This is a post about mainly
Sample Teams, but it will also touch on usage stats and tiering.
Let's get straight to the point: There is not enough sample teams. For comparison, here is the number of sample teams for the other main tiers:
OU: 17 sample teams
UU: 10 sample teams
RU: 6 sample teams
NU: 15 sample teams
PU: 7 sample teams
As you can see, with the exception of PU, RU is trailing far behind all other tiers.
Ok but why is this a problem though? I would like to point 2 reasons:
1. It reduces perceived diversity, and ladder diversity
The lesser of the two problems, this simply means that you are more likely to find the same teams on ladder, or slight variations of said teams. It also fails to convey the diversity of the tier. Of the 4 balance sample teams, Slowbro is in all 4 of them, Krookodile in 3 of them, and many 2s like Gengar, Talonflame, Jirachi, Noivern, Breloom. It doesn't sound too bad, but surely we can manage to expand our showcase a little more. Also, do Offense and Stall not exist in the tier? Of course they do, but a new player wanting to try out those archetypes will be left with good ol' nothing to try.
2. It directly impacts usage and tiering for RU and tiers below
This is the actual important problem in my opinion. I am sure you have heard of
this post in policy review. I would love to take part in it but I physically can't lol so instead I'll point out how we are currently directly participating in the worsening of the problem.
And to show this, look no further than Toxtricity.
Disclaimer
There are other mons it could apply too, both today (Torterra) and before that (don't got any off the top of my head but there has to be other examples), but this would complicate things further so let's keep it simple.
Toxtricity is highly likely to rise to RU next shifts due to LBN's Webs Sample team. Here is proof of my claim:
This is Toxtricity's teammates according to February's stats.
As you can see, you have the 5 teammates of the Sample team, and a gigantic difference between Ribombee and Mimikyu. We can infer that therefore, approximately
at least 60% of Toxtricity's usage in RU comes from 1 single team, without accounting for edits of the sample that might have different teammates.
Toxtricity had a 6.1% usage rate in February, remove 60% from that and you end up with Toxtricity at below 3% usage, way lower than the threshold to rise.
Whether you believe this is normal and how it should function, I will let you decide. But what I do know, is that we are going to steal Toxtricity from NU, which is such an important mon of the tier that it has just received a suspect test. All because of 1 sample team
(which I do not have anything against, it's totally viable and works well as a sample), which has no competition as one of the two HO samples, and the only Webs team.
My personal opinion is that
this should simply not happen, it
would not happen if we had
more diversity in sample teams, and this issue
directly impacts NU.
So what do we do now? You could argue that I am part of the problem as I literally haven't submitted a sample team recently, and... ok you are right
BUT I would like to take a look at the tournament scene. Surely, with all the tournaments happening all the time where there SHOULD be high quality teams, let's try and have tournament players submit sample teams.
Obviously you cannot force one to submit their teams, but surely someone out here cares enough to participate...
I don't see the solution to this problem except, like, begging to active players to submit teams, but then if you force people it could lower the quality of the samples and... you get the point, I haven't found the universal solution. At least you have this post as food for thought. Or maybe I'm over exaggerating again idk