• Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!

[Standard] NOC Desktop Dungeons Mafia GAME OVER

Yeti said:
hey genius
making one tl;dr doesn't qualify as regular contributions

you stand out to me as not really doing much or anything significant except voting and wanting things to end

don't have an opinion eh?? now why is that? because your mafia buds determine your opinion? perhaps they aren't on right now to tell you what your opinion should be. EVERY villager in this game should be formulating their own opinions and reading peoples' posts. the fact you're so disinclined to state or hold one (note how that was a bone of contention with isaac who claimed he had no choice but to bandwagon) lends you no credibility as a (useful) villager.

voting me as well eh? a rather defensive move on your end. rather than unvote or leave your vote, a scummy move was certainly to vote the person attempting to get you to speak up or vote someone else under heavy suspicion.

note how at no point did I say you were actually mafia or that I felt very strongly you were scum, rather, I pointed out how your actions could easily be construed as scummy. and here you go voting me because you, like isaac, apparently have no choice in the matter? you feel like you have to?? maybe one of your mafia mates is on and told you it was the best idea???

if you had bothered to read the thread you'd know that voting and insinuating you have little to no control over your own vote is likely not a wise decision. which leads me to believe you are indeed a scum following other villagers' examples, unfortunately, isaac acted quite poorly to avoid suspicion.

child please. if you have no opinion on who is scum you should not be voting if you're not going to try to scumhunt someone out (like I am doing with you). rather you just look suspect now.
Click to expand...
As I have apparently not made this clear enough, there is so little evidence right now that votes become based heavily on suspicion. My vote was based out of the fact that you ignored what I had written, voted me with little to no reasoning, and I'm just wholly not good at this game. Also, it is natural behavior to feel confronted when one votes for you, hence my vehement defense. It is DAY 2, so the fact that I have not done a remarkable amount, discussion-wise is hardly a significant red flag for mafia. Also, explaining every single one of my actions AS IF I was mafia is not an argument for the fact that I am scum. The same could be said of anyone, and you are not providing much evidence of any kind. Perhaps your out-of-the-blue vote for me with flawed reasoning was suggested by our "mafia buddies" as I had an equal vote count to one of them at that point. Now while you could have easily been a perfectly innocent villy in voting as such, that is a possibility. That alone does not make you mafia.

I would again cite my lack of experience for much of my actions in this game. READ MY POST. I explained this in great detail.
I'm assuming the reason for said suspicion is my trend of bandwagoning My reasons for bandwagoning are as numerous as they are innocent, and I'll gladly explain them to you. First off, in the case of Gallade, as I will explain further in response to billy, there was little reason to oppose the majority, as my dissent would do nothing to prevent the lynch and I was getting pretty bored of the constant hysteria arising out of every word anybody spoke, as there was so little evidence and only a couple posts from which to draw our conclusions. secondly, there was little evidence to the contrary in either the case of polelover or Gallade, and not a great deal higher likelihood that an alternative lynch would provokemore desirable results. Thus, I bandwagoned. Thirdly, as I have made clear earlier, I am the epitome of a mafia noob. Thus, I am not as adept at discerning the meaning behind the posts of all these people as are US and even Fate, both who seem far mopre knowledgeable than I know myself to be in regards to the game we are playing, so I am forced to somewhat rely on them to provide convincing arguments for the lynch of a person, while if I see them making a groundless claim I will surely not support it. My fourth and final reason I will be explaining in this post also is derived from my new-ness to this game as a whole. As this is literally my first game, I have been trying to avoid being lynched early on, for I really want to be able to experience a full game. In that same vein, I usually tend to respond quickly when my name is spoken, as well as avoid invoking on large campaigns against a suspect of my own, especially when I essentially have no real suspects and have to rely on the deep analysis of simple posts to find my evidence. I would hate to have two straight villy lynches in a row, and I hope my absolute lack of mafia skill will not further doom the village in this game by creating yet another useless lynch.
Click to expand...
Respond to that, please.
 
dude you seem to be missing where it is incredibly obnoxious (and difficult) to read 20+ lines with no spacing on a computer screen.
why do you think the PARAGRAPH exists? you have an enter key: learn to love it. obsess over it. fetishize it.......... anything to stop the walls ;p;

i voted you to get you to talk because obviously you weren't very inclined to post your thoughts otherwise. it tends to work on new mafia players or idiots (j-man...).
the others i will deal with later, or let other users draw them out.

maybe if you had been 1-2 votes from having majority on yourself i can see you getting testy someone put a vote on you but you must not even be halfway there and i wanted to see some posts. absolutely no reason to go voting me except being overly defensive about any votes and confrontational/deflective. should've taken notes from my bg isaac here, don't vote without intention.

i was generous and read your tl;dr
basically you make a bunch of excuses for why your opinion/vote don't actually count and you're just another number on the way to majority. plus apparently because you are new you have nothing to contribute?? us experienced players know how each other plays but you new players need to make yourselves known, or garner our suspicions for being too quiet. regardless of your experience you should be able to read prior NOC games or at least look at what you find suspicious or even agree with experienced players' analysis.

but no, apparently you exist to end the day and go along for the ride, following experienced players' votes and resisting forming your own opinion.
 
Yeti said:
dude you seem to be missing where it is incredibly obnoxious (and difficult) to read 20+ lines with no spacing on a computer screen.
why do you think the PARAGRAPH exists? you have an enter key: learn to love it. obsess over it. fetishize it.......... anything to stop the walls ;p;

i voted you to get you to talk because obviously you weren't very inclined to post your thoughts otherwise. it tends to work on new mafia players or idiots (j-man...).
the others i will deal with later, or let other users draw them out.

maybe if you had been 1-2 votes from having majority on yourself i can see you getting testy someone put a vote on you but you must not even be halfway there and i wanted to see some posts. absolutely no reason to go voting me except being overly defensive about any votes and confrontational/deflective. should've taken notes from my bg isaac here, don't vote without intention.

i was generous and read your tl;dr
basically you make a bunch of excuses for why your opinion/vote don't actually count and you're just another number on the way to majority. plus apparently because you are new you have nothing to contribute?? us experienced players know how each other plays but you new players need to make yourselves known, or garner our suspicions for being too quiet. regardless of your experience you should be able to read prior NOC games or at least look at what you find suspicious or even agree with experienced players' analysis.

but no, apparently you exist to end the day and go along for the ride, following experienced players' votes and resisting forming your own opinion.
Click to expand...
WEll, first off, I'm glad you actually read my post. Secondly, while I most certainly bwed on Gallade I most certainly do not plan on doing so. I get overly defensive because I really don't want to get lynched so soon in my first mafia game. Also, I think more people need to start speaking and outlining their cases or there is little hope for discussion. I've outlined mine, so perhaps the other possible lynch targets would like to explain themselves as well. I'll be perfectly honest I'm doing my best to contribute but I'm struggling. As of now the only real suspects I can think of are polelover or rickheg, since they appear to be bandwagoning as well and are clearly more experienced than myself, so I feel I must
Unvote
Vote: rickheg
as his only reasoning for voting J-man was
rickheg said:
Judging by everyone else's posts, J-Man is acting outside of his usual behavior by not reacting. I'm not voting for him yet, because I want to see if he responds to any of this soon.
Click to expand...
I doubt you're mafia, as you're bringing a great deal of attention to yourself and I can't deny the suspiscious quality of my behavior.
 
So, it looks like Yeti v masterful has more-or-less resolved itself, so we need more stuff to get into heated discussions/arguments about. Oddly enough, I've felt inspired to try my hand at this scumhunting business, or whatever it's called.

I've realized that a certain someone, who was very much active Day One and as far as I remember did not post anything in the thread pertaining to a possible absence today (though of course I could very easily be wrong, as I didn't read scour every page). This is rather uncharacteristic, and I think most people would agree.

Therefore, Vote: UncleSam

I don't particularly think you're scum, I'm just curious as to why such a vocal user has been silent for nearly two days. Voting you just seems to be the standard means of acquiring an answer.
 
i find him suspicious and am definitely not convinced he is a villy but i am content to not lynch him IF he keeps his activity up and contributes, also i am open to other options.
not to mention i don't want to be unclesam 2.0 and get into a multi-post argument with an inexperienced villy then force a lynch on him, only for him to turn out to be vanilla. there is no time for such nonsense.

we do have silent unclesam over here................. !
 
Yeti said:
it tends to work on new mafia players or idiots (j-man...).
the others i will deal with later, or let other users draw them out.
Click to expand...

Ok, that was seriously uncalled for

Vote: Yeti

Unless there is a clear scum to vote for, this is how i will express my displeasure in this characterless attack of me.

You know, it's hard to change your character when there are jerks out there who are determined to keep a label stuck on you.
 
bring%20it.jpg
 
Spiffy said:
unvote

Vote: Da Letter El

dalettertroll

And J-Man shut up you did the same thing to me that Yeti is doing to you!!!!!!!!!!!
Click to expand...

...what, i used you as an example of undesirable behavior? You're very late because i already expressed dislike of both bm's and yeti's behavior and expressed interest in getting back in the game. What's there to shut up about?
 
i suppose i'll help out

unvote
Vote: DLE

though somehow i feel he'll end up just being one of the group of people that weren't talking in this day long squabble amongst a certain group of people... meh whatever.
 
Votecount
masterful (1): polelover44
rickheg (4): Da Letter El, Uncle Sam, DetroitLolcat, masterful
Fangren (1): Isaac 2.0
Acklow (1): Fatecrashers
Uncle Sam (1): Fangren
Da Letter El (3): Spiffy, billymills, J-man


With 17 alive, it is 9 to lynch.

Ditto said:
I am confused. Some people are showing up twice on this. J-man (for Isaac and billy), Spiffy (for polelover and me), and HSA (for J-man and me).
Click to expand...
My mistake - some of the unvotes were not accounted for, though the votes that came after them were. That votecount has been fixed.

Don't hesitate to call me out on mistakes in my votecount! Nobody's perfect, after all.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top