FrostFire said:Lol, Ho-Oh is Fire/Flying with 90 base speed, and it's a bloody God. Sorry, that just popped in to my mind when I read your post, SmashBrosBrawl.
But yeah, there is a reason why very few pokemon succeed with a Stealth Rock weakness, and that's because it's an amazing move that lots of things get, it's on every team, easy to set up, and Spinning them away is comparatively difficult. You can't say that Gyarados has this amazing bulk to take stuff on, when it's weak to SR, takes Sand damage, and has no reliable recovery. What's more, if you're using Substitute, that's going to eat away at your health too. I think somebody posted above about how Gyarados can simply 'wear down' it's checks or counters, via Substitute; but this is kind of a bad point. If you're using Sub, then your sacrificing 25% of your HP, and this is making the generous assumption that SR won't be on the field. So, whilst Gyarados is attempting to 'wear down' it's own checks and counters, Gyarados gets worn down itself very quickly. This is bad, because Gyarados is slow, so it needs to rely on it's bulk to set up and sweep. But it has no reliable recovery. Do you see what I'm getting at? I actually think Gyarados could have stayed in the now non-existent A- tier; it just doesn't fit in A.
Notes about Volcarona and Dragonite: I would rather use either of these over Gyarados generally speaking, for a few different reasons. Volc has higher speed to begin with, but also gets a Special Defense boost from Quiver Dance and Roost, allowing it to go the bulky route effectively. Dragonite is kinda slow like Gyarados, but it has Multiscale and Roost, both of which are a pretty big deal if you're doing a bulky DD set. Offensive DD is a bit different (I actually don't like it as much, as Sandstorm often negates Multiscale), but it hits like a nuke with Outrage that's for sure. Oh, that was the other thing; Gyarados lacks a really powerful STAB to sweep/ nuke stuff with; Waterfall is significantly weaker than the likes of Outrage, Close Combat, Fire Blast, Hydro Pump etc.
So yeah. Gyarados is cool and all, and it isn't explicitly bad, but I've honestly never had trouble with it when facing it on the ladder. Terrakion? Scary. Keldeo? Scary. Breloom? Scary.
Gyarados? Ehhhhh... Could be worse.
I'm sorry, but this entire post is wrong on so many levels it's not even funny. Where on earth are you getting this information from? Very few Pokemon with a SR weakness succeed in this metagame? So you're telling me that Thundurus-T, Kyurem-B, Tornadus, Dragonite, Salamence, Gyarados, and even Volcarona to an extent are a very few Pokemon that can succeed with a SR weakness? Ironically, all of these things I just listed are top tier threats and or are one of the most dangerous sweepers in the metagame, and although they don't like taking SR damage, they still manage to succeed just fine. Just because something is weak to SR, doesn't mean that it's already extremely hindered. Sure, Volcarona's x4 weakness to it really hurts its effectiveness, but it still manages to be one of the most dangerous Pokemon in the tier. Next off, have you ever actually used Gyarados or are you just theorymoning? You make it sound like it's just some outclassed rain sweeper that only finds its niche as an okay rain sweeper, when in fact it's quite the opposite. You're automatically shutting it down because of its below average speed and weak STABs, but ironically, not many Pokemon in the tier can resist both of its STAB combinations, and coming off of 125 base Attack and at +1 or +2 with rain factored in, Gyarados hits just as hard if not harder then Dragonite. Honestly, Gyarados doesn't really mind SR as much as Dragonite for example, because unlike Dragonite or Volcarona, it isn't threatened by a wide variety of common attacks. Rotom-W is by no means uncommon, but they don't normally run T-bolt and Volt Switch, and Gyarados can easily play around Volt Switch. Thundurus-T is demolished by a rain boosted Waterfall. Gyarados isn't weak to any sort of priority, in fact it resist Mach Punch and Bullet Punch. Honestly though, all of your assumptions with Gyarados' weak STABs and SR weakness are all obviously paper assumptions, because in battle, none of these factors really bother it too much. It's slow, but Dragon Dance fixes that problem, and it's easy for it to setup a Dragon Dance on most of the metagame. Gyarados is by no means "an almost explicitly bad" Pokemon. Maybe you should try it out in battle sometime? If you have, and all you can really say is that Gyarados is meh, then you're clearly doing something wrong.
Gyarados? Ehhhhh... Could be worse.
Ehhh...it couldn't be much better.