Ulevo said:You're straw manning the point I made. They are all equal contributions to the problem, but I wasn't implying that that means we have to ban one particular thing specifically (in fact it was the complete opposite of what I was trying to point out).
The point is that all the factors play a role, and we should ban what makes sense, and what is concise. Banning Speed Boost on Blaziken doesn't equate to banning Swift Swim. First of all, banning Swift Swim is a clean blanket ban on the entire ability, while banning Speed Boost on Blaziken is another complex ban. Secondly, assuming you banned Speed Boost, it wouldn't equate to the same thing. There are multiple problematic Pokemon in the rain with Drizzle and Swift Swim, while Speed Boost is clearly only problematic on Blaziken thus far.
You missed my points entirely.
I admit that I misunderstood your conclusion, but the differences you bring up don't seem relevant. First, to clarify: My suggestion regarding Speed Boost was not that your suggestion would equate to banning Blaziken + Speed Boost, but that it would equate to banning Speed Boost on all Pokemon, a simple ban like the ban of Swift Swim.
With that in mind, multiple Pokemon being broken with Swift Swim + Drizzle is hardly relevant, as it's still a minority. Banning Kingdra, Ludicolo, and Kabutops may entail more separate bans than a single blanket ban of Swift Swim, but that isn't any more of a reason to make a blanket ban on Swift Swim instead than it is to make a blanket ban on all 42 Pokemon with 600+ BST rather than banning 18 Pokemon individually.
So with that in mind: Why ban Swift Swim rather than individual Pokemon?
Raikaria said:Where did I ever indicate that my theorymoning was accurate? I was just listing pokemon that MAY be broken under infinite Rain with Swift Swim.
You said "probably", which implies that it was accurate. If your argument is that they are just bans that might happen, then we're on the same page.
Raikaria said:As I said before, Swift Swimmers are broken under Drizzle. Swift Swimmers do not cause Drizzle. Blaziken is broken with Speed Boost, however, another pokemon does not provide Speed Boost for Blaziken. Therefor, Blaziken is the broken party. Banning Speed Boost on Blaziken is totally different from banning DrizzleToad and SS Kingdra being used in tandem, because Speed Boost is part of Blaziken, Infinite Rain is NOT part of Kingdra.
There is no single broken party with Swift Swim and Drizzle. Neither is broken without the other, IMO.
Infinite rain may not be part of the Swift Swim users, but as it currently stands, it's a part of the game, like any other factor.
Last gen, Salamence was banned. It could not use Stealth Rock, but Stealth Rock's damage against its counters surely contributed to it being broken. Would Salamence have been broken if Stealth Rock was not permitted? I'm not sure; I wasn't active on Smogon at the time those matters were being decided. Let's assume it was. Would that be a reason not to ban Salamence? It's the same story with Drizzle.
Also, Manaphy is only known to be broken with Drizzle, and yet it was banned entirely.
Raikaria said:As for why I don't think banning Drizzle is the answer:
- Makes Rain Stall unviable
- Makes Rain Offense Unviable
- Will almost certainly lead to a ban of Drought, and possibly even Sand Stream [Hail sucks]
No objections.
Raikaria said:Banning Kingdra and co is not the answer because:
- Some of the pokemon, such as Ludicolo, who are not broken of their own accord, have uses in other teams [Rain Stall] and teirs. Blaziken was broken of his own accord, however, so do not bring up Blaze Blaziken against this, as the two situations are not the same.
- Could lead to multiple bans of pokemon not even OU worthy under normal circumstances [Huntail? Carracosta, Omastar]
- Will slow down the suspect process, by repeatedly testing the same types of pokemon again, just the teir below them.
Pokemon are rarely broken in isolation. Unless a team consisting only of Blaziken was broken, Blaziken is not broken of his own accord. He's broken on the accord of himself and reasonable team support, just like Ludicolo.
"Normal circumstances" are irrelevant. If a Pokemon is broken, it's broken, regardless of what tier it might otherwise be in.
We don't have to slow down the testing process if we test them on the Suspect ladder. Besides, look at how multifaceted this disagreement is. No matter what, we aren't going to reach a good solution without slowing down and reconsidering things.
Raikaria said:Banning Swift Swim is not the answer because:
- Banning Swift Swim would have to lead to a blanket ban on all equivilent abilities. As the rain can't be the broken party, otherwise, Drizzle would have been banned, and the pokemon cannot be the broken party, as otherwise, they would be banned. Therefor, an ability that doubles speed is broken, so Sand Rush and Chlorophill are broken.
No objections.
Raikaria said:A Kingdra + Drizzle Ban... eh, I don't like the idea, but, it would work. You'd have to extend it to Kabutops though... and what about Ludicolo, who's used on Rain Stall and Swift Swim abuse?
How about Garchomp + Sand Stream?
Volcarona or Venusaur + Drought?
Notice the floodgate?
Kingdra was mentioned as an example to cut it down to one Pokemon. I indeed advocate for bans of Kabutops + Drizzle and Ludicolo + Drizzle, as well. I'm aware of the potential alternative applications of the latter, but they're no more relevant than the potential alternatives of Blaze Blaziken.
And yes, it would also apply to any other Swift Swim abusers. If Omastar and Gorebyss turn out to also become broken with Swift Swim + Drizzle, then I will advocate for Omastar + Drizzle and Gorebyss + Drizzle. On a related note, I also believe that Manaphy + Drizzle should be tested. In fact, the idea of that ban was what originally lead me to this matter.
I don't support a ban of Garchomp + Sand Stream. Instead, I've been advocating for bans on Sand Veil + Sand Stream and Snow Cloak + Snow Warning.
But that is where the doors slam shut, and no floodgates are opened. For that is the extent to which there is actually a good reason to ban something for weather-related reasons, whether for brokenness or uncompetitiveness. No Pokemon or ability has been indicated to be either broken or uncompetitive when and only when combined with Drought. We should consider such bans to be an option, but they should still only be used when there is something to ban. The fact that we can ban certain things under that rule does not mean that we can or should ban everything under that rule. Not everything warrants a ban.