• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

The Everything NFL Thread: 2011-2012 Season (plus free agency I guess)

Status
Not open for further replies.
My apologies if I missed that in the moment DM. I just think that we need to wait to see if the "other foot drops for" a team like the Bills or Lions before putting them over a select few teams who are also playing smash mouth football and have more extensive recent success. I would rank teams something like Packers > Saints > Ravens > Bills > Patriots > Texans > Lions > Jets as my list of teams who have a reasonable shot at the Super Bowl, and of course that could significantly change. Packers/Saints/Ravens are the three I really believe in, with Bills/Texans as the most exciting outsiders to that group for me.

Valkyries, the Packers have the #1 rushing defense, and even if passing is obviously more important, controlling your opponent's rushing game so extremely is going to produce good results. I can understand why people think they have not been the most dominant team in the NFL, but I think that they excel in controlling a game enough to come away with the win. The points allowed should hopefully become a little normalized, but we will see. The Falcons give up more points than the Packers, so I do not see why the Falcons would be the ones doing the lighting up.
 
CaptKirby said:
Valkyries, the Packers have the #1 rushing defense, and even if passing is obviously more important, controlling your opponent's rushing game so extremely is going to produce good results. I can understand why people think they have not been the most dominant team in the NFL, but I think that they excel in controlling a game enough to come away with the win. The points allowed should hopefully become a little normalized, but we will see. The Falcons give up more points than the Packers, so I do not see why the Falcons would be the ones doing the lighting up.

Oh no, don't get me wrong, I certainly agree that they do dominate and dominate hard. I'm just saying they aren't THE dominant team. What you have to remember is that while the pack is #1 against the run, they also are the second worst team against the pass. While Michael Turner may not be able to get the ball rolling for the Atlanta Offense, the Falcons are no slouches on the pass, and there will be a lighting up of that hurting Pack defense next weekend, and it'll blemish the appearance of the "number one team in the league."

I'm not saying the Falcons will blow them out though, just that it'll be a shootout, and it takes a herculean effort to win a shootout on the road, so Atlanta will take it.
 
Killah said:
CK, might I ask why you have the Jets placed so high? It took a late punt block + 2 Romo turnovers to beat Dallas at home, and their defense got thrashed in Oakland on Sunday. Shonn Greene is awful (3.3 yards per carry), and Sanchez is hardly average. The defense has looked good facing the pass on paper, but in reality the only good QB they've faced (Romo) lit them up most of the game.
Because CK can't follow his own logic and just types the bullshit that comes off his head.

Jets pass defense has been and still is vastly overrated. As the Patriots have been figuring out the last couple weeks, No Pass Rush = Defense gonna get shredded.

The only reason the Jets aren't near the bottom of the league in pass defense so far is because they got to play Luke McCown for 3 quarters.
 
Killah said:
Valkyries, I'm assuming the only Falcons game you've seen has been the Eagles game. The entire team has looked awful against Chicago and Tampa Bay, and were gifted with a short field for much of the Eagles game. They are worse than the team they were in the playoffs last year, and while that game might have been somewhat of an aberration I suspect a blowout in two weeks nonetheless.

Uhhhh, if by worse than the team last year, you mean exactly the same team, then yes, I agree with you. The Falcons last year were always shaky at home, but consistently winning, and a lucky road team. That's all. But forgetting all of that, football is about match-ups of the here and now, and not about what you've done in the past against x-team during x-week. While the past is a good barometer of the strengths and weaknesses of a team, the only thing that matters on Sunday are the two teams playing.

That said, the Packers defense has shown to be consistently weak to the pass. This is what is indicated by the past. Meanwhile, the Falcons in the past, have had a successful and sometimes prolific offense, ESPECIALLY WHEN AT HOME. What this means is that despite the fact that the Packers are destroying, and generally tearing up the NFC left and right, allowing few points, and scoring big every game... they will probably face a challenge in two weeks.
 
Well, Matt Ryan has been having some problems this year. He certainly has a nice time at home though.

Killah, I give credence to a team who has a proven track record within the last few years. Jets have earned that and are sitting at 2-1, even if their one thrashing was not the greatest test ever. The Titans have the best points defense outside of the Ravens, and they gave up 14 points to the Jaguars, so the Jets in that game did show they still have the explosive defense potential to matter in the playoffs.

HeroMasaki, I am not sure why you are being so insulting and especially not why you are being so hateful here. I am extremely consistent, I am not sorry at all that you have a fucking problem with me being willing to make a lot of analysis and making a lot of claims because I am not a fucking coward. I do not know what it is about sports that makes everyone have to act so fucking overreactionary; all I am doing is posting some analysis from people who might not be watching things like Red Zone and be seeing as many games. Only a few teams have a shot at winning the Super Bowl, plenty have a shot at having a good record. I put the Lions and Jets last because they are teams with high potential and possibly fatal flaws, any teams I left off have actually fatal flaws in my opinion.
 
Well looks like Colts are going with Dan Orlovsky now at QB...dunno if he can do much worse than Collins has so far. Not that it's entirely Collins' fault, he was all set and retired, but Colts somehow got him out of retirement and he only had what, a week or 2 to try cramming everything in for an offense that Manning has essentially ran himself for the past many years. Personally I don't think they can do much worse with Painter at this point, he's been with the team and has a basic ideal of what happens at least, unlike Collins and now Orlovsky, but I suppose if Collins could potentially be out with his concussion, not bad to have another QB waiting as well (and Painter does little else to inspire that he's the future anyways). Either way, it's a lost season for the Colts if Manning isn't back till next year, good time to play in the Luck sweepstakes I suppose, nothing like having a rookie stud to build up behind Manning's last few good years.
 
HeroMasaki said:
Because CK can't follow his own logic and just types the bullshit that comes off his head.

Jets pass defense has been and still is vastly overrated. As the Patriots have been figuring out the last couple weeks, No Pass Rush = Defense gonna get shredded.

The only reason the Jets aren't near the bottom of the league in pass defense so far is because they got to play Luke McCown for 3 quarters.

HA... HAHAHA... Overrated Pass Defense...

Darrelle Revis averaged a 30% completion rate last year when he was thrown to. Clearly he's bad and overrated. Antonio Cromartie had 44% completion rate. He as well, is also bad and overrated.

Those two guys are the Pass Defense, and they are the real deal. If you'll remember, the Raiders won their game against the Jets on 171 yards, and 9 yards a carry from Darren McFadden, not from a "collapsing" pass defense. While I would agree that they're numbers are inflated due to Luke McCown, they aren't inflated by all that much.
 
Blindy McBlind said:
Texans have a shot at the Super Bowl? *sniff* I think I'd cry if they won the Super Bowl. Andre Johnson deserves that damn ring!

Umm wait till you guys actually make a playoffs before you get too excited champ. As a Ravens fan I still like the Texans a fair bit but we're talking about one of the more historically choke-worthy teams of the last decade. Then again without Kenny Brit blowing the top off the defenses for the Titans the division should be an absolute cakewalk for the Texans.
 
Just want to say that when a team has a dominant run defense like the packers have, their pass defense is inevitably going to be bad. Why? Because teams stop trying to run against them. Of course your pass defense is going to be bad when the opposing QB is throwing 45-50 balls a game. The Packers pass D is better than you give it credit for, teams have just been so pass happy against them. Same thing happened to the Steelers last year, and they went all the way to the Super Bowl. If you want a better measure of how good a team's pass defense is, look at their red zone defense, opposing passer ratings or completion percentages, or passing TDs allowed. The NFL defense rankings only go by yards allowed by default, so you can't really judge it that way only.

Also the Jets are never going to be a Super Bowl contender with Sanchez. I'm sorry, the guy just isn't good enough. He's had flashes here and there and he's gotten better at taking care of the ball, but he is just incapable of carrying the team with the game on the line.
 
WaterBomb said:
Just want to say that when a team has a dominant run defense like the packers have, their pass defense is inevitably going to be bad. Why? Because teams stop trying to run against them. Of course your pass defense is going to be bad when the opposing QB is throwing 45-50 balls a game. The Packers pass D is better than you give it credit for, teams have just been so pass happy against them. Same thing happened to the Steelers last year, and they went all the way to the Super Bowl. If you want a better measure of how good a team's pass defense is, look at their red zone defense, opposing passer ratings or completion percentages, or passing TDs allowed. The NFL defense rankings only go by yards allowed by default, so you can't really judge it that way only.

Even if they are thrown to more often, they're still giving up 8.7 yards on every pass play. The Patriots have been thrown at just as often and allow 9 yards a play. Are you going to tell me that the Packers secondary is good and the Patriots isn't? Hell no, they're performing exactly the same, and when you compare it to the Oakland Raiders, who have been thrown at the most, they allow only 6.9 yards on average, making them the 8th best defense against the pass on average. The Packers Pass Defense is doing piss poor, and no excuses can really be made for it.

P.S. Ochocinco hasn't tweeted for 3 days straight. Brace for impact. I feel it coming.
 
The Falcons are a worse team than last year because their offensive line has significantly regressed (Matt Ryan has been sacked 13 times in 3 games; last season he was sacked 23 times in 16 games plus 5 times against the Packers in the playoffs) and their special teams is simply horrid (Bosher is averaging 36 yards per punt and can't get the ball into the endzone on kickoffs). The interior defensive line has been getting mauled without Babineaux, Roddy White is tied for the league lead in drops, and "Matty Ice" looks terrified in the pocket on every passing down. Even if the Packers pass defense is bad, Ryan can't do much damage if he doesn't get much time in the pocket, and the defense can't slow Rodgers let alone stop him.

I might be exaggerating a tad, but as someone who's seen all three Falcons game this year I can say that we are lucky to be 1-2, lucky we didn't get lit up in Tampa, lucky that Vick got hurt, and will be lucky if Ryan makes it another month without being injured. They still have plenty of time to turn it around, but I have yet to see anything that would indicate that they will be able to. Home field advantage has been a gift for the Falcons in the past, but for a team that is outmatched at almost every position I don't see it helping enough.

Or they could get lucky again, I guess that's why they play the game!
 
TheValkyries said:
Antonio Cromartie had 44% completion rate. He as well, is also bad and overrated.
yeah with all the pass interferences that completion rate goes up to 60%

and no the raiders didnt win solely because of mcfadden (i am the #1 mcfadden fan in the entire world), they won because cromartie messed up like 6 times defending and fumbled a kickoff which essentially ended the game
 
ElPEO.png


So I was trying to figure out the best RBs (and just including WRs since they were interspersed) of all time, and I really think I have to go with:
#1 Barry Sanders
#2 Jim Brown
#3 LaDainian Tomlinson
#4 Marshall Faulk
#5 Terrell Davis (maybe the best of all time, but you have to adjust for career totals at least a little)
#6 Priest Holmes (despite an incredibly short career managed to get an ungodly 86 touchdowns and put up three 2000+ yard years, catching better than LT but worse than Faulk)
#7 Emmitt Smith

People who put Smith #1 Payton #2 just do not care about interpreting statistics, just looking at totals.

Also I have no idea what to think about Shaun Alexander. Just a product of an offensive line? I mean, by sheer statistics he belongs at #8...but sheesh.
 
The fact that Smith was only great during the Cowboys Super Bowl years when the team had the most talent surrounding him means I will always keep him as low as possible. Walter Payton being the biggest fumbler of any of these guys should absolutely be remembered. He is like 20 ahead of Emmitt, who is at least 10 more ahead of anyone else in this chart. Priest Holmes got nearly as many touchdowns with 1/5th the fumbles, for instance, and LaDainian Tomlinson and Marshall Faulk have done an even better job on that count. I wanted to put Payton higher for his Super Bowl year, but in the end I just decided it was not really relevant.
 
Really enjoying the NFL at the moment. Still trying to get into it a little, being British, I haven't grown up with it, so I'm still getting used to the whole idea. I really like the tactical side of the game!
 
Emmitt's Career is more of a testament to his longevity than actual ability so #7 does sound about right.

LT at 3? A bit high IMO

Also, interesting to note where AP will rank among these backs when its all said and done.

And if we're gonna call Shaun Alexander a product of his O-Line then Terrell Davis should also be penalized
 
Imran said:
Really enjoying the NFL at the moment. Still trying to get into it a little, being British, I haven't grown up with it, so I'm still getting used to the whole idea. I really like the tactical side of the game!

Don't worry, keep watching and reading people's analysis of the game. It's more complicated than most fans will admit, and the more you know the less you actually do know. But it's not necessarily as enigmatic as baseball, for instance.

Pick a favorite team and watch them. I'd also recommend watching the "good" games every week (the ones that feature the best teams) to get a better take on the actual game. Feel free to ask questions here as well.
 
Imran, if you are watching on internet or have the channel somehow (doubtful but hey) I would recommend watching Red Zone, at least during commercials for a game that you are already watching. It is highly entertaining, the only thing I dislike about it is when they flash to an obviously terrible game (like Dolphins this last week..or the week before that). Turn off bad games :@

LT at 3 is not too high...he dominated touchdowns and he dominated yards. For the first eight years of his career he got 1900 yards from scrimmage a year, and a single season of 1900 yards is a career year for most players. Unless he plays another 3-4 seasons, his season/game averages should not fall enough to push him lower, and even if he does he would probably only fall past Faulk.
 
I don't think there's a compelling argument on this planet to justify putting ANY RB in history ahead of Barry Sanders. Not even Jim Brown. I've been getting into watching older footage lately, and when you watch Barry run it's just out of this world. He is so noticeably far ahead of any other RB you could watch in terms of skill.

Anyway hoping Pittsburgh gets their O Line crap in order quickly, before the season gets away from them. I doubt they can make another super bowl run but hey, anything's possible?
 
CK/WB: how much footage have either of you gotten to watch of Jim Brown? Sanders played when we were kids, so we got to watch him, but talk to any grown man who got to see Brown play and he will instantly regress to the mental state of a preteen while describing what Brown did. I don't know how you placed Sanders above Brown based on those statistics when Brown is in the top 3 in EVERY SINGLE CATEGORY.

I do not believe any of us can rank the "greatest RBs of all time" because we don't have the proper frames of reference to grade them all. It makes for a fun argument, but it's ultimately silly and pointless. At best, you could make an "Elite RB" group and say who belongs there, guys like Brown/Sanders/Smith/Faulk/Payton/etc. Ranking is arbitrary.
 
barry sanders quit because the lions management were dicks, his talent cannot be measured in career statistics, only the years he played

i dont rly care about this argument/discussion but i hate the lions for destroying barry sanders

haha i hate myself sometimes

so after looking up actual statistics.. barry sanders retires one year after his best season, was still healthy averaging 6ypc at age 30 and only 1-2 seasons away from the all time rushing record. for some reason i thought he retired much earlier than that.

anyway to actually discuss the matter at hand like i said i would not. in this case ranking is a little arbitrary but i applaud ck for attempting to logically place the careers of 10~ running backs into perspective. very interesting stats
 
Jim Brown got 126 of his team's 337 TDs, Sanders got 109 of 348 in an era more geared toward passing without ever being a running back who really got touchdowns. His one injury (11 games played) he only got 3 TD, which is fluky. Brown was on a perennial playoff winner, the Lions were perennial losers with Sanders as the only bright spot. Finally, I always personally give a bit of bias to players who play in the modern era because they play against bigger, tougher competition and games have more complexity to them now. That has a flip side, like how there is so much more receiving to be had that guys like LT/Faulk almost have an unfair "advantage" over their predecessors, but for Sanders v Brown I just have to give the #1 spot to the guy who played against modern supertruck competition instead of the guy who played against skinny opponents.

I introduced elements to make it less arbitrary (mostly because Priest Holmes is the coolest motherfucking running back of all time). We can rank the best RBs, it is easy - Sanders, Brown, LT, and Faulk are the best four :@ If you want to call it arbitrary to rank those, then okay, but even then Sanders+Brown are #1 & #2 and LT and Faulk are #3 & #4..there are no real grounds to put anyone else past. Especially not Smith or Payton, who statistics do not support at all. Past that it gets a bit more esotertic, but putting these guys at top is the opposite of arbitrary, it is factual. If you want to call Davis/Holmes after that arbitrary, go nuts. (Holmes had three straight 2000+ seasons...not many players could have matched that before the ridiculous passing era we are getting into now). LT is actually hurting himself a bit by not retiring, a la Jerry Rice syndrome.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top