Hi, I'm very tired so I'll won't post quotes, just my opinions on the players that I and other people seem to have strong opinions about (I guess this is my “3 scummiest” penitence for Hydrattler's inactivity) Pokemaniac212: I'd agree with some recent odd suspicions of him: the contents of Ditto's posts seem trustworthy (maybe I implicitly trusted him while reading due to his mod status which would be irrelevant but w/e) so it's understandably strange/scummy that pokemaniac would have made such an assumption not based off his trustworthiness. I think the fact that Ditto actually cast a lynch vote on him could go either way: that early in the game we probably wouldn't have gone past L-1 without a serious guarantee which doesn't exclude him from being scum. ORC/AG: I think these two are probably clean, although there are claims of them being mafians due to their fighting bogging down discussion, I think this was just due to AG being bothered at the fact that he was being consistently misunderstood. Having lurked in other mafia games I predict that although jalmont has the same role, we'll be seeing a very different person from here on out due to AG's unique personality. In other words the constant defensiveness doesn't seem to me like a definite scumtell. Empoof: Besides Quagsires he has the most experience in mafia so far which would account for his odd ability to correctly make hunches that later turned out to be true. The only thing more scummy than immediate lynching/bandwagon is the kind of posts being made generally by EP/empoof (although I like the red pandas ). I actually found the last part of Quagsires' post just now to be somewhat suspcious: generally it's suspicious be ambivalent but it's also suspicious to come right out the gate with a strong suspicion. He did neither and jokingly lynched Walrein, which, although funny, is kind of a clever “third option” in terms of what we might think of him, neither overly vague or overly suspicious. Added to the fact that nEsp was very inactive before he subbed out and that Quag is an experienced mafian.