builds such as Bulky Offense that still would employ a decent defensive backbone on their teams, Choice Scarf is also an option, this allows Kyogre to get a jump on other frailer targets and give it more valuable revenge killing capabilities too that would otherwise threaten it such as Marshadow, Mega Lucario, Unboosted Salamence etc.
The main issue with regular kyogre and especially choice sets is the huge 'guessing game' which in turn can cause some 50/50 moments of 'does the opponent switch in Primal Groudon on the water move or do they Ice Beam?' which I honestly feel is the largest downside to Kyogre and could mean you could completely lose momentum with an incorrect guess. this also means Kyogre requires a considerable amount of team support that is required which makes it inferior to Primal Kyogre which is a Pokemon that faces some teambuilding constraints itself.
If you manage to remove Primal Groudon, this set can start taking a hefty toll on against opposing teams and you simply can't ignore the power and small merits that Regular Kyogre can sometimes have over Primal Kyogre. Despite its flaws I feel its attributes still warrant it of the C rank.
A- to B+ - Agree
DMDW said:Arceus-Fairy reminds me of the fact that many balance teams persist in same erroneous mindset, thinking it is "a glue mon" which can provide various utility options in both offensive and defensive sides. Arceus-Fairy is indeed a Pokemon that is capable of blanket checking many things, but some players fail to account for the downsides it leaves its own team to deal with.
The first tragic flaw of Arceus-Fairy I would like to point out is its strapped moveslot. Support variants of Arceus-Fairy prefers taking advantage of its offensive typing to be a Stealth Rock setter that can force out Mega Sableye and therefore struggles fitting both Toxic and Will-O-Wisp. I witness more balance teams employing both Primal Groudon and Necrozma-DM in their team and this means that Arceus-Fairy will inevitably be taken advantage by either of them due to lacking Toxic against the former or lacking Will-O-Wisp against the latter. Many people, including myself, have attempted to experiment on dual status Arceus-Fairy to maximize the number of Pokemon it can punish, but this means that Arceus-Fairy will forgo Stealth Rock and will no longer be able to compress the roles it previously did. Even with this dedicated and niche adjustment of moveset, Arceus-fairy continues to struggle against any team with Ho-Oh and Toxapex.
The second flaw of Arceus-Fairy is other Pokemon fulfilling similar roles while providing other utilities. Other Arceus formes like Arceus-Dark and Arceus-Water rose as viable Stealth Rock users that can threaten common Defog users. Whereas Arceus-Water prevents every Defog users apart from Giratina-A from staying in, Arceus-Dark stands as a Stealth Rock setter that discourages Lunala lead, avoids Shadow Tag trapping, and checks other threatening foes like Yveltal and Ultra Necrozma. Arceus-Fairy too threatens Defog users like both Giratina formes, but it fails to keep Stealth Rock from staying on the field with its inability to threaten Defog Ho-Oh and Skarmory - choosing to run Fire Blast over Toxic to deal with Skarmory leads Arceus-Fairy to being completely useless against Ho-Oh. As a Stealth Rock user, Arceus-Fairy also has unfavorable matchup against other relevant Stealth Rock setters like Primal Groudon, Necrozma-DM, or even Excadrill, which it cannot take out swiftly. Calm Mind sets fails to threaten balance teams as Arceus-Fairy will never be able to justify both Earth Power and Fire Blast in its moveset, and specially defensive Necrozma-DM easily walls this set regardless, leaving Arceus-Ground, Arceus-Flying, and Arceus-Dark as far better Calm Mind users than Arceus-Fairy in most instances.
The third flaw of Arceus-Fairy is its inability to check foes properly. While Arceus-Fairy is one of the few Pokemon that can reliably take STAB combinations from Yveltal and Marshadow, it is often forced to use Recover to prevent it from getting picked off by Marshadow / stay healthy enough to take +2 Bullet Punch from Mega Lucario / other purposes and often ends up 'meat-shielding' hits and yielding momentum to dangerous threats like Primal Groudon and Necrozma-DM. Arceus-Fairy's effectiveness as a pivot is further diminished by its vulnerability to both Shadow Tag users and vulnerability to status moves and this leads to my final point.
As publicly known, Arceus-Fairy's efficiency is undermined by its vulnerability to Shadow Tag trapping, and this worsens players' headache with teambuilding when they are already concerned about Gothitelle's presence when deciding to use an Arceus forme in the first place. To specify, every relevant cleric apart from Magearna are vulnerable to Mega Gengar, and pairing Magearna with Arceus-Fairy to alleviate it of status moves (which it will be inflicted with while combating Defog users, Yveltal, and other threats) will make the team more vulnerable to aforementioned common threats. This means that Arceus-Fairy's vulnerability to Shadow Tag not only hampers its usefulness in certain matchups but it also worsens the difficulty of a cleric justifying a place in the team and thus making Arceus-Fairy making easier to overload in general.
With this many drawbacks and opportunity costs coming from this Arceus forme, I refuse to believe that A- is an appropriate place for Arceus-Fairy when its efficiency with defensively checking foes and providing utility options are progressively declining. The benefit from using Arceus-Fairy is nowhere close to other Pokemon dwelling in A- like Magearna, Arceus-Dark, Toxapex, and Ferrothorn. I therefore believe the most accurate representation of Arceus-Fairy's viability in the current metagame state is somewhere lower than A- rank. B+ is what I propose for now.
I agree with this nomination, I actually brought this up on the previous viability rankings update, DMDW actually covered the points as to why considerably well, so I won't elaborate as much as I usually do.
I honestly do feel Arceus-Fairy isn't really capable of pulling the stops as a top support Arceus anymore and is being overshadowed considerably by other formes of Arceus such as Dark and Water Arceus due to their superior defensive capabilities they bring to team structures. Therefore they have been also occupying Arceus-Fairy's support role as a Stealth setter as well in recent metagame trends as these Arceus aren't complete Mega Gengar bait compared to Arceus-Fairy which is really huge, trappers are quite prevalent in USM Ubers and Mega Gengar is arguably one of the most threatening Pokemon in Ubers right now. Arceus-Dark in particular, cannot be directly threatened by any major trapper in the tier (think Gengar, Gothitelle/Gothorita) whatsoever and this is a big boon for it, becoming the metagame trend to be the foundations of the defensive backbone on teams. Furthermore I feel as a support Fairy, Xerneas has the superior support moves currently, with access to Aromatherapy, can actually pull off the Defog support role and is actually stronger against offense as it is able to utilise all of this on the Choice Scarf set.
A to A+ - Disagree
InvalidOS said:Offensive Calm Mind is the set used for this analysis.
Capable of 2HKO on Zygarde-Complete without boosts, possible OHKO with boosts, and guaranteed OHKO on Zygarde before Power Construct takes effect.
+1 200+ SpA Kyogre-Primal Ice Beam vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Zygarde-Complete: 836-988 (131.4 - 155.3%) -- guaranteed OHKO
200+ SpA Kyogre-Primal Ice Beam vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Zygarde-Complete: 560-660 (88 - 103.7%) -- 25% chance to OHKO after Leftovers recovery
200+ SpA Kyogre-Primal Ice Beam vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Zygarde: 560-660 (133.3 - 157.1%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Capable of OHKO on defensive Groudon-Primal, though has to switch in on it or Desolate Land will take priority.
200+ SpA Kyogre-Primal Origin Pulse vs. 248 HP / 252+ SpD Groudon-Primal in Heavy Rain: 1132-1336 (280.8 - 331.5%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Can be OHKOed by offensive Stealth Rock Groudon-Primal, though highly unlikely.
236+ Atk Groudon-Primal Precipice Blades vs. 32 HP / 124 Def Kyogre-Primal: 262-309 (75 - 88.5%) -- 6.3% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock
OHKOed by offensive Swords Dance Groudon-Primal.
+2 160 Atk Groudon-Primal Precipice Blades vs. 32 HP / 124 Def Kyogre-Primal: 454-535 (130 - 153.2%) -- guaranteed OHKO
2HKOed by Necrozma-DM without boosts, OHKOed by Necrozma-DM with boosts.
252 Atk Necrozma-Dusk-Mane Photon Geyser vs. 32 HP / 124 Def Kyogre-Primal: 180-213 (51.5 - 61%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
+2 252 Atk Necrozma-Dusk-Mane Photon Geyser vs. 32 HP / 124 Def Kyogre-Primal: 358-423 (102.5 - 121.2%) -- guaranteed OHKO
OHKOes Necrozma-DM, but is threatened by Necrozma-DM with boosts due to Necrozma outspeeding. Having a Substitute can allow Kyogre to get the KO.
200+ SpA Kyogre-Primal Origin Pulse vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Necrozma-Dusk-Mane in Heavy Rain: 343-405 (102.3 - 120.8%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Kyogre-Primal Speed: Base 90, 31 IVs, 152 EVs, 254 Spe
Necrozma-DM Speed: Base 77, 31 IVs, 252 EVs, 278 Spe
CM Kyogre may struggle against defensive Kyogre, as it needs a +3 SpA boost before it can 2HKO. However, it can still easily get the +3 boost if it's at full health.
200+ SpA Kyogre-Primal Origin Pulse vs. 252 HP / 168+ SpD Kyogre-Primal in Heavy Rain: 99-117 (24.5 - 28.9%) -- 99.8% chance to 4HKO
0 SpA Kyogre-Primal Scald vs. 32 HP / 0 SpD Kyogre-Primal in Heavy Rain: 72-85 (20.6 - 24.3%) -- guaranteed 5HKO
With a +1 SpA boost, Kyogre-Primal 2HKOes +1 SpD Gothitelle.
+1 200+ SpA Kyogre-Primal Origin Pulse vs. +1 252 HP / 252+ SpD Gothitelle in Heavy Rain: 249-294 (72.3 - 85.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
Kyogre-Primal actually is better off using Origin Pulse on Yveltal than using Ice Beam.
+1 200+ SpA Kyogre-Primal Origin Pulse vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Yveltal in Heavy Rain: 559-658 (122.5 - 144.2%) -- guaranteed OHKO
+1 200+ SpA Kyogre-Primal Ice Beam vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Yveltal: 408-480 (89.4 - 105.2%) -- 37.5% chance to OHKO after Leftovers recovery
If Kyogre had just a little more speed, this would matter.
+1 200+ SpA Kyogre-Primal Origin Pulse vs. 72 HP / 100 SpD Xerneas in Heavy Rain: 508-598 (123.6 - 145.4%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Unfortunately (or fortunately), Xerneas does win after Geomancy...
+2 252+ SpA Xerneas Thunder vs. 32 HP / 0 SpD Kyogre-Primal: 352-416 (100.8 - 119.1%) -- guaranteed OHKO
+1 200+ SpA Kyogre-Primal Origin Pulse vs. +2 72 HP / 100 SpD Xerneas in Heavy Rain: 255-301 (62 - 73.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
...Unless Kyogre has +3 boosts, which is highly unlikely.
+2 252+ SpA Xerneas Thunder vs. +3 32 HP / 0 SpD Kyogre-Primal: 142-168 (40.6 - 48.1%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
+3 200+ SpA Kyogre-Primal Origin Pulse vs. +2 72 HP / 100 SpD Xerneas in Heavy Rain: 424-499 (103.1 - 121.4%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Overall, I think Kyogre-Primal is worthy of getting boosted to A+. It has too many checks to be S rank, but I don't think A does it any justice.
I feel Primal Kyogre is a bit of a luxury mon in the current metagame and this whole nomination is mostly theorymon and there isn't really any substance to back it up aside the calculations. Primal Kyogre is something that constantly gets nominated and I constantly feel it isn't really worthy of an A+ Rank, though I do agree it is one of the strongest breakers the metagame has at the moment, however as a breaker, it has some teambuilding constraints and isn't very flexible in team options and can lead to situations of 'forced team partners' earlyish in the teambuilder, Primal Kyogre teams only tend to work when it is the focus of the team.
One of the major downsides of Primal Kyogre is that it struggles considerably against offense which just dances on it due to its lack of recovery and bulk meaning it can't stomach any heavy hit well. In most Matchups against offense, Primal Kyogre is getting a trade off at best ,making it quite unreliable in such an offensive metagame, the less reactive a team is, the easier it deals with Primal Kyogre. An attribute Lunala has over Primal Kyogre as a wallbreaker, currently is its ability to take hits from offense and Shadow Shield helps it out considerably.