Gah777 said:Hypothetically, compared to Vaporeon, how would something like this work out?:
Mamanbou@Leftovers
Ability: Regeneration
Nature: Careful
EVs: 188 HP/ 68 Def/ 252 SpD
-Wish
-Protect
-Toxic
-Waterfall
It has 70 more HP, only 27 less Def, and 36 less SpD than the standard Bold 188 HP/ 252 Def/ 68 SpD Vaporeon (I borrowed the EVs from this set but switched them around for Mamanbou lol). Plus Mamanbou gets regeneration.
How much does that extra 70 HP make up for the difference in defences? Can someone run some calcs please?
Same set but with a different EV spread:
Mamanbou@Leftovers
Ability: Regeneration
Nature: Impish
EVs: 108 HP/ 200 Def/ 200 SpD
-Wish
-Protect
-Toxic
-Waterfall
Basically more bulky than vaporeon, it's jobs are usually to pass wishes, out stall pokes with protect and poison foes then retreats to step 2.
Regeneration makes up and keeps it in competition with Vaporeon and any reason not to Mamanbou (unless you want to run heal bell) is ridiculous imo, unless you're a 1st gen fanatic (Yes I went there)
It's attack stat is better than it's sp.atk stat so I also run waterfall to get off some extra damage.
Bologo said:People may like to talk about Vaporeon and say "AMAZING! Even better than Mama!", but it's not necessarily true. :]
It really isn't.
Gah777 said:Thanks Bologo. This thing really is not outclassed in any way by Vaporeon. In fact it's giving my favorite bulky water wish passer a run for its money...
That's how I feel.
masterful said:With bigger wishes, arguably a better ability, and greater HP, I don't see this being at all outclassed by Vaporeon. Also, it can be EV'ed to take physical hits far better than Vaporeon, giving it greater versatility
True
Gah777 said:But if it takes physical hits better that means you're most likely missing out on some SpD EVs.
Regeneration alone can compensate that.
FastFlygon said:This thing is FAR more useful than most of you are making out. I have a reasonably good stall team and this is easily the MVP. Sure, Waterfall doesn't hurt much, but you just have to hit the Opponent with a toxic and Stall to high hell. I've seen it outstall Ttar, Wobbuffet and a Burned Scizor, all in one match, and with Toxic Spikes support in the rain, spamming rest outstalls anything that hasn't done serious boosting. If you get Reflect up, it's nigh invincible, surviving even +6 Deoxys-A Zen Headbutt. It has no utility outside of heavy stall, but in a dedicated stall team, especially with Toxic Spikes and Burn Support, it's a beast.
Nice.