So basically, kHz is saying that hydrattler is clean?
I'm honestly not sure. Ditto may have assumed that Maxim was going to post later since he had said so just before hand. Actually I think it's more suspicious that Maxim said he was going to post later but then never does. It's like he says he will post to get himself off the hook then disappeared once the pressure was off.
Anyway, I think EP is very suspicious for a few reasons:
Engineer Pikachu said:
Considering the fact that there are 20 players in this game, there are probably five to six mafia members. This mafia had 17 players and five mafia. By lynching, we have approximately a 31-37% chance of catching a mafia; not exactly favorable odds.
Here EP pretty much advocates not lynching until we get a majority. Bad idea, I think not?
Engineer Pikachu said:
Again, I didn't post because I didn't really have an opinion. If I'm going to get called out for not posting, and then get called out again for posting something "useless" because I don't have an opinion, it's kind of a catch-22, isn't it?
If you're going to force me to vote for someone, though, I guess lynch TalkingLion? His D1 vote change was quite suspicious and no villager would see a need to change his vote.
This was the 299th post in the thread. So after all that time, EP never had a read on anyone. Seems to me like he wants to blend in. And when he does vote someone, he just hops on the nearest bandwagon and regurgitates the reasoning given
here,
here,
here and
here. IIoA I believe it's called.
Engineer Pikachu said:
Actually, this is a pretty good point. His posts don't make much sense logically. See here, second paragraph and here.
More IIoA.
And then we have his read list:
Engineer Pikachu said:
Paperblade - Generally helpful?
Mithril - Kind of confusing; I don't really know what to think of him.
Ditto - Was extremely helpful in D1; hasn't been as helpful since, but is still present and a discussion sparker.
auramaster - Haven't really seen him post.
Flamestrike - Posting more lately; seems to be being helpful.
empoof - Great posts.
Metal Bagon - Complex role that seems unlikely to be faked.
Orcinus Duo - Starting a bandwagon on mafia D1 would make it seem like he's not mafia.
nEsp - No clue.
khz - See above.
Hydrattler - Maxim didn't really post much, so I guess Hydrattler gets a clean slate.
Aura Guardian - His posts are kind of confusing, but since he claimed and there's been no counterclaim so far, I guess he's village?
pokémaniac 212 - See nEsp.
New World Order - See AG.
Which is virtually a copypasta of everyone else's read list.
Then there's when he posts false evidence against me. OD deals with that above, no need for me to repeat it.
All in all, EP sounds like scum trying to fly under the radar. Lynch Engineer Pikachu