he mis-spoke, you need 5 in your party. it sounds like you have 4?
one flame body, two parents, and one sweet scent equals four pokemon right?
add one more, then you'll be at 5, which gives you six when you sweet scent and catch a random pokemon.
other than that your steps seem fine.
granted i only did this once, that seems to be the thing you're messing up to me. i had IV check, fast hatch and instant egg on when i successfully attempted it the other day.
also a side note, my SID is only 4 characters long, is that weird?