They sneered at the broken checks brokens argument but the moment overpanicky ban happy mods have to hold their horses due to new releases, the meta seems to adjust itself into a mostly organic representation of what’s broken and spammed vs what isn’t. Currently, we have a meta broken off from the shed tail cheese / unaware stall of the initial sv meta, more diverse than the bax hail infested home meta, vastly superior to the gliscor zap lu spam of dlc 1 meta, a barren wasteland that houses little more than grassy terrain Strats or gliscor stall. As it stands, we have a meta where all those Strats are concurrently viable, with good wealth distribution among usable mons to curb the past hoarding of wealth committed by the likes of tusk and gambit; the number of threats has brought a renaissance to strategizing for team synergy, creating move techs, adapting to meta teras, and general outplayablilty. Please do not take a ban first test later approach in a meta rich with unexplored combinations, checks, and counters to the real broken strategies. If strategies like sneasler grassy become overwhelmingly spammed and boast extraordinary win rates, or if something like gliscor proves to be too centralizing still, we can then look to those specific threats and take action. Just my two cents, trust me I know better.
- tiering goat
Ps stop banning shit in general I’m on this site to play Pokémon not the lack thereof come on bruh
I am speaking as a council member, but these are my own opinions, not a post of all of our collective thoughts.
I don't think the koko method is the best option for us at the moment.
The meta at the moment feels.. interesting. There is a LOT to do in the builder. That is one of the big upsides to me, but at the same time it feels overwhelming. Game freak gave us a lot to work with this time around.
I agree with a lot of what CTC has said here, outside of Sneasler (it's banned

) Banning anything off-rip to me
currently feels like a mistake.
Last DLC introduced Ursa-Moon, which stuck around for quite a while before people started realizing this thing is absolute bonkers. I don't think there is a 'mon in this DLC currently that matches the prowess/strength of what we saw at that time, but I would love to discuss Pokemon I feel
could make it over the edge as time goes on.
We are only two weeks into this meta, which is why I'm mostly hesitant on jumping the gun and banning everything.
That being said here are my first-takes on all of the new (and existing) Pokemon that have been mentioned in this thread.
---
Gouging Fire to me feels like a more intensive/bulkier version of ZardX. DD 3Atks is a very valid set, as is DD Morning Sun and Bulwark DTail variants. There's quite a bit that you can do with this guy. Having access to protect that burns makes the cherry on top, which makes me so adamant on rating him naturally above the others. Protosynthesis gives this 'mon an insane boost, and moves like Heat Crash are completely justifiable due to how strong naturally Gouging Fire is. Also being able to Thanos snap 'mons like Clefable under the sun is complete bonkers
+1 252+ Atk Tera Fire Gouging Fire Heat Crash (120 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Clefable in Sun: 520-612 (131.9 - 155.3%) -- guaranteed OHKO
To me, this is my definition of stepping over the edge of balanced and broken. Infinite creativity of sets, the bulk of Zygarde (basically the same hp/defense stats!) and access to moves that naturally give it such a boost over everything else, yeah I do think this deserves a suspect one way or another in the future.
---
Oh god he's back. I personally do not think this guy is healthy in any metagame, as shown from the previous DLC there's really not much you can do if your opponent is operating the correct set/spread, with Tera it's almost unkillable. Not only that but the flexibility of sets such as Brick Break or Taunt offers a lot more than usual this time around. I'd bring this guy up to #2,
juust below Gouging Fire. Not only that but being able to operate both Roaring Moon and Gouging Fire in sun is just absurd.
---
Welcome back, Moth. Making its return to OU is one of the biggest powerhouses of the decade, making its mark ever since it was introduced in Gen 5.
Bringing the moth back is something you have to question as to whether it was the correct choice or not. To put it out there, I was one of the votes to not quickban Volcarona at the time, as I would have much preferred a longer discussion with a suspect since this would be the first time Volcarona would ever be banned in an OU metagame. However, as time went on the more I realized how meta-defining he would/could have been, not only checking most fairies but being able to set up on all of them is a very big reason to put Volc on all of your teams. The question is if I think it's much different now than before - probably not. I still think that quiver terablast is extremely tough to prep against, especially with 'mons like Gouging Fire lurking around. Personally, I've been using
QD Terablast Dragon to be able to somewhat counteract Gouging Fire while also being able to set up on Pokemon such as Wellspring. I think it's a question of if Moth is a necessary evil to the tier with Pokemon like Enamorus and Valiant roaming around using Stellar, and if this 'mon would be banned, how badly would we need to take action against the Stellar Fairies? As I've stated before there are a lot of powerhouses roaming about currently and it's hard to gauge what's necessary to stabilize the tier currently as is. That being said I am putting this at #3 on my list due to how controversial the matchup moth can get, as well as the flexibility of sets you can operate with.
---
This ranks 4th on my list due to how annoying freeze can be in-game and the guessing game of if it's DD or Choice Specs/Special. Alongside Tera the reasoning for banning Kyurem would be almost the same as how it was handled in SS except now it has Tera to back up its defenses. In short, this Pokemon is annoying! But the fact it is 4th on my list shows to me personally how crazy the new meta is currently.
---
In theory these three 'mons to me pose the strongest uses of Stellar currently. I genuinely do not think Valiant ever needs to be banned. He constructs offense and fixes a lot of issues with most teams on its own, as well as providing blanket checks to Pokemon like Kingambit (with encore/stellar). I feel as it would be a mistake to ban him. Enamorus on the other hand is something I
can see (but currently, I don't think deserves) being banned in the future due to Stellar, and is probably the best Stellar user at the moment. Serperior has insane room for creativity at the moment and I'm not totally sure about it right now. In any case these three Pokemon feel like they create an invisible line on what to prep for currently, as well as the other 'mons I mentioned above.
---
Ever since I started playing this game in BW, every time Deoxys was introduced to the tier it got quickbanned/suspected almost a week or two later.
Wow, I never would have thought he'd be
somewhat balanced in this generation.
That being said Deoxys does offer a shit ton of flexibility for teams. Screens, spikes, offensive, Deoxys-D I think are all very valid uses. And you can 100% make the argument of a ban due to the gymnastics Deoxys could potentially pull off. I do not think it poses more of a problem than the others mentioned though, from what I've seen on ladder and tests.
---
After many, many months of trial and error from Game Freak's end, they still struggle to give us more Steel Pokemon. This is an issue I have that strikes a nerve because while Gambit and Gholdengo are both inherently crazy to deal with, they both provide a lot of balance with our metagame, being the two prominent steels throughout every single DLC. When Game Freak gives us more to work with, I think Gambit could potentially either get the boot, or the meta would be stable enough to fully counteract him. Gholdengo is just another topic on its own that we would have to discuss later in the future, as it belongs in the Hazards conversation.
The addition of Skarmory
and
however, is very nice and incredibly noteworthy. I do believe it's a step in the right direction in terms of stabilizing Gambit, although I still believe it could be an issue regardless.
One thing is clear: We need fairy answers. And one of our steels isn't even resistant to fairy.
---
I think this 'mon can break balance fairly easily but I am not truly convinced it's broken yet. There are a lot of sets roaming around, I personally have been using this Pokemon with booster energy on Grassy terrain with CM. I've also seen
Weather Ball Tera Water roaming around, which is honestly really cool. Overall I still need to think about this guy. It's a really cool and versatile 'mon on paper, but the fact you can run this on a sun team with Gouging / Moon roaming around just feels like complete insanity lol
---
I do not have a fair opinion on these Pokemon yet:
They feel incredibly new, some of them feel very weak to common types and overall I'm not sure what to make of them yet. Iron Boulder is obviously strong, but its typing inherently feels like it struggles with a lot.
Archaludon feels solid on rain, but I am not sure if it's meta-defining yet.
Iron Crown is really cool to use but I am not as experienced with it as I am with the others. I've also not seen it as much on high ladder yet.
Keldeo is an amazing addition to this generation but I am not entirely sure if he should be on the radar yet.
---
I would like to provide more insight on String Cheese, but I feel it is a huge topic to go about and I would much rather provide my thoughts on him in a separate thread. Yes, it is also on my radar and always has been. I listen to the community and I always strive to but words can't really describe how badly Game Freak fucked up our hazard removal, let alone how badly they nerfed our Steels this generation. It is a powerhouse topic by itself and if a ban was implemented it would change the meta by x100.
---
Anyways I think I ran out of words to type. This is just my opinion WRT Pokemon on my radar and what I think people should currently look out for. I am having a blast and I would not type this without trying it all out for myself.
I peaked top 3 a couple days ago and overall just love the new Pokemon and am continuously reading your thoughts and opinions. Just want to let you guys know your voices are not being unheard. Finch is doing a fantastic job at this as the Tier Leader and I am hoping this thread can have more of our council members open up more with their thoughts.
Peace and love