Alright, here are the reads I have after reading through the thread again. Those not mentioned, well I don't have much of a read on them yet.
New World Order - While the lynch on Ditto didn't make much sense, I get the feeling that he is a more inexperienced town player. Especially since there has been no counter claim to mayor, he is most likely village.
Aura Guardian / Orcinus Duo - A this point, I get the feeling that they are both village and stuck in a rather pointless circular argument. It isn't helping drive discussion forward at all. However I do feel I need to reread this debate a few more times.
zorbees - Seems like a village. Has well thought out posts in my opinion, and seems to be helping push discussion forward.
Metal Bagon - I feel that Metal Bagon is probably mafia. First, the early bandwagon seemed rather foolish, especially with no evidence given for his vote. Then, his post 107 where he attempts to justify his vote made absolutely no sense to me. Finally, he says he will be forced to claim if people don't pull their votes, which sounds to me like he is trying to scare the village away from lynching him in fear of having a power role revealed. Also, a lot of his posts just don't seem to have much substance to me. He is probably my number one suspect.
Ditto / Flamestrike - Both fall into the same category for me. More than likely village. Sound reasoning, simply helping push discussion along.
Pokemaniac - His first 2 substantial posts seem to do nothing more than reiterate what other people were saying, but didn't actually have any of his own ideas. It feels like he is trying to feign agreement while blending in to avoid suspicion. He is another suspect for me.
Kingofkongs - His attack on OD made very little sense to me. Felt like it was an attempt to attack one of the people promoting discussion, and came out of nowhere. Unsure of him, but possibly mafia.
NJiggly - Post 85 made no sense whatsoever, and outside of that he really hasn't said much. Unsure of him, but would definitely like to hear more out of NJiggly.
Those are all the reads I fell strongly about so far. The other people in the game haven't done enough for me to draw any sound conclusions yet.
EDIT - Forgot about Empoof - To me his move of no lynch seemed like that of someone that isn't sure what to do in NOC games. Outside of that, I feel like he has had pretty decent logic, and more than likely is village.