I
shrang said:Groudon (base) from D to C-
I've brought this up before in SM but I forgot if it had a proper discussion because it was pretty much end of SM and a new thread started pretty soon but whatever. I feel base Groudon has a niche in the way that if you actually go out of your way to build a specific team for it, it can actually work, unlike a lot of the shit in D, which makes me want this to be a bit higher IMO. Of course, using base Groudon has the very huge opportunity cost in not being able to run Primal Groudon, but it has a few perks of its own and has its own team that it could use. For one, it's probably the only Ground type in the tier that doesn't have to auto-trade with support Groundceus whereas pretty much every other Ground (outside of Groundceus itself) dies to Judge/Ice Beam, meaning you can retain momentum without having to either die or switch out. Z moves has also given base Groudon a very good lease on its ability to sweep. Something like RP/SD/P Blades/Dragon Claw with Dragonium-Z or Groundium-Z lets it beat lots of its original checks (Dragonium Z probably has the widest distribution to kill its checks - +2 Dragonium Z easily OHKOs Zygarde/Gira-A/Gira-O/Mega Mence/Ho-oh with no issues whatsoever; Groundium-Z lets you muscle past Arceus formes more easily).
This is not to mention the whole Drought vs Desolate Land business. Of course, Desolate Land is what makes PDon so great, but Drought opens up a couple of options for aggressive sun teams and what not. Again, it's hard to build these because you need really solid POgre checks and you're giving up PDon's splashable check-all, but I'm pretty sure you can make this work if you really wanted to.
All in all, I feel while base Groudon is definitely much less viable than its Primal variant, it still has a couple of perks and if you put it the effort, you can really make a niche for it which differentiates from the other D rank mons which are really out of niches.
No offence but I disagree. All D-Rank pokemon can be at the very least semi-useful with the right set. I could say run a Kasib Berry NecroDW with 252SpD
252Spatk and 4spd and use it to limited success. The point of being in D-tier is because if one has to build an entire team around a pokemon to make the mon viable or if its hopelessly outclassed by something else. Groudon fits both. Common Mons Like Pogre, Marshadow, Yveltal Xerneas can all check it.
Marshadow 252 atk life orb close combat vs Groudon 0 def Guaranteed 2HKO
Besides primal groudon invalidates any 'niche' it might have had. There are far superior users of Dragonium-Z, Groundium-z ets than groudon
and Primal Groudan can do everything groudon could and more. Groudon needs to set-up in order to KO, Pdon just comes in and you are guaranteed to get a KO. Groudon is basically never used(pun intended) in ubers and i think its good where it is.
EDIT- Superior users of dragonium and groundium z- Nagadanel, Zygarde, Groundceus, Rayquaza
ALL of these get STAB with Z-moves and have superior stats coverage etc
GZ Zygarde is a bit of a niche set but I have seen it used before successfully
Groundceus
Nagadanel can easily use Dragonium Z to pick up quick KO's so that beast boost activates and offset it's somewhat lacking stats
Rayquaza like naganadel Ko opponents after one Dragon Dance boost
Groudon is not as bad as other Mons in D. BUT since the forme that outclasses it is so prevalent in the metagame there is no real reason to use it
apart from experimenting. Specs Kyogre is not D as it can do something its Primal forme cannot. Groudon requires set up in order to works as you intended and it can easily be OHKO'd or 2HKO'd by Primal Groudon, Primal Kyogre, Specs Kyogre, Xerneas(After Geomancy), Yveltal, Mega gengar
Marshdow(Marshdium-Z or life orb). The point is that all of these mons are everywhere. Groudon requires set up in order to make the momentum that Primal Groudon can create without any. Groudon lacks the offensive/defensive/Phazing capabilities of its better form and requires heavy team support to use succesfully. Besides ANY pokemon can be used in ubers to great effect. From Cottonee(FEAR) to Cofagrigus one can do heavy damage to teams yet are not in ubers. The reason why is that one needs tons of practice and skill to excel in ubers with these pokemon , they are not one-hit wonders like P-don, NecroDM, and require high amounts of team support and practice to use. In other words you COULD make it work but why would you?In my opinion we should rank pokemon based on actual viability(Offensive/Defensive prowess) not on potential viability because then there wont be any D-rank at all or any tiers for that matter.