PKMN1 said:Actually, I remember Smogon's UNIVERSITY's (important word here) ENTIRE purpose was to help new players into competitive Pokemon gaming. The name seems redundant now....
"Smogon is the most comprehensive and accurate online resource for competitive Pokémon battling. We offer articles and advice via our community forums to help fans of the game compete at every level, while honing their skills in every aspect of competitive Pokémon from team building to battling tactics."
Right at the beginning of the About page, it is not very comprehensive anymore, nor is it catering to fans of pokemon, just to their own people. It is also NOT helping in EVERY aspect of competitive battling.
Zyphex said:Then were can we go? Smogon is the the only in-depth competitive battling guide I've seen, and other sites tend to use the same meta-games, as far as I know.
You can probably get help with anything by asking the right people, but every decision we make here is based around our own metagames. Smogon is the most in-depth competitive site out there, and while other have their own tiers, they end up very similar to ours more often than not because we have such an in-depth testing process for every decision we make. If you come here looking for competitive advice but you don't have Smogon's tiers in mind, then what system are you using? One you made up? Because Nintendo's ruleset is
not that of a competitive metagame, if that's what you're thinking.
But both of you are missing the point. We have no obligation to change our metagame for people who have no interest in playing our tiers in the first place.
Metal Sonic said:Now notice that XY is already a very different metagame anyway. What's with your example of Landorus-T countering Terrakion: that's a BW example in the BW metagame. It doesn't even hold water when you consider new threats, checks, counters, et cetera in XY. If you change the metagame at the start and set it in stone, you will not feel the difference because that is how it is.
I wish I didn't have to keep saying this, but stop focusing so much on the particulars of my examples. You get so carried away with the examples that you miss the underlying point. Compared to level 100, Pokemon at level 50 will have to invest even more in bulk just so that they can keep checking the things they used to check, which weakens their overall potential since it takes investment away from other areas.
We're not changing from LV 100 to 50 in the middle of the XY metagame. We're not introducing a power creep: there won't be a creep if there isn't anything to base it off in the first place.
That's like saying starting the generation with all Ubers unbanned isn't a power creep because you started that way. Of course it isn't a power creep from the beginning if that
was the beginning, but it is a power creep from the status quo. The status quo right now is level 100, and changing that to level 50 does introduce a power creep that was not there to begin with.
Therefore, Reducing levels from 100 to 50 won't actually hurt the metagame, and I feel that your arguments of "power creep" and "new speed tiers" are fallacious.
Push aside the arguments about the power creep and such if you want, but they still exist. Meanwhile, I've seen no reason as to why we should drop to level 50 besides adhering to some Wi-Fi rule that's optional to begin with.