Tabuu said:
Here is my thoughts on why Dugtrio is B-Tier:
A B-Tier Pokemon struggles to sweep/wall a significant portion of the metagame. Observing Dugtrio it really can't function as a sweeper due to BPs, ESs, Ice Shards and other bulky threats that litter OU. TBH Dugtrio isn't a sweeper pokemon. It functions more as an offensive niche than anything. You need a Heatran gone? Look no further. Tyranitar? Got him. Ninetales? Over. Other threats that can be trapped and OHKOd? Will do. (Now, we're obviously assuming these 'Mons don't hold Air Balloon or SHed Shell. However this just adds to my argument yet again, as sometimes, Dugtrio's offensive niche can easily be taken away.) He also does have flaws namely a scare movepool and a frail defense. However, Dugtrio is still a very dangerous 'Mon; this fact prevents him from falling any further than B. But to say that a niche pokemon is A-Tier?....not this time :)
Dugtrio IS a niche Pokemon, that's its entire purpose, to trap and KO Heatran and Tyranitar/Ninetales/weakened Politoed. However, you are underestimating how devastating that is. For rain teams, unless the opposing weather inducer is Hippowdon, Dugtrio will consistently win the weather war. Sun has trouble with Heatran and Tyranitar and beating weakened Politoed is a great thing to have. Additionally, with Stone Edge, Dugtrio can KO Volcarona, a huge obstacle for the many sun teams that have difficult dealing with its onslaught. Dugtrio can even find time to set up Stealth Rock, which is an invaluablr utility. While Dugtrio's lack of power can't be denied, it's still one of the most useful Pokemon in OU, so much so that some of the teams that define this metagame, such as Politoed/Dugtrio/Tentacruel/Tornadus-T/Ferrothorn/Genesect and Lavos Sun, use it. With all of these traits considered, Dugtrio is undoubtedly worthy of A tier.
Anyway, nominating Landorus-T for A tier. Landorus-T's got a lot going for it. With Intimidate, it is one of the best Terrakion checks in existence, not to mention that it neutralizes +1 Salamence/+1 Dragonite and forces most CBers out. The standard pivot set is, well, an excellent pivot for an array of attacks, perhaps the most notable of these being Genesect's U-turn. It is among the most reliable setters of Stealth Rock, only outdone by MAYBE Deoxys-D and Terrakion, but neither have much opportunity to set up Stealth Rock more than once throughout the duration of a match, something Landorus-T doesn't have too much trouble doing. When Landorus-T comes in on something such as Terrakion that won't be doing too much damage to it factoring in Intimidate, it can take advantage of the imminent switch and U-turn to bring a teammate in unscathed, a la bulky attacker Rotom-W. Even with not that much investment, base 145 Attack makes Landorus-T pack a punch. It can even utilize Rock Polish and sweep once Skarmory/Ferrothorn are removed, be a nice bulkyish revenge killer, set up the dangerous Gravity, or just don a Choice Band and OHKO/2HKO the metagame. Seriously, the sky's the limit for Landorus-T, and faring poorly against Steel-types should not deter it from claiming a spot in A tier.
EDIT: Oh, and briefly on Mew—it has some flaws that keep it B tier imo, it's an excellent mon with some effective sets, but you can say that about most of B tier. I might nominate Bronzong for B tier once I gather my complete thoughts on it (it's awesome and I love it to pieces on my sun team, but I need to test it out a bit more for some more conclusive data).
EDIT2: Oh, and Tabuu, I don't think anyone agrees with B tier Starmie, don't fret. Starmie's an awesome mon brimming with positives, including the ability to spin, great coverage, decent bulk when you invest in it, blazing Speed, and a powerful STAB Hydro Pump/Surf (especially in rain). Starmie isn't going anywhere.